Page 1 of 4
ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 19:49 pm
by 12xu
Josh Naylor may not look like a ballplayer, but he sure plays like one. Doubles off Skubal, steals third and scores on a SF by Garver to put Seattle up 1-0. One of the slowest runners in MLB, but he has stolen 30 bases this year.
Meanwhile, George Kirby demonstrates how to pitch to Javy Baez, striking him out on three pitches out of the strike zone.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 20:02 pm
by Ozziesfan41
12xu wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 19:49 pm
Josh Naylor may not look like a ballplayer, but he sure plays like one. Doubles off Skubal, steals third and scores on a SF by Garver to put Seattle up 1-0. One of the slowest runners in MLB, but he has stolen 30 bases this year.
Meanwhile, George Kirby demonstrates how to pitch to Javy Baez, striking him out on three pitches out of the strike zone.
Yea I’m with you on that if he can steal 30 bases and Soto can steal 38 Winn has no excuse for not stealing 30
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 20:44 pm
by Carp4Cy
HR Kerry Carpenter. And that is why you never go to the pen in a shutout.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 20:54 pm
by 12xu
Carp4Cy wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 20:44 pm
HR Kerry Carpenter. And that is why you never go to the pen in a shutout.
It was the proper move, Speier just made a terrible pitch to Carpenter.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 20:56 pm
by fullswing
It’s funny listening to AJ talking like he knows more about pitching than Waino.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 21:04 pm
by Melville
Carp4Cy wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 20:44 pm
HR Kerry Carpenter. And that is why you never go to the pen in a shutout.
It was a stupid move.
And I told my wife it would backfire before Carpenter batted.
Remove a starter who has a low pitch count and who has been pitching brilliantly, in favor of a relief pitcher who is coming in cold, is likely to need a few pitches to get in rhythm, and who may or may not have his "A" stuff.
The known was a far smarter bet than the unknown and the risk factor was far greater than leaving Kirby in.
Data is extremely important, but this is a great example of common sense being sacrificed to common practice.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 21:34 pm
by 12xu
Melville wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 21:04 pm
Carp4Cy wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 20:44 pm
HR Kerry Carpenter. And that is why you never go to the pen in a shutout.
It was a stupid move.
And I told my wife it would backfire before Carpenter batted.
Remove a starter who has a low pitch count and who has been pitching brilliantly, in favor of a relief pitcher who is coming in cold, is likely to need a few pitches to get in rhythm, and who may or may not have his "A" stuff.
The known was a far smarter bet than the unknown and the risk factor was far greater than leaving Kirby in.
Data is extremely important, but this is a great example of common sense being sacrificed to common practice.
Maybe you missed game last Saturday, when Carpenter hit a 2 run bomb off Kirby? Perhaps you are unaware that Carpenter in his career is 4 for 8 off Kirby, with all 4 being HR, and 7 RBI???
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 22:14 pm
by icon
Carp4Cy wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 20:44 pm
HR Kerry Carpenter. And that is why you never go to the pen in a shutout.
I'm so tired of managers pulling stud starters for nobody middle relievers. Phils manager with Sanchez last night, and the reliever walked in the tying run. Tonight, it was Skubal pulled at 99 pitches while pitching a 2-hitter with 13 Ks, though it wasn't a shutout.
It's the pussification of starting pitchers by pencil-pushing geeks marching to the tune of "100 pitch roadblocks" and "3rd times through the order." And it has made the game worse.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 22:17 pm
by icon
12xu wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 21:34 pm
Melville wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 21:04 pm
Carp4Cy wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 20:44 pm
HR Kerry Carpenter. And that is why you never go to the pen in a shutout.
It was a stupid move.
And I told my wife it would backfire before Carpenter batted.
Remove a starter who has a low pitch count and who has been pitching brilliantly, in favor of a relief pitcher who is coming in cold, is likely to need a few pitches to get in rhythm, and who may or may not have his "A" stuff.
The known was a far smarter bet than the unknown and the risk factor was far greater than leaving Kirby in.
Data is extremely important, but this is a great example of common sense being sacrificed to common practice.
Maybe you missed game last Saturday, when Carpenter hit a 2 run bomb off Kirby? Perhaps you are unaware that Carpenter in his career is 4 for 8 off Kirby, with all 4 being HR, and 7 RBI???
Yeah, I have no problem with Kirby being pulled. Skuball being pulled at 99 pitches was dumb.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 22:23 pm
by 12xu
Helluva game! Detroit has their top of the lineup up here in the 11th, with Gilbert in for another inning.....and Carpenter singles up the middle. He now has 4 of the Tigers' 5 hits in the game.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 22:28 pm
by Cranny
Exciting game.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 22:33 pm
by 12xu
Polanco - Suarez - Naylor in the 11th for the Mariners.......one of these dudes needs to power up and end this marathon.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 22:44 pm
by CorneliusWolfe
Melville wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 21:04 pm
Carp4Cy wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 20:44 pm
HR Kerry Carpenter. And that is why you never go to the pen in a shutout.
It was a stupid move.
And I told my wife it would backfire before Carpenter batted.
Remove a starter who has a low pitch count and who has been pitching brilliantly, in favor of a relief pitcher who is coming in cold, is likely to need a few pitches to get in rhythm, and who may or may not have his "A" stuff.
The known was a far smarter bet than the unknown and the risk factor was far greater than leaving Kirby in.
Data is extremely important, but this is
a great example of common sense being sacrificed to common practice.
Well put! …I don’t know if you possess the genius intellect you claim, but you do have your moments!
…I know, not about you, only the game Lol!
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 23:06 pm
by Clubmaker2
what a joke, no ball can change direction like that without hitting the bat to do it. All america but the review ump can get this right lol
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 23:07 pm
by 12xu
I think the review folks in New York got that HBP wrong.
Re: ALDS game 5
Posted: 10 Oct 2025 23:12 pm
by ramfandan
fullswing wrote: ↑10 Oct 2025 20:56 pm
It’s funny listening to AJ talking like he knows more about pitching than Waino.
and then Waino tells the audience that Gilbert is going with his fastball .. he doesn't 82 mph ... Waino chuckles after being foooled .. then before the next pitch , he will go fastball on this one .. and he does NOT again and strikes out the batter ! lol So Waino guesses wrong twice back to back on national TV.
So Waino had his moment too