Which of these trade packages is preferable involving Donovan?

[Shady]

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/mlb/th ... 2603&ei=10

[Othawhitemeat]

Way too much for Woo, imo to give Romero, Donovan, and Walker - overreach here. Really don't like most of those packages as while it would be wise to trade Donovan, that is only if we get a haul.

[hullie]

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/mlb/th ... 2603&ei=10

I’ll edit for Craviduce to analyze it. He knows what he’s talking about

[Ace]

Way too much for Woo, imo to give Romero, Donovan, and Walker - overreach here. Really don't like most of those packages as while it would be wise to trade Donovan, that is only if we get a haul.

I can't believe ANY baseball fan would take the Woo proposal seriously, let alone think it's "too much" for Woo. Bryan Woo is one of the best young pitchers in the game and cost controlled for several years. In almost no scenario would Seattle even consider trading him. Theoretically, if they did decide to trade him, almost every team in MLB would be calling. Most assets in most organizations would be available. They wouldn't be targeting a 29 year old middling infielder and a prospect bust.

[rockondlouie]

I'd take Woo (2024-2025: 52 GS/2.92 ERA/0.91 WHiP/8.7 SO9) for Brendan Donovan, JoJo Romero and Jordan Walker in a NY Minute!

Woo is a true ACE at the FOTR and under control for four years.

If the M's made that offer, then C. Bloom would fall out of his chair reaching for the phone to accept it ASAP.

[ramfandan]

All I gotta say is if Cardinals make that trade with Seattle .... WOO-hoo !

[hullie]

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/mlb/th ... 2603&ei=10

I’ll wait for Craviduce to analyze it. He knows what he’s talking about

[mattmitchl44]

Yeah, the Woo trade would be a slam dunk.

BTV

Woo +71.7

Donovan +32.1
Romero +1
Walker +5.4

[JuanAgosto]

If Donovan is moved, I prefer a bat in return. Hopefully a 3b or OF bat. Unless you can obtain a really good pitcher in return.

[scoutyjones2]

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/mlb/th ... 2603&ei=10

Shut up Bobo

[Melville]

If Donovan is moved, I prefer a bat in return. Hopefully a 3b or OF bat. Unless you can obtain a really good pitcher in return.

Correct
One obvious move would be Donovan for Pages.
With whatever spare parts would be needed to finalize
None of the proposals in the linked article make sense

[Talkin' Baseball]

If Donovan is moved, I prefer a bat in return. Hopefully a 3b or OF bat. Unless you can obtain a really good pitcher in return.

Correct
One obvious move would be Donovan for Pages.
With whatever spare parts would be needed to finalize
None of the proposals in the linked article make sense

These are bad proposals.

[zuck698]

No way we are getting Woo at those prices. None. We would have to add a couple of our top ten prospects just to get them not to hang up the phone.

[Shady]

Getting the Yankees top two pitching prospects, Lagrange and Rodriguez, for Donovan would be a bonanza. Wouldn't the Cardinals have to add something?

[zuck698]

The Yankees two top pitching prospects would be a bonanza.

I think George Bowles from MSM is talking from his Bowels! We are never going to get Lagrange and Hess for Donovan. I will have some of what he is smoking. You got to just say no to MSM for trade proposals in the future Shady. They are usually not in align with realistic thoughts.

[hornetfb52]

Way too much for Woo, imo to give Romero, Donovan, and Walker - overreach here. Really don't like most of those packages as while it would be wise to trade Donovan, that is only if we get a haul.

In the words of cousin Eddy…
You serious Clark??