Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

[TAFKAP]

can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...

What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?

not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh

6'1 200 would be a small linebacker

You could have saved us the time by saying, "I think this is a bad comparison because they are essentially already equal" to which no that is not correct and your point, which I did originally take, was itself wrong and bad. Are we done now

Why so many new people want to be "edgy"?

I've got a growing "Foe" list. We'll see if they become worth a [shirt] once the season starts, but for now it's boring.

[theograce]

can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...

What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?

not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh

Perron was what 180 maybe less at 18 Perron played the PITA well but he also got his (donkey) concussed

Are you talking about Joe’s cheap shot? Lindros got concussed too. What are you trying to say?

[theograce]

can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...

What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?

not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh

6'1 200 would be a small linebacker

You could have saved us the time by saying, "I think this is a bad comparison because they are essentially already equal" to which no that is not correct and your point, which I did originally take, was itself wrong and bad. Are we done now

Carbonneau is average NHL height & weight: I don't get the "linebacker" comparable (Perron is just slightly smaller)

He's not no linebacker, just a medium sized dude that plays hockey. He's not like Byfuglien, Reaves or Grier, etc.

Yeah, we're done now.

Lots of guys at 180-190 … so undersized? have played like linebackers and crushed 220+ pound men regularly. Lots goes into it…not just size

[Mr.Snuggleupagus]

Lots of guys at 180-190 … so undersized? have played like linebackers and crushed 220+ pound men regularly. Lots goes into it…not just size

Seattleblue might understand.

[theograce]

Lots of guys at 180-190 … so undersized? have played like linebackers and crushed 220+ pound men regularly. Lots goes into it…not just size

Seattleblue might understand.

As long as you do. I mean you didn’t understand Lucic doesn’t jump guys and throw punches. I mean now you get it…took work.

Laughing still

[Harry York 37]

Woah... I can get ugly, but, Jeez.


Perron might have been in the top couple of skilled forwards in the entire league in the PITA Trophy Voting.
He was at Ryan Suter's level of devious, and humiliatingly legal cheap shots.
I think Sundqvist learned a few things from him. He was a spectacular diver, when diving was absolutely called for.
I never saw anyone nullify more penalties with athleticism, dishonesty, and pluck.

Carbo has the build and attitude to play a more open and honest game.

[theograce]

Woah... I can get ugly, but, Jeez.


Perron might have been in the top couple of skilled forwards in the entire league in the PITA Trophy Voting.
He was at Ryan Suter's level of devious, and humiliatingly legal cheap shots.
I think Sundqvist learned a few things from him. He was a spectacular diver, when diving was absolutely called for.
I never saw anyone nullify more penalties with athleticism, dishonesty, and pluck.

Carbo has the build and attitude to play a more open and honest game.

Perron was a terrible diver…especially early on his career

[Mr.Snuggleupagus]

I mean you didn’t understand Lucic doesn’t jump guys and throw punches. I mean now you get it…took work.

Laughing still

You mean, you didn't understand that Lucic will punch opponents that deserve it out of nowhere trying to get them to drop the gloves and fight back (most willing combatants will fight back - like Bennett). You came up with some crazy scenario where he literally jumps on their backs and starts punching their lights out.

Took you awhile, but you finally understood.

[theograce]

I mean you didn’t understand Lucic doesn’t jump guys and throw punches. I mean now you get it…took work.

Laughing still

You mean, you didn't understand that Lucic will punch opponents that deserve it out of nowhere trying to get them to drop the gloves and fight back (most willing combatants will fight back - like Bennett). You came up with some crazy scenario where he literally jumps on their backs and starts punching their lights out.

Took you awhile, but you finally understood.

No this is what I mean. And you tried to prove with a vid hahahaha

I hope Lucic pounds Bennett into the ice (they might be buddies though).

Bennett wouldn’t waste his time on Looch. I hope my boy Neighbours goes with him again.

He might not have a choice in the matter.

Of course he has a choice. You think Lucic is gonna jump on guys and start throwing punches lol

He has before you know.

"lol"

[Mr.Snuggleupagus]

Where's the "vid"? You didn't post the "vid".

Is there a reason you didn't post the "vid"?

[Mr.Snuggleupagus]

Here, I'll post the "vid" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qf2bxfI54ik

Oh, so he has "jumped" on opponents before and tried to get them to fight back.

You don't know much about hockey bubb.

[theograce]

Where's the "vid"? You didn't post the "vid".

Is there a reason you didn't post the "vid"?

I can post the entire thread where you embarrassed yourself if you like? Still laughing. You could have just said … I was wrong lol

Like when he went after Mathieu Joseph as an example (I hope they kissed and made up)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qf2bxfI54ik

[Mr.Snuggleupagus]

Where's the "vid"? You didn't post the "vid".

Is there a reason you didn't post the "vid"?

I can post the entire thread where you embarrassed yourself if you like? Still laughing. You could have just said … I was wrong lol

Like when he went after Mathieu Joseph as an example (I hope they kissed and made up)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qf2bxfI54ik

Thanks for posting the proof that he has done that before (literally jumped an opponent).

Now quit trying to derail this thread with your lies and childish goalpost maneuvers.

[theograce]

Where's the "vid"? You didn't post the "vid".

Is there a reason you didn't post the "vid"?

I can post the entire thread where you embarrassed yourself if you like? Still laughing. You could have just said … I was wrong lol

Like when he went after Mathieu Joseph as an example (I hope they kissed and made up)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qf2bxfI54ik

Thanks for posting the proof that he done that before.

Done what? Those are punches? 6 years ago…and that was your BEST!

Hahahaha

[Mr.Snuggleupagus]

Where's the "vid"? You didn't post the "vid".

Is there a reason you didn't post the "vid"?

I can post the entire thread where you embarrassed yourself if you like? Still laughing. You could have just said … I was wrong lol

Like when he went after Mathieu Joseph as an example (I hope they kissed and made up)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qf2bxfI54ik

Thanks for posting the proof that he done that before.

Done what? Those are punches? 6 years ago…and that was your BEST!

Hahahaha

That's usually how fights get started, punching with the gloves on. Don't you know anything?

[theograce]

Where's the "vid"? You didn't post the "vid".

Is there a reason you didn't post the "vid"?

I can post the entire thread where you embarrassed yourself if you like? Still laughing. You could have just said … I was wrong lol

Like when he went after Mathieu Joseph as an example (I hope they kissed and made up)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qf2bxfI54ik

Thanks for posting the proof that he done that before.

Done what? Those are punches? 6 years ago…and that was your BEST!

Hahahaha

That's usually how fights get started, punching with the gloves on. Don't you know anything?

At what point in the video were the punches thrown? Do you know what punches are? McSorley lol