Who f'ing cares how you label it ?

Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
The MLB might care. Burleson may be selected for the Silver Slugger Award this season as a utility player. And could repeat in '26.
Jimmy cracked cornShady wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 15:51 pmThe MLB might care. Burleson may be selected for the Silver Slugger Award this season as a utility player. And could repeat in '26.
Tee Hee! Good joke Shady monster!Shady wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 15:51 pmThe MLB might care. Burleson may be selected for the Silver Slugger Award this season as a utility player. And could repeat in '26.
If Burleson gets a Silver Slugger MLB may as well abolish the award. Nothing says slugger like 18 HR, 69 RBI.Shady wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 15:51 pmThe MLB might care. Burleson may be selected for the Silver Slugger Award this season as a utility player. And could repeat in '26.
6 homeruns and 20 RBI in the second half. A silver slugger for an empty batting average? If you want to cheer an award like that, have at it. MLB should retroactively award Aaron Miles one too.Shady wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 15:51 pmThe MLB might care. Burleson may be selected for the Silver Slugger Award this season as a utility player. And could repeat in '26.
A Sliver of a SluggerCorneliusWolfe wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 18:05 pm6 homeruns and 20 RBI in the second half. A silver slugger for an empty batting average? If you want to cheer an award like that, have at it. MLB should retroactively award Aaron Miles one too.Shady wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 15:51 pmThe MLB might care. Burleson may be selected for the Silver Slugger Award this season as a utility player. And could repeat in '26.
Agree. Contreras has averaged 114 games over the last four seasons. 110 the last two seasons. He'll be 34 when the season starts. In addition to missing lots of games, we should expect a drop off (at minimum gradually) offensively and defensively.
Are you talking about the same Alec Burleson that just put up 1.9 WAR this season and has 2.3 for his career?Lloyd Braun wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 20:27 pmAgree. Contreras has averaged 114 games over the last four seasons. 110 the last two seasons. He'll be 34 when the season starts. In addition to missing lots of games, we should expect a drop off (at minimum gradually) offensively and defensively.
Whereas, Burleson has the ability to winning a batting title and hit at least 20 homers... and if he keeps improving, maybe 25-30.
The only players to hit .290 with 18 or more HRs this year were:
Aaron Judge
Bobby Witt
Vlad Guerrero
Freddie Freeman
George Springer
Bo Bichette
Yandy Diaz
Josh Naylor
Geraldo Perdomo
Alec Burleson
The combined salary for Aaron Judge, Bobby Witt Jr., Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Freddie Freeman, George Springer, and Bo Bichette is $129,750,000 or $22 million per season.
Burleson makes $2.1 million.
I just don't understand the hate for Burlseon. The guy is a unique skill in today's game of hitting for high average and pop. It just doesn't grow on trees. And he's probably the only Cardinal that has improved year to year.
My thought is one of Pages or Pozo will be non-tendered or traded. The other will be the backup with Crooke starting at Triple A if he isn’t traded. It wouldn’t shock my if Crooks is traded for pitching with Bernal identified as the catcher to be the guy when the rebuild is done.
Thanks. That's what I figured. That hate comes from the computer geek stat nerds that destroyed the game with fake, subjective, made up statsTalkin' Baseball wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 20:32 pmAre you talking about the same Alec Burleson that just put up 1.9 WAR this season and has 2.3 for his career?Lloyd Braun wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 20:27 pmAgree. Contreras has averaged 114 games over the last four seasons. 110 the last two seasons. He'll be 34 when the season starts. In addition to missing lots of games, we should expect a drop off (at minimum gradually) offensively and defensively.
Whereas, Burleson has the ability to winning a batting title and hit at least 20 homers... and if he keeps improving, maybe 25-30.
The only players to hit .290 with 18 or more HRs this year were:
Aaron Judge
Bobby Witt
Vlad Guerrero
Freddie Freeman
George Springer
Bo Bichette
Yandy Diaz
Josh Naylor
Geraldo Perdomo
Alec Burleson
The combined salary for Aaron Judge, Bobby Witt Jr., Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Freddie Freeman, George Springer, and Bo Bichette is $129,750,000 or $22 million per season.
Burleson makes $2.1 million.
I just don't understand the hate for Burlseon. The guy is a unique skill in today's game of hitting for high average and pop. It just doesn't grow on trees. And he's probably the only Cardinal that has improved year to year.
Judge hit a LOT more than 18 home runs. Still only took up a single roster spot and spot in the lineup.Lloyd Braun wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 20:48 pmThanks. That's what I figured. That hate comes from the computer geek stat nerds that destroyed the game with fake, subjective, made up statsTalkin' Baseball wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 20:32 pmAre you talking about the same Alec Burleson that just put up 1.9 WAR this season and has 2.3 for his career?Lloyd Braun wrote: ↑28 Sep 2025 20:27 pmAgree. Contreras has averaged 114 games over the last four seasons. 110 the last two seasons. He'll be 34 when the season starts. In addition to missing lots of games, we should expect a drop off (at minimum gradually) offensively and defensively.
Whereas, Burleson has the ability to winning a batting title and hit at least 20 homers... and if he keeps improving, maybe 25-30.
The only players to hit .290 with 18 or more HRs this year were:
Aaron Judge
Bobby Witt
Vlad Guerrero
Freddie Freeman
George Springer
Bo Bichette
Yandy Diaz
Josh Naylor
Geraldo Perdomo
Alec Burleson
The combined salary for Aaron Judge, Bobby Witt Jr., Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Freddie Freeman, George Springer, and Bo Bichette is $129,750,000 or $22 million per season.
Burleson makes $2.1 million.
I just don't understand the hate for Burlseon. The guy is a unique skill in today's game of hitting for high average and pop. It just doesn't grow on trees. And he's probably the only Cardinal that has improved year to year.