Page 3 of 3
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 14 Jun 2025 06:51 am
by JDW
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:13 pm
Cranny wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:47 am
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:41 am
Cranny wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:32 am
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
Should have promoted Antico or Church.
Yes....or the bat boy. Try something new at least.
Right. Sometimes change can keep the interest up.
McGee was just a short term until he became the CF. Albert was just supposed to fill in for a while and look at how that turned out. I mean, give some people a chance instead of running out these effing cast offs that couldn't make it with other teams. FFS.
Wait, or you saying it's possible Church or Antico could be the next Pujols or McGee just given the MLB opportunity?
Just messing with you, lol.
When what begins to look like a career milb guy like Koperniak or Antico don't get much opportunity at the show, I am disappointed for them, and don't always understand why they get stuck in AAA when sometimes their milb numbers look good, but the complications with the 40 man is part of the reason.
Anyway, Siani has been up before and provided some positive value for the team. He is only 25.
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 14 Jun 2025 08:16 am
by scoutyjones2
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:02 am
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 18:42 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:10 pm
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 12:06 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
So who should be called up? One thing to (bleep) and moan and make statement like "The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again?" but offer no solution.
I am sure you are too clueless to realize Siani is hitting 263/348/451/800 at Memphis...
Meanwhile, Argo keeps sinking to depth not seen before:
June, 9 games: 120/290/120/410
Siani can hit in Memphis. That's your play? LOL As for who could they call up? I don't follow the minors but I'm sure some could show you some examples of people that deserve a try and could be much better. Like I said, if not then go out and make a trade. Stop putting these no hit turds in the starting lineup.
No, that's not my play. But Argo isn't hitting up here and no need for Villade...why not Siani? Who else can they call up to take over in CF and keep the defensive above average?
So you just like to criticize but not do any investigation who else could be a possible solution...got it.
The Cards are full of non hitting players. Nothing to get worked up over in the minors.
You just never know when you give a young player a chance. As I said, McGee and Albert both were just supposed to fill in. Enough with Siani, he was given a lot of rope and he hung himself with it. I don't care if they bring up a young guy and give him a chance. Siani failed in Cincy and he failed in St Louis. Enough with the love for a no hit CF that plays a little above avg defense. They keep running these cast offs out there because they're cheap. They don't want to start the clock on a young guy. You know it and I know it. Gorman should go to the minors, everyone knows it. Noot isn't cutting it, everyone knows it. While Arenado is struggling toward the end of his career, at least he was a star. Who the hell wants to pay money to watch Siani or Vlade play. Not me.
Are you paying money to watch the Cards? I don't!
And you may "know it" but you don't.
Were you claiming all this during May?
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 14 Jun 2025 08:51 am
by rockondlouie
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:11 pm
rockondlouie wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 11:40 am
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
+1
Mo has just mailed in this season.
The c r a p he's been bringing up for the bullpen, while leaving Andre Granillo (looked darn good) in Memphis until last night, plus these horrible callups like Vilade and now Sinai proves he's already checked out and is just going through the motions.
Just quietly leave at the ASB Mo and hand the keys over to C. Bloom.
I mean they could at least try to look like they care about winning. This is sad.
And why on earth was Oli playing him?

Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 14 Jun 2025 11:29 am
by CCard
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:36 am
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:02 am
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 18:42 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:10 pm
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 12:06 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
So who should be called up? One thing to (bleep) and moan and make statement like "The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again?" but offer no solution.
I am sure you are too clueless to realize Siani is hitting 263/348/451/800 at Memphis...
Meanwhile, Argo keeps sinking to depth not seen before:
June, 9 games: 120/290/120/410
Siani can hit in Memphis. That's your play? LOL As for who could they call up? I don't follow the minors but I'm sure some could show you some examples of people that deserve a try and could be much better. Like I said, if not then go out and make a trade. Stop putting these no hit turds in the starting lineup.
No, that's not my play. But Argo isn't hitting up here and no need for Villade...why not Siani? Who else can they call up to take over in CF and keep the defensive above average?
So you just like to criticize but not do any investigation who else could be a possible solution...got it.
The Cards are full of non hitting players. Nothing to get worked up over in the minors.
You just never know when you give a young player a chance. As I said, McGee and Albert both were just supposed to fill in. Enough with Siani, he was given a lot of rope and he hung himself with it. I don't care if they bring up a young guy and give him a chance. Siani failed in Cincy and he failed in St Louis. Enough with the love for a no hit CF that plays a little above avg defense. They keep running these cast offs out there because they're cheap. They don't want to start the clock on a young guy. You know it and I know it. Gorman should go to the minors, everyone knows it. Noot isn't cutting it, everyone knows it. While Arenado is struggling toward the end of his career, at least he was a star. Who the hell wants to pay money to watch Siani or Vlade play. Not me.
