Victor Scott has earned a spot on this team

[bfib]

So naturally, Siani will come north with the team

[Alex Reyes Cy Young]

So naturally, Siani will come north with the team

I don't think so, I think Scott made a big statement this game and honestly throughout ST'ing. He'll be on this team IMO. But to your point if there is 1 team who would send him down it's yours truly.

[BrummerStealsHome]

Victor Scott has earned a spot on this team

Revren!

[General]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

[TheFantasyStud]

I hope they give Vic some runway. Let him start the first 10 games and get comfortable.

[scoutyjones2]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

Agree with this thinking. If VS2 isn't starting almost every game, then he goes to AAA

[bfib]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

Agree with this thinking. If VS2 isn't starting almost every game, then he goes to AAA

Why?

There will be plenty of reps even if there is a pseudo time share.

This does point to the organizations failure to move Arenado though and the consequences

[General]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

Agree with this thinking. If VS2 isn't starting almost every game, then he goes to AAA

Why?

There will be plenty of reps even if there is a pseudo time share.

This does point to the organizations failure to move Arenado though and the consequences

It won't be any kind of time share. Noot will begin the season as the starting CFer and the backup may get 1-2 starts a week at most. If that changes and if Vic is hitting while playing every day in AAA, Vic can be brought up. At this point, however, Vic hasn't shown the slightest indication that he can his anything above AA.

If you really are high on Vic, you want him in AAA so he can develop for the long term.

The inability to move Arenado was a problem but it's over and time to move on. I will say, he did get traded to one of the five teams he said he would go to only to ultimately turn it down. I can't blame the org for that, especially with the limitations they were under.

[HOUCARD]

He should be the starter in CF with Noot in LF and Walker in RF.

[thetank2]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

Agree with this thinking. If VS2 isn't starting almost every game, then he goes to AAA

Why?

There will be plenty of reps even if there is a pseudo time share.

This does point to the organizations failure to move Arenado though and the consequences

If this team is such a failure why did average 90 wins over 14 full seasons from 2008-2022. You think by keeping mentioning this you can re-write history.

[Ozziesfan41]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

Agree with this thinking. If VS2 isn't starting almost every game, then he goes to AAA

Why?

There will be plenty of reps even if there is a pseudo time share.

This does point to the organizations failure to move Arenado though and the consequences

If this team is such a failure why did average 90 wins over 14 full seasons from 2008-2022. You think by keeping mentioning this you can re-write history.

What does past success have to do with current failure?

[imetsatchelpaige]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

Agree with this thinking. If VS2 isn't starting almost every game, then he goes to AAA

Why?

There will be plenty of reps even if there is a pseudo time share.

This does point to the organizations failure to move Arenado though and the consequences

If this team is such a failure why did average 90 wins over 14 full seasons from 2008-2022. You think by keeping mentioning this you can re-write history.

And averaged 74 wins in '23 and '24. See how that works?

[riff raff]

He should be the starter in CF with Noot in LF and Walker in RF.

I agree. He's earned it.

[vegascardsfan5890]

With Scott on the team I really like the different lineups this team could use every day

Vs RH

CF Scott
RF Noot
1B Contreras
3B Arenado
LF Donovan
DH Burleson
C Herrera
2B Gorman
SS Winn

Vs LF
SS Winn
LF Noot
1B Contreras
3B Arenado
2B Donovan
C Herrera
DH Baker
RF Walker
CF Scott

[hilton head is 4 idiots]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

No.

No one remembers Scott "EARNING" a spot last year, including you.

Scott was given the assignment because of injuries to the IGNITER, Edman, and Carlson.

Now, a year later, Scott has shown improvement necessary to say he is worthy of being here.

[scoutyjones2]

Remember when Vic "earned" a spot last year, was futile in the Majors, and then did poorly in AAA? He hasn't shown he can hit anything above AA pitching yet.

Neither Vic nor Siani can hit so Noot will be given every opportunity to be the starting CFer. In that case, it is blatantly obvious to have Siani make the team as backup CFer and defensive replacement while Vic goes back to AAA to get regular reps and see if he's figured out how to hit AAA pitching yet.

If yo think Vic can me a legit MLer, he needs to keep developing in the minors.

At this point, they are the same player although I'd say Siani is the better defensive player at this point.

No.

No one remembers Scott "EARNING" a spot last year, including you.

Scott was given the assignment because of injuries to the IGNITER, Edman, and Carlson.

Now, a year later, Scott has shown improvement necessary to say he is worthy of being here.

He did well last spring training...how'd that turn out both in the minors and at MLB?