Hellebuyck or Binnington

[bluesXwinXtheXcup]

Who would you rather have in net?

I know Connor has better stats and just won the Jennings Trophy, but Jordan is clutch.

Thoughts?

[DawgDad]

We have Binnington. He's won a Cup, he's inside MacKinnon's head, he recently won the 4Nations, and he's been playing well. Why would we want some other guy when we have Binner? Count our blessings.

[theograce]

Helley is much bigger and more skilled.

Binnington is a much better puck manager

[dhsux]

That is quite the question.

I wonder how many posters will answer it.

I'm predicting Blues in 6 so I guess my answer is JB.......but I must say the perspective of this question had me thinking.

[dhsux]

Wonder how many wishy washy answers will be given?

One so far.

[BudOnTap]

Helley is much bigger and more skilled.

Binnington is a much better puck manager

Perpetual fence rider. Pick one. Make a stand.

[sdaltons]

Only one has won when it counts.

[Pierre McGuire]

Binner is a winner but you can’t win the cup until you win it…Hellebuyck is eventually gonna come up big when it counts. Will it be this year? Guess we are gonna find out

[imyourhuckleberry]

Ride or die with Binny. He's earned it.

[theograce]

Binner is a winner but you can’t win the cup until you win it…Hellebuyck is eventually gonna come up big when it counts. Will it be this year? Guess we are gonna find out

Jets have never had a team like the 2019 Blues. McDavid hasn’t won a Cup and he might be the best player of all time.

[Spyro Gyra]

Who would you rather have in net?

I know Connor has better stats and just won the Jennings Trophy, but Jordan is clutch.

Thoughts?

When the chips were down, who answered the bell? TWICE. Give me Binnington all day, everyday.

[Aesa]

Who would you rather have in net?

I know Connor has better stats and just won the Jennings Trophy, but Jordan is clutch.

Thoughts?

When the chips were down, who answered the bell? TWICE. Give me Binnington all day, everyday.

+1

[John Cocktoastin]

Who would I rather have in net?

Hellebuyck in the regular season.

Binnington in the playoffs. No doubt.

[icon]

Hellofabuick hasn't won s*** yet. He always breaks down under stress. Binnington all series, every game over that loser.

[Old_Goat]

Who would I rather have in net?

Hellebuyck in the regular season.

Binnington in the playoffs. No doubt.

Good assessment.

[PPG]

Come on Theo- The Jets were every bit as good as the Blues in 2019. They finished ahead of us in the standings and had a 2 goal lead in the pivotal game 5. If Schwartz doesn't miraculously bat the puck out of mid air with 15 seconds left and the Blues end up losing game 5, they would have most likely been out in round 1 and there is no iconic photo of Petro hoisting the Cup....LOL