Siani was just brought up because they needed an OFer. It’s not like Oli declared him a starter.
Siani barely played in April
Siani barely played because he can't hit and people were (bleep) about it, add with that Scott playing good and there you go. You just know they're going to stick him in every chance they get.
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 14 Jun 2025 18:23 pm
by ecleme22
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 11:29 am
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:36 am
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:02 am
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 18:42 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:10 pm
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 12:06 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
So who should be called up? One thing to (bleep) and moan and make statement like "The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again?" but offer no solution.
I am sure you are too clueless to realize Siani is hitting 263/348/451/800 at Memphis...
Meanwhile, Argo keeps sinking to depth not seen before:
June, 9 games: 120/290/120/410
Siani can hit in Memphis. That's your play? LOL As for who could they call up? I don't follow the minors but I'm sure some could show you some examples of people that deserve a try and could be much better. Like I said, if not then go out and make a trade. Stop putting these no hit turds in the starting lineup.
No, that's not my play. But Argo isn't hitting up here and no need for Villade...why not Siani? Who else can they call up to take over in CF and keep the defensive above average?
So you just like to criticize but not do any investigation who else could be a possible solution...got it.
The Cards are full of non hitting players. Nothing to get worked up over in the minors.
You just never know when you give a young player a chance. As I said, McGee and Albert both were just supposed to fill in. Enough with Siani, he was given a lot of rope and he hung himself with it. I don't care if they bring up a young guy and give him a chance. Siani failed in Cincy and he failed in St Louis. Enough with the love for a no hit CF that plays a little above avg defense. They keep running these cast offs out there because they're cheap. They don't want to start the clock on a young guy. You know it and I know it. Gorman should go to the minors, everyone knows it. Noot isn't cutting it, everyone knows it. While Arenado is struggling toward the end of his career, at least he was a star. Who the hell wants to pay money to watch Siani or Vlade play. Not me.
Siani was just brought up because they needed an OFer. It’s not like Oli declared him a starter.
Siani barely played in April
Siani barely played because he can't hit and people were (bleep) about it, add with that Scott playing good and there you go. You just know they're going to stick him in every chance they get.
He played so much in 2024 because the team had no one else.
He played so little in April because they had someone else (Scott).
And looky here, Siani was just optioned to AAA.
Your panic about Siani was wrong and laughable.
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 14 Jun 2025 21:33 pm
by CCard
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 18:23 pm
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 11:29 am
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:36 am
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:02 am
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 18:42 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:10 pm
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 12:06 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
So who should be called up? One thing to (bleep) and moan and make statement like "The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again?" but offer no solution.
I am sure you are too clueless to realize Siani is hitting 263/348/451/800 at Memphis...
Meanwhile, Argo keeps sinking to depth not seen before:
June, 9 games: 120/290/120/410
Siani can hit in Memphis. That's your play? LOL As for who could they call up? I don't follow the minors but I'm sure some could show you some examples of people that deserve a try and could be much better. Like I said, if not then go out and make a trade. Stop putting these no hit turds in the starting lineup.
No, that's not my play. But Argo isn't hitting up here and no need for Villade...why not Siani? Who else can they call up to take over in CF and keep the defensive above average?
So you just like to criticize but not do any investigation who else could be a possible solution...got it.
The Cards are full of non hitting players. Nothing to get worked up over in the minors.
You just never know when you give a young player a chance. As I said, McGee and Albert both were just supposed to fill in. Enough with Siani, he was given a lot of rope and he hung himself with it. I don't care if they bring up a young guy and give him a chance. Siani failed in Cincy and he failed in St Louis. Enough with the love for a no hit CF that plays a little above avg defense. They keep running these cast offs out there because they're cheap. They don't want to start the clock on a young guy. You know it and I know it. Gorman should go to the minors, everyone knows it. Noot isn't cutting it, everyone knows it. While Arenado is struggling toward the end of his career, at least he was a star. Who the hell wants to pay money to watch Siani or Vlade play. Not me.
Siani was just brought up because they needed an OFer. It’s not like Oli declared him a starter.
Siani barely played in April
Siani barely played because he can't hit and people were (bleep) about it, add with that Scott playing good and there you go. You just know they're going to stick him in every chance they get.
He played so much in 2024 because the team had no one else.
He played so little in April because they had someone else (Scott).
And looky here, Siani was just optioned to AAA.
Your panic about Siani was wrong and laughable.
You love Siani. I get it.
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 14 Jun 2025 23:44 pm
by ecleme22
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 21:33 pm
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 18:23 pm
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 11:29 am
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:36 am
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:02 am
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 18:42 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:10 pm
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 12:06 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
So who should be called up? One thing to (bleep) and moan and make statement like "The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again?" but offer