STLtoday.com

Andrew McCutchen is still a free agent at this point in the offseason, would you open to bring him in as a veteran in the club house // DH on a one year low cost deal ? Always respected him as a player.

No thanks

It's a rebuild. NO!

I would pick up McCutcheon in a hot minute. Veteran leadership, great experience, it can still play.

stanw wrote: ↑22 Feb 2026 17:53 pm Andrew McCutchen is still a free agent at this point in the offseason, would you open to bring him in as a veteran in the club house // DH on a one year low cost deal ? Always respected him as a player.

No.

no thanks

I would for leadership if he would do like a 5 mill contract. Dude is still productive in a part-time role and would help others I think.

No not after signing Urias however after Noot can’t hold up and Walker bombs out probably wish we had.

He’s a class act and would bring leadership and experience.
And I’m sure he’d be productive.
Of course it would depend somewhat on the $$ but:
It’s a no because the PT needs to go to younger guys.
And....I don’t know why Cutch would want to go to the Cards??
Would make more sense to come off the bench for a playoff contender.

Trade Noot, sign AM.

No. Play the youths. He serves no purpose.

I would sign him in a New Joisy minute.

Jatalk wrote: ↑22 Feb 2026 18:57 pm No not after signing Urias however after Noot can’t hold up and Walker bombs out probably wish we had.

Walker bomb out ? Didn't you see he has a .500 batting average so far this spring ?

I don’t see a meaningful role…

Great player, class act. Always loved AndyMac, but not for the Cards at this stage of his career. As has been pointed out, this is a rebuild.

No. Play the youths. He serves no purpose.