STLtoday.com

1) Scott CF
2) Saggese 2B
3) Wetherholt 3B
4) LaViolette DH
5) Herrera C
6) Gorman 1B
7) Walker RF
Eight) Davis LF
9) Winn SS

Looks good. Give us another one of these in a few weeks.

If all those guys come up and Walker still can't get out of 7th..

Next five years:

1) Noot RF
2) Wetherholt 2B
3) Donovan LF
4) ????? 3B (After NADO's gone)
5) Herrera DH
6) ????? 1B (After WillyC's gone)
7) Crooks C
8 - Scott CF
9) Winn SS

????? needs to come via trades and free agents.

I would hope for more pop. Also, if there is no Arenado, Nootbaar, or Donovan I would expect someone of significance to plug in.

rockondlouie wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:43 am Next five years:

1) Noot RF
2) Wetherholt 2B
3) Donovan LF
4) ????? 3B (After NADO's gone)
5) Herrera DH
6) ????? 1B (After WillyC's gone)
7) Crooks C
8 - Scott CF
9) Winn SS

????? needs to come via trades and free agents.

You are underestimating Saggese. He's just scratching the surface as an MLB hitter. He's going to be a good one for a long time. Wetherholt may be a better eventual MLB hitter than Saggese. But that's certainly not a given. I guess we will have to just wait and see. The future catcher situation is fluid, indeed.

rockondlouie wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:43 am Next five years:

1) Noot RF
2) Wetherholt 2B
3) Donovan LF
4) ????? 3B (After NADO's gone)
5) Herrera DH
6) ????? 1B (After WillyC's gone)
7) Crooks C
8 - Scott CF
9) Winn SS

????? needs to come via trades and free agents.

Nootbar will be a Dodger in the next few years if not this year via trade or after 2027 as a free agent

Shady wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:47 am

rockondlouie wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:43 am Next five years:

1) Noot RF
2) Wetherholt 2B
3) Donovan LF
4) ????? 3B (After NADO's gone)
5) Herrera DH
6) ????? 1B (After WillyC's gone)
7) Crooks C
8 - Scott CF
9) Winn SS

????? needs to come via trades and free agents.

You are underestimating Saggese. He's just scratching the surface as an MLB hitter. He's going to be a good one for a long time. Wetherholt may be a better eventual MLB hitter than Saggese. But that's certainly not a given. I guess we will have to just wait and see. The future catcher situation is fluid, indeed.

He's not a fit at 3rd base (power bat position), not going to block JJW at 2nd either if the kid is who we think he is.

kyace wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:48 am

rockondlouie wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:43 am Next five years:

1) Noot RF
2) Wetherholt 2B
3) Donovan LF
4) ????? 3B (After NADO's gone)
5) Herrera DH
6) ????? 1B (After WillyC's gone)
7) Crooks C
8 - Scott CF
9) Winn SS

????? needs to come via trades and free agents.

Nootbar will be a Dodger in the next few years if not this year via trade or after 2027 as a free agent

Nope, they'll go big for Tucker if he hits the open market.

I expect Noot & Donovan to ink extensions in the next year or so.

VS2 CF
Noot RF
Donovan LF
Wetherholt 3B
Herrera/Gorman 1B
Crooks/Bernal C
Gorman/Herrera DH
Sagesse 2B
Winn SS

Just using current players in the system, but always kinda silly to project out very far if we followed this out a couple years.
Talk about a cost controlled lineup, which IF this turned out to be anywhere close the Cards FO would need to invest into some top notch pitching or continue to potentially lose more of its fan base, or invest into a Kyle Tucker type position player (pause for laughter).

Shady wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:07 am 1) Scott CF
2) Saggese 2B
3) Wetherholt 3B
4) LaViolette DH
5) Herrera C
6) Gorman 1B
7) Walker RF
Eight) Davis LF
9) Winn SS

Hmmm. Don’t know. You have three guys listed with no major league experience. Two that have yet to prove they can play at this level. And no Noot or Donovan ? I’m not sure that’s a winning line up.

Jatalk wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 16:06 pm

Shady wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 11:07 am 1) Scott CF
2) Saggese 2B
3) Wetherholt 3B
4) LaViolette DH
5) Herrera C
6) Gorman 1B
7) Walker RF
Eight) Davis LF
9) Winn SS

Hmmm. Don’t know. You have three guys listed with no major league experience. Two that have yet to prove they can play at this level. And no Noot or Donovan ? I’m not sure that’s a winning line up.

I shoulkd have specified this being a 3 year lineup projection. Obviously, a lot can happen between now and then. Maybe Donovan is still around and is still very productive.

1. Scott CF
2. Saggese 2B
3. Burleson LF
4. Burleson LF
5. Saggese 2B
6. Burleson LF
7. Burleson LF
8. Saggese 2B
9. Burleson LF

But now if Burleson doesn't "pick it up" here, we may need to reconsider this

imadangman wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 16:58 pm 1. Scott CF
2. Saggese 2B
3. Burleson LF
4. Burleson LF
5. Saggese 2B
6. Burleson LF
7. Burleson LF
8. Saggese
9. Burleson LF

But now if Burleson doesn't "pick it up" here, we may need to reconsider this

How clever.

Shady wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 16:59 pm

imadangman wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 16:58 pm 1. Scott CF
2. Saggese 2B
3. Burleson LF
4. Burleson LF
5. Saggese 2B
6. Burleson LF
7. Burleson LF
8. Saggese
9. Burleson LF

But now if Burleson doesn't "pick it up" here, we may need to reconsider this

How clever.

Thank you

imadangman wrote: ↑27 Apr 2025 16:58 pm 1. Scott CF
2. Saggese 2B
3. Burleson LF
4. Burleson LF
5. Saggese 2B
6. Burleson LF
7. Burleson LF
8. Saggese
9. Burleson LF

But now if Burleson doesn't "pick it up" here, we may need to reconsider this

Starting rotation:
Roby
Mathews
Roby
Roby
Roby

Bullpen:
Munoz
Munoz
Pallante
Munoz
Hence
Liberatore
Munoz
Munoz