An Old Friend wrote: ↑24 Mar 2025 22:02 pm
@Quincy…
Thought I’d share some of the biggest reaches on keepers, IMO, in my H2H 12 teamer. As a reminder, rules are have to start the draft with 5 players - so, can keep up to 5 with at least one pitcher, can keep as few as 3 and pick guys predraft.
4 of the 12 only kept 3 players. Their picks in the first predraft round:
Schwarber, Sale, Framber Valdez, Jackson Holliday
The guy that took Holliday also kept James Wood and Westburg, then picked Schwellenbach for his 5th.
There were then 6 picks in the second predraft round:
Clase, Josh Naylor, Devin Williams, CJ Abrams, Schwellenbach, and Junior Caminero
Wyatt Langford, O’Neil Cruz, Jackson Merrill, Dylan Crews, Michael Harris all were kept
Only one guy kept 3 SP - Blake Snell, Dylan Cease, Bryce Miller. Workhorse SP can pile up points. I did keep Strider
So I have the 2nd overall pick (pick #62) - up for debate:
Logan Webb, ADP 50, SP 16, two straight 200 IP seasons. Boring but fantastic this spring.
Sandy Alcantara, ADP 104, SP 43… would be an overdraft but potential ace and keeper moving forward. 0.00 ERA 0.97 WHIP in 5 spring training outings
Aaron Nola, ADP 60, SP 15. High floor but never a keeper
Top projected hitters:
Christian Walker, ADP 61, 1B 9. Oblique scares me off
Buxton, ADP 69, OF 45. Risky
Bryan Reynolds, ADP 59, OF 26. Boring but consistent, high floor. Would be safe pick.
Marcell Ozuna, ADP 74, utility only.
Mike Trout, ADP 52, OF 23. Very tempted.
Adames - no
Yelich - no
Nimmo - no
Semien or Altuve?? Both ADPs in the 40’s. I should probably do this.
Right now I might have:
Webb
Trout
Alcantara
Altuve
Semien
As my 5 best options. Thoughts? Altuve soon to have 2B/OF would be nice.