Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Join the discussion about the Blues.

[Complete Blues coverage on STLtoday.com]

Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Blues Talk Moderators

stljrs
Forum User
Posts: 132
Joined: 01 Feb 2018 09:17 am

Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by stljrs »

Interesting. Looks like they are going to give him a chance to push his way onto the roster. I believe he's the only one double dipping.
seattleblue
Forum User
Posts: 1788
Joined: 08 Feb 2025 12:01 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by seattleblue »

It took me a little while last year to hone in on him and put forward his name in a situation where my prediction mattered to me. Picking him as the target meant not picking others.

But this kid just has "it" - you can see the quality of something that can't be taught. There is a force to this kid and he applies it in service of what he wants. I'm rooting for him to follow the Perron path and steal a spot. Doubtful but you have to love a player like this intent on disrupting plans
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 4744
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by theograce »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:22 am It took me a little while last year to hone in on him and put forward his name in a situation where my prediction mattered to me. Picking him as the target meant not picking others.

But this kid just has "it" - you can see the quality of something that can't be taught. There is a force to this kid and he applies it in service of what he wants. I'm rooting for him to follow the Perron path and steal a spot. Doubtful but you have to love a player like this intent on disrupting plans
He’s your Perron. Cheater
seattleblue
Forum User
Posts: 1788
Joined: 08 Feb 2025 12:01 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by seattleblue »

theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:25 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:22 am It took me a little while last year to hone in on him and put forward his name in a situation where my prediction mattered to me. Picking him as the target meant not picking others.

But this kid just has "it" - you can see the quality of something that can't be taught. There is a force to this kid and he applies it in service of what he wants. I'm rooting for him to follow the Perron path and steal a spot. Doubtful but you have to love a player like this intent on disrupting plans
He’s your Perron. Cheater
can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 4744
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by theograce »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am
theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:25 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:22 am It took me a little while last year to hone in on him and put forward his name in a situation where my prediction mattered to me. Picking him as the target meant not picking others.

But this kid just has "it" - you can see the quality of something that can't be taught. There is a force to this kid and he applies it in service of what he wants. I'm rooting for him to follow the Perron path and steal a spot. Doubtful but you have to love a player like this intent on disrupting plans
He’s your Perron. Cheater
can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
Well. Does he have the balls to do it consistently? Because when you play like that you become a target. I don’t think people realize how much abuse Perron took. For me it’s not just about the trucking…it’s about taking all the sticks in front of the net and having a world class French chirp. The chippers who do it right have a special place in my heart
seattleblue
Forum User
Posts: 1788
Joined: 08 Feb 2025 12:01 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by seattleblue »

theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:33 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am
theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:25 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:22 am It took me a little while last year to hone in on him and put forward his name in a situation where my prediction mattered to me. Picking him as the target meant not picking others.

But this kid just has "it" - you can see the quality of something that can't be taught. There is a force to this kid and he applies it in service of what he wants. I'm rooting for him to follow the Perron path and steal a spot. Doubtful but you have to love a player like this intent on disrupting plans
He’s your Perron. Cheater
can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
Well. Does he have the balls to do it consistently? Because when you play like that you become a target. I don’t think people realize how much abuse Perron took. For me it’s not just about the trucking…it’s about taking all the sticks in front of the net and having a world class French chirp. The chippers who do it right have a special place in my heart
Perron took huge abuse he was a low key PITA to play against. I noticed tons of players take issue with how his competitiveness manifested. (I can utterly relate to this.) They are going to do the same to Carbo you are correct. My read on him is he he will lean into it and it's a signal the other team knows to take him seriously but more importantly his own teammates understand: We have things to win here boys
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 4744
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by theograce »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:39 am
theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:33 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am
theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:25 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:22 am It took me a little while last year to hone in on him and put forward his name in a situation where my prediction mattered to me. Picking him as the target meant not picking others.

But this kid just has "it" - you can see the quality of something that can't be taught. There is a force to this kid and he applies it in service of what he wants. I'm rooting for him to follow the Perron path and steal a spot. Doubtful but you have to love a player like this intent on disrupting plans
He’s your Perron. Cheater
can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
Well. Does he have the balls to do it consistently? Because when you play like that you become a target. I don’t think people realize how much abuse Perron took. For me it’s not just about the trucking…it’s about taking all the sticks in front of the net and having a world class French chirp. The chippers who do it right have a special place in my heart
Perron took huge abuse he was a low key PITA to play against. I noticed tons of players take issue with how his competitiveness manifested. (I can utterly relate to this.) They are going to do the same to Carbo you are correct. My read on him is he he will lean into it and it's a signal the other team knows to take him seriously but more importantly his own teammates understand: We have things to win here boys
I hope so. I was talking to my kid about it the other day. There’s just something about a French guy talking about your ugly girlfriend or fat sister that gets me going. French disturbers are my favorite. Hope to see Bolduc growing into it too.

I love Perron almost as much as you. He made me love him
seattleblue
Forum User
Posts: 1788
Joined: 08 Feb 2025 12:01 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by seattleblue »

theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:46 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:39 am
theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:33 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am
theograce wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:25 am
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:22 am It took me a little while last year to hone in on him and put forward his name in a situation where my prediction mattered to me. Picking him as the target meant not picking others.

But this kid just has "it" - you can see the quality of something that can't be taught. There is a force to this kid and he applies it in service of what he wants. I'm rooting for him to follow the Perron path and steal a spot. Doubtful but you have to love a player like this intent on disrupting plans
He’s your Perron. Cheater
can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
Well. Does he have the balls to do it consistently? Because when you play like that you become a target. I don’t think people realize how much abuse Perron took. For me it’s not just about the trucking…it’s about taking all the sticks in front of the net and having a world class French chirp. The chippers who do it right have a special place in my heart
Perron took huge abuse he was a low key PITA to play against. I noticed tons of players take issue with how his competitiveness manifested. (I can utterly relate to this.) They are going to do the same to Carbo you are correct. My read on him is he he will lean into it and it's a signal the other team knows to take him seriously but more importantly his own teammates understand: We have things to win here boys
I hope so. I was talking to my kid about it the other day. There’s just something about a French guy talking about your ugly girlfriend or fat sister that gets me going. French disturbers are my favorite. Hope to see Bolduc growing into it too.

I love Perron almost as much as you. He made me love him
It is worth watching the Game 7 broadcast on the French Canadian channel because they interview Perron on the ice twice during the celebration (and showing the Blais family and friends party during). That expression on his face after the fourth goal, every single thing he did on the ice was building to that moment. That moment in his head provided the centrifugal force for everything. That expression was the pleasure of it all, breaking over him. That is how Carbo is also held together. I am not saying other players also aren't, but I'm saying that certain type of people are not playing for money. They want the money to be fair and right but all they really care about is not getting taken advantage of for their good faith. If I could make one single off ice thing happen by snapping my fingers I would make Perron the new Federko on broadcasts and it would be one of the best things Blues fans ever got, he would be skilled at it.
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 4744
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by theograce »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:55 am It is worth watching the Game 7 broadcast on the French Canadian channel because they interview Perron on the ice twice during the celebration (and showing the Blais family and friends party during). That expression on his face after the fourth goal, every single thing he did on the ice was building to that moment. That moment in his head provided the centrifugal force for everything. That expression was the pleasure of it all, breaking over him. That is how Carbo is also held together. I am not saying other players also aren't, but I'm saying that certain type of people are not playing for money. They want the money to be fair and right but all they really care about is not getting taken advantage of for their good faith. If I could make one single off ice thing happen by snapping my fingers I would make Perron the new Federko on broadcasts and it would be one of the best things Blues fans ever got, he would be skilled at it.
The goal wasn’t a pressure valve release as much as his celebration/behavior.

When you make your Captain laugh out loud and shake his head during a moment like that you’re doing something special. He’s a true legend for the franchise. I’d love to talk to him. He just has the energy.

Go Carbs go
Mr.Snuggleupagus
Forum User
Posts: 368
Joined: 23 Aug 2025 17:34 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by Mr.Snuggleupagus »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?
seattleblue
Forum User
Posts: 1788
Joined: 08 Feb 2025 12:01 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by seattleblue »

Mr.Snuggleupagus wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:36 pm
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?
not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh
Mr.Snuggleupagus
Forum User
Posts: 368
Joined: 23 Aug 2025 17:34 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by Mr.Snuggleupagus »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:50 pm
Mr.Snuggleupagus wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:36 pm
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?
not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh
6'1 200 would be a small linebacker
seattleblue
Forum User
Posts: 1788
Joined: 08 Feb 2025 12:01 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by seattleblue »

Mr.Snuggleupagus wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:57 pm
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:50 pm
Mr.Snuggleupagus wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:36 pm
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?
not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh
6'1 200 would be a small linebacker
You could have saved us the time by saying, "I think this is a bad comparison because they are essentially already equal" to which no that is not correct and your point, which I did originally take, was itself wrong and bad. Are we done now
Mr.Snuggleupagus
Forum User
Posts: 368
Joined: 23 Aug 2025 17:34 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by Mr.Snuggleupagus »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 14:12 pm
Mr.Snuggleupagus wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:57 pm
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:50 pm
Mr.Snuggleupagus wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:36 pm
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?
not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh
6'1 200 would be a small linebacker
You could have saved us the time by saying, "I think this is a bad comparison because they are essentially already equal" to which no that is not correct and your point, which I did originally take, was itself wrong and bad. Are we done now
Carbonneau is average NHL height & weight: I don't get the "linebacker" comparable (Perron is just slightly smaller)

He's not no linebacker, just a medium sized dude that plays hockey. He's not like Byfuglien, Reaves or Grier, etc.

Yeah, we're done now. :wink:
Ace07
Forum User
Posts: 90
Joined: 26 May 2024 10:58 am

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by Ace07 »

stljrs wrote: 21 Sep 2025 09:59 am Interesting. Looks like they are going to give him a chance to push his way onto the roster. I believe he's the only one double dipping.
Buchnevich-Thomas-Snuggerud
Holloway-Schenn-Kyrou
Neighbours-Suter-Dvorsky
Toropchenko-Bjugstad-Walker
Texier-Sundqvist-Joseph
Lucic
Carbonneau

Where exactly do we expect him to fit in? We are cluttered with forwards signed to NHL contracts.
Harry S Deals
Forum User
Posts: 1865
Joined: 23 May 2024 14:25 pm

Re: Carbonneau in today vs CBJ

Post by Harry S Deals »

seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:50 pm
Mr.Snuggleupagus wrote: 21 Sep 2025 13:36 pm
seattleblue wrote: 21 Sep 2025 10:27 am can you honestly imagine David Perron if he also were 6'1" linebacker build and wanted to truck people ...
What if Perron was 1 inch taller, what would happen?
not sure 1 inch on his existing frame, but if he were taller and more built like a linebacker the way Carbonneau is and he played with the same Perron energy we saw then we likely would have seen more violence out there on the ice tbh
Perron was what 180 maybe less at 18 Perron played the PITA well but he also got his (donkey) concussed
Post Reply