13th: Sawyer Strosnider OF - TCU
32nd: Trevor Condon OF - HS
50th: Denton Lord RHP - HS
68th: Will Yow - SS - HS
72nd: Eli Herst RHP - HS
86th: Blake Morningstar RHP - Wake Forest
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
Good question and glad you asked ... Baseball America had to say this ....
The two best draft pundits in the industry both say it's a deep college hitters draft up top....sorta like 2023 (that draft had college hitters with at least an "A Tier Grade" all the way to 18 pick, we got Davis at 18, hasn't worked out, per se, but there's still time. And it's THE BEST Prep draft...perhaps ever. Prep hitters and especially Prep pitchers...the amount of High Control with this crop of HS pitchers has never been seen before.
Herst has that tall frame you want in a pitcher. PNW prep star....I think he'll go higher than 72....we'll see how the spring turns out.cardinalsfever44 wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 17:56 pm I asked AI and here is what it gave me for each pick. Looking forward to Crav and other draft experts to pick this apart![]()
13th: Sawyer Strosnider OF - TCU
32nd: Trevor Condon OF - HS
50th: Denton Lord RHP - HS
68th: Will Yow - SS - HS
72nd: Eli Herst RHP - HS
86th: Blake Morningstar RHP - Wake Forest
So no excuse for Bloom to miss on this draftcraviduce wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:28 pmThe two best draft pundits in the industry both say it's a deep college hitters draft up top....sorta like 2023 (that draft had college hitters with at least an "A Tier Grade" all the way to 18 pick, we got Davis at 18, hasn't worked out, per se, but there's still time. And it's THE BEST Prep draft...perhaps ever. Prep hitters and especially Prep pitchers...the amount of High Control with this crop of HS pitchers has never been seen before.
So...yeah, this is a really good draft, it's going to be interesting to see how it plays out. We might go deep with HS talent on day 1... our first 6 picks are on day 1.
I'm not a Sawyer Strosnider fan...but I'd live with it. If Gracia, Reese, Hacopian are available, I pray we take one of them.cardinalsfever44 wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:39 pm The scouting report for Herst that I read says his fastball sits 88-93 MPH but plays up due to his elite extension. Best secondary pitch is a low 80's changeup with heavy fade. He's a Vandy commit.
On Day 1...we should "HIT" on 3 of 6...that would be my standard with this depth of a draft....time will tell, but I'd go as far as 4 of 6 as a "HIT".Goldfan wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:43 pmSo no excuse for Bloom to miss on this draftcraviduce wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:28 pmThe two best draft pundits in the industry both say it's a deep college hitters draft up top....sorta like 2023 (that draft had college hitters with at least an "A Tier Grade" all the way to 18 pick, we got Davis at 18, hasn't worked out, per se, but there's still time. And it's THE BEST Prep draft...perhaps ever. Prep hitters and especially Prep pitchers...the amount of High Control with this crop of HS pitchers has never been seen before.
So...yeah, this is a really good draft, it's going to be interesting to see how it plays out. We might go deep with HS talent on day 1... our first 6 picks are on day 1.
Can any one remember the last Cards drafted impact OFer?craviduce wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:44 pmOn Day 1...we should "HIT" on 3 of 6...that would be my standard with this depth of a draft....time will tell, but I'd go as far as 4 of 6 as a "HIT".Goldfan wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:43 pmSo no excuse for Bloom to miss on this draftcraviduce wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:28 pmThe two best draft pundits in the industry both say it's a deep college hitters draft up top....sorta like 2023 (that draft had college hitters with at least an "A Tier Grade" all the way to 18 pick, we got Davis at 18, hasn't worked out, per se, but there's still time. And it's THE BEST Prep draft...perhaps ever. Prep hitters and especially Prep pitchers...the amount of High Control with this crop of HS pitchers has never been seen before.
So...yeah, this is a really good draft, it's going to be interesting to see how it plays out. We might go deep with HS talent on day 1... our first 6 picks are on day 1.
"HIT" means they make it and make a splash at the MLB level. ie: Winn and Burleson would be considered as making a Splash. Both were taken in the day 1 window. Still waiting on Walker's splash, if it comes, but he has "Made it" to the MLB level.
Remember this, Goldfan....if you take the HS route in the draft... then you HAVE to be patient with that prospect. PATIENCE.
Bader, but the fans didn't have the patience for him.....we were spoiled. Hell, remember Colby Rasmus? He was a 4-5 WAR player, but the fans didn't like the Batting Average. Sigh...it begat a World Series in the trade....so there's that.Goldfan wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:48 pmCan any one remember the last Cards drafted impact OFer?craviduce wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:44 pmOn Day 1...we should "HIT" on 3 of 6...that would be my standard with this depth of a draft....time will tell, but I'd go as far as 4 of 6 as a "HIT".Goldfan wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:43 pmSo no excuse for Bloom to miss on this draftcraviduce wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:28 pmThe two best draft pundits in the industry both say it's a deep college hitters draft up top....sorta like 2023 (that draft had college hitters with at least an "A Tier Grade" all the way to 18 pick, we got Davis at 18, hasn't worked out, per se, but there's still time. And it's THE BEST Prep draft...perhaps ever. Prep hitters and especially Prep pitchers...the amount of High Control with this crop of HS pitchers has never been seen before.
So...yeah, this is a really good draft, it's going to be interesting to see how it plays out. We might go deep with HS talent on day 1... our first 6 picks are on day 1.
"HIT" means they make it and make a splash at the MLB level. ie: Winn and Burleson would be considered as making a Splash. Both were taken in the day 1 window. Still waiting on Walker's splash, if it comes, but he has "Made it" to the MLB level.
Remember this, Goldfan....if you take the HS route in the draft... then you HAVE to be patient with that prospect. PATIENCE.
I had to look up Will Yow....holy moly, he has Victor Scott II SPEED....80 Future Value on Speedcardinalsfever44 wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 17:56 pm I asked AI and here is what it gave me for each pick. Looking forward to Crav and other draft experts to pick this apart![]()
13th: Sawyer Strosnider OF - TCU
32nd: Trevor Condon OF - HS
50th: Denton Lord RHP - HS
68th: Will Yow - SS - HS
72nd: Eli Herst RHP - HS
86th: Blake Morningstar RHP - Wake Forest
it warms the heart to hear all that Duce !craviduce wrote: ↑04 Feb 2026 18:28 pmThe two best draft pundits in the industry both say it's a deep college hitters draft up top....sorta like 2023 (that draft had college hitters with at least an "A Tier Grade" all the way to 18 pick, we got Davis at 18, hasn't worked out, per se, but there's still time. And it's THE BEST Prep draft...perhaps ever. Prep hitters and especially Prep pitchers...the amount of High Control with this crop of HS pitchers has never been seen before.
So...yeah, this is a really good draft, it's going to be interesting to see how it plays out. We might go deep with HS talent on day 1... our first 6 picks are on day 1.