ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Join the discussion about the Blues.

[Complete Blues coverage on STLtoday.com]

Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Blues Talk Moderators

Post Reply
netboy65
Forum User
Posts: 1414
Joined: 23 May 2024 12:54 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by netboy65 »

Bomac wrote: 03 Nov 2024 11:22 am
dhsux wrote: 02 Nov 2024 17:13 pm
Bomac wrote: 02 Nov 2024 10:11 am Yeas....... Again he is looking good. And yeas again. It's early.


. But, Why is this thread needed twice a week. Hell this might be the second since his last game. Oh yeah, and again. Praise Army... Small ego needs big praise.
I felt like doing another thread too because of how impressed I am and what the possibilities are here with him.

It's too early but man it's hard to suppress the optimism on what he could mean for this franchise.
I have not been as impressed. Maybe one thread impressed.
But his main issue came to play big last night... The kid doesn't know how to take a hit. And that's just as big a flaw as any other metric.

The problem with yet another thread... For me. Is it's brought to you and promoted by those who would cancel a poster for posting the opposite... Hypocrisy is as [shirt]. As loyalty.
Well, except it wasn’t some normal check along the boards or in the corner, Marner fell right on his knee
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 3760
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by theograce »

Wish Broberg nothing but the best, but it’s pretty clear to see he’s physically inferior and can be taken advantage of. Imagine that in the playoffs. He’s 23.5 years old as well.
Bomac
Banned User
Posts: 403
Joined: 24 May 2024 11:09 am

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by Bomac »

theograce wrote: 03 Nov 2024 12:24 pm Wish Broberg nothing but the best, but it’s pretty clear to see he’s physically inferior and can be taken advantage of. Imagine that in the playoffs. He’s 23.5 years old as well.
He's only 23.... And being physical, is a confidence issue and usually a lacking skill. He'll come around. If he doesn't keep getting himself hurt, before he figures it out.
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 3760
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by theograce »

Bomac wrote: 03 Nov 2024 12:33 pm
theograce wrote: 03 Nov 2024 12:24 pm Wish Broberg nothing but the best, but it’s pretty clear to see he’s physically inferior and can be taken advantage of. Imagine that in the playoffs. He’s 23.5 years old as well.
He's only 23.... And being physical, is a confidence issue and usually a lacking skill. He'll come around. If he doesn't keep getting himself hurt, before he figures it out.
He’s 23.5. As an example, pietrangelo was leading the club in ice at 21-22 and playing playoffs. 80 games doing that.

Hedman and Doughty were doing more than Broberg with more responsibility when they were 19.
TBone
Forum User
Posts: 758
Joined: 28 May 2024 09:00 am

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by TBone »

theograce wrote: 03 Nov 2024 11:29 am Tbone, bubbles, dsux and hairy have made their living here by calling a hard nosed HOFer soft.
But he is soft. :laughing-laughing:

Image
thetank2
Forum User
Posts: 4183
Joined: 23 Aug 2018 10:30 am

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by thetank2 »

How well did he do in the playoffs last year?
Bubble4427
Forum User
Posts: 630
Joined: 23 May 2024 13:18 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by Bubble4427 »

TBone wrote: 04 Nov 2024 06:12 am
theograce wrote: 03 Nov 2024 11:29 am Tbone, bubbles, dsux and hairy have made their living here by calling a hard nosed HOFer soft.
But he is soft. :laughing-laughing:

Image
Owner of the most embarrassing moment by any Blues captain EVER.
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 3760
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by theograce »

thetank2 wrote: 04 Nov 2024 09:10 am How well did he do in the playoffs last year?
Nobody even knew who he was. Oil have about 15 players they cared about more.

He’s a boy still. The alphas are coming for him
sdaltons
Forum User
Posts: 2773
Joined: 23 May 2024 12:45 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by sdaltons »

thetank2 wrote: 04 Nov 2024 09:10 am How well did he do in the playoffs last year?
He was excellent over the last 10 games or so. You could tell he was starting to get comfortable.
Moberly Blues
Forum User
Posts: 109
Joined: 11 Oct 2022 06:56 am
Location: Moberly,Mo

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by Moberly Blues »

Alpha is a word you no nothing about Theograce, sit behind a keyboard and act tough , we should sit and talk hockey sometime troll!!
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 3760
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by theograce »

Moberly Blues wrote: 04 Nov 2024 09:42 am Alpha is a word you no nothing about Theograce, sit behind a keyboard and act tough , we should sit and talk hockey sometime troll!!
Focus. The alphas are coming from Broberg as we saw. Brady hurt him bad. Focus
Lloyd Braun
Forum User
Posts: 1838
Joined: 05 Feb 2021 22:03 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by Lloyd Braun »

Harry S Deals wrote: 01 Nov 2024 09:03 am This kid.... again even in a loss last night he for me is again the Blues best player on the ice.

23 yrs old tied for the team lead with 9pts leads the team with +6, and doing it with limited to no PP 4th in ATOI

For NHL dmen 23 or under:

Clarke 11pts
Broberg 9 pts
Sanderson, Power 8pts

Schneider +8, Hartely, Broberg +6

Do we need to start talking a little more about exactly what Army may have landed here? This has to be viewed in the context also that lets be honest the Blues this week, no Thomas, no Joseph, no Leddy just arent that good. Also i have to believe another coach would have had Broberg as the QB on the #1 PP which is painfully obvious to anyone watching the Blues. But again this also a coach that runs Brayden Schenn out on a #1 PP, but i am digressing.
Time will tell but man at 23 and so far, early, Broberg is the #! LHD fans were asking for. What does Broberg look like at 26 or 27 years old, Hedman-ish? Maybe he puts on a few more pounds, hes not timid as it is, 10 hits in 11 games he has no problem finishing his checks. Hes just getting his feet wet, going to be great watching him develop.
Petro is a Blue HOFer and will have #27 in the rafters one day. And Bouwmeester was a very good defenseman, although we got him in the 2nd half of his career, when he wasn't as offensively productive.

But I would say Broberg has the chance to be right there behind Petro.
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 3760
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by theograce »

Can always tell when there a lot of pain in this place.

Brady and lil Mitchy have this place a buzzin
Harry S Deals
Forum User
Posts: 1372
Joined: 23 May 2024 14:25 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by Harry S Deals »

Lloyd Braun wrote: 04 Nov 2024 09:57 am
Harry S Deals wrote: 01 Nov 2024 09:03 am This kid.... again even in a loss last night he for me is again the Blues best player on the ice.

23 yrs old tied for the team lead with 9pts leads the team with +6, and doing it with limited to no PP 4th in ATOI

For NHL dmen 23 or under:

Clarke 11pts
Broberg 9 pts
Sanderson, Power 8pts

Schneider +8, Hartely, Broberg +6

Do we need to start talking a little more about exactly what Army may have landed here? This has to be viewed in the context also that lets be honest the Blues this week, no Thomas, no Joseph, no Leddy just arent that good. Also i have to believe another coach would have had Broberg as the QB on the #1 PP which is painfully obvious to anyone watching the Blues. But again this also a coach that runs Brayden Schenn out on a #1 PP, but i am digressing.
Time will tell but man at 23 and so far, early, Broberg is the #! LHD fans were asking for. What does Broberg look like at 26 or 27 years old, Hedman-ish? Maybe he puts on a few more pounds, hes not timid as it is, 10 hits in 11 games he has no problem finishing his checks. Hes just getting his feet wet, going to be great watching him develop.
Petro is a Blue HOFer and will have #27 in the rafters one day. And Bouwmeester was a very good defenseman, although we got him in the 2nd half of his career, when he wasn't as offensively productive.

But I would say Broberg has the chance to be right there behind Petro.
Petro is a great two way dman nobody with any cred disputes this, 54 pt season so far APs tops perhaps he eclipses that this year. SO FAR, VERY EARLY Brobie looks like he has the potential for more. Time will tell
Army's Mom
Forum User
Posts: 457
Joined: 21 Aug 2024 10:23 am

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by Army's Mom »

Lloyd Braun wrote: 04 Nov 2024 09:57 am
Harry S Deals wrote: 01 Nov 2024 09:03 am This kid.... again even in a loss last night he for me is again the Blues best player on the ice.

23 yrs old tied for the team lead with 9pts leads the team with +6, and doing it with limited to no PP 4th in ATOI

For NHL dmen 23 or under:

Clarke 11pts
Broberg 9 pts
Sanderson, Power 8pts

Schneider +8, Hartely, Broberg +6

Do we need to start talking a little more about exactly what Army may have landed here? This has to be viewed in the context also that lets be honest the Blues this week, no Thomas, no Joseph, no Leddy just arent that good. Also i have to believe another coach would have had Broberg as the QB on the #1 PP which is painfully obvious to anyone watching the Blues. But again this also a coach that runs Brayden Schenn out on a #1 PP, but i am digressing.
Time will tell but man at 23 and so far, early, Broberg is the #! LHD fans were asking for. What does Broberg look like at 26 or 27 years old, Hedman-ish? Maybe he puts on a few more pounds, hes not timid as it is, 10 hits in 11 games he has no problem finishing his checks. Hes just getting his feet wet, going to be great watching him develop.
Petro is a Blue HOFer and will have #27 in the rafters one day. And Bouwmeester was a very good defenseman, although we got him in the 2nd half of his career, when he wasn't as offensively productive.

But I would say Broberg has the chance to be right there behind Petro.
I LOVE the optimism around Broberg, and feel it to. I want to believe, lol.

That said, I remember after ten games thinking that Barrett Jackman was the second coming of Scott Stevens.

Broberg reminds me a LOT of early Pronger, minus the mean side. I don't want to saddle him with those expectations. Here's hoping he's healthy again soon, and back to doing what got him mentions alongside such luminary Blues players. He can then decide who he wants to be :)
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 3760
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: ITS EARLY but is Broberg the Blues best dman since Pronger/Mac

Post by theograce »

Harry S Deals wrote: 04 Nov 2024 10:16 am
Petro is a great two way dman nobody with any cred disputes this, 54 pt season so far APs tops perhaps he eclipses that this year. SO FAR, VERY EARLY Brobie looks like he has the potential for more. Time will tell
Shattenkirk got more…the league is different now. Much more offensive. Offense will never be Broberg’s issue. Away from the puck will be…as we saw many times already

The problem with you has always been player assessment and bias. You suck at the first and have too much of the second.
Post Reply