CT poll- Rose in/out

[Monsieur De Treville]

I was an attorney, so one word answers are simply impossible! lol

Look, Rose probably should be in, but I have two problems with him.

1. He lied to fans for years about his gambling. I hate that.
2. Rose thought he was soooo big that the rules simply would not apply to him. He was wrong.

In. With reservations.

[Monsieur De Treville]

In.

Joe Jackson better go in first.

Will Joe Jackson be in or will he be "Steppin Out"?

Is she really going out with him?

[Monsieur De Treville]

In. As I recall, when he bet on his own team, he only bet on them to win.

1. That's what he said. Believe him at your own risk.
2. Would a big bet force him to use his bullpen differently? Would he bring in his closer with a 4 run lead if he needs to win by 3 in order to win the bet.
3. Was the rule ever, no betting on baseball UNLESS you bet on your team to win?

Your argument is tired and immensely flawed.

[Monsieur De Treville]

In. As I recall, when he bet on his own team, he only bet on them to win.

Does it matter?

Yes, because he could do things to lose.

Going out of his way chasing a win also is detrimental. Burning up your bully because you bet to win has repurcussions

Exactly!

[Monsieur De Treville]

In

As a player he's a slam dunk, 1st ballot Hall of Famer and that's what he's going in for not his managing which s u c k e d.

Once the Hall started letting STEROID freaks in, there was no reason to exclude Rose the Player anymore.

Agreed. If you let steroid freaks in you might as well let everybody in

Which proven steroid freaks other than Fat Papi are in?

I don't know about "proven"....but...I'm incredibly skeptical of Pudge, Bagwell, and yes...Nolan Ryan.

[sikeston bulldog2]

One of the most fundamental goal in baseball is to get a hit.
The best kind of hit is a home run.

It’s comical that neither the guy who has the most hits nor the guy who has the most “best kind of hits” are not in the Hall of Fame.

Put Pete in, explain the gambling on his plaque.

Your vote one on panel 4.

Overall 34-15

Panel four is 3-1 In. 37-16 overall. .698 percent. Need 75.

The fourth group of posters are at 5-2 In. That’s 42-18 In. 69 percent ish.

[icon]

I was an attorney, so one word answers are simply impossible! lol

Look, Rose probably should be in, but I have two problems with him.

1. He lied to fans for years about his gambling. I hate that.
2. Rose thought he was soooo big that the rules simply would not apply to him. He was wrong.

In. With reservations.

Out. With extreme prejudice.

[KeeptheRamsinSTL]

:Out - alleged sex with child under 16 years old

[icon]

:Out - alleged sex with child under 16 years old

Just pretend we're in Saudi Arabia, among other places, where that's A-OK.

[renostl]

In

As a player he's a slam dunk, 1st ballot Hall of Famer and that's what he's going in for not his managing which s u c k e d.

Once the Hall started letting STEROID freaks in, there was no reason to exclude Rose the Player anymore.

Agreed. If you let steroid freaks in you might as well let everybody in

Which proven steroid freaks other than Fat Papi are in?

I don't know about "proven"....but...I'm incredibly skeptical of Pudge, Bagwell, and yes...Nolan Ryan.

Should we be equally skeptical that MLB didn't release all the information on Rose?
They had enough to convict, why release more convict twice.

I don't see the two offenses the same at all. Which 2B with 10 HR's were
using so they could hit 15? Same 2B bets on games and now what you got? Each to their own.

[Gob]

In.

I actually think there's a lot of merit to Derrick Goold's suggestion. Induct all of the questionable characters who performed at a HOF level and list their (baseball) transgressions on their plaque, whether it be gambling, performance-enhancing drug use, etc. The players get to say they're Hall of Famers and fans can get the whole picture to interpret and evaluate how they see fit.

Would that mean they make new plaques for Piazza, Bagwell, Biggio, Thome, Henderson etc?

[OldRed]

As a baseball player - yes.

[ramfandan]

We need the Child Protection group to be vocal. Climbing on top of some young girl when you are married with 2 kids begs many questions. Somehow who drove her to the meeting place?

Good question .. they didn't have Uber cars back then . Just a wild guess but he probably told her that taking a taxi would be a lot to reimburse her so he probably said take the city bus to the hotel . Only 25 cents or whatever back then.

[Vacardfan1964]

In

[pdcox1951]

IN
Shoeless Joe Jackson..in

[OldRed]

Here's what teammate Tony Perez said:

I always say what he did on the field is why he should be in the Hall of Fame. But this is great news. I'm happy that they are giving him the opportunity. They can vote for him and see if he can get in the Hall of Fame, because he should be in there.

He paid the price for a long, long, long time and I know he was hurt. He maybe didn't look like it, but I know he was hurt. Because he loved the game so much and he wanted to be with the fans and he wanted to be at the ballpark. But he made a mistake and he paid for that.

He can always play with me. When I meet him again, I would love to play with him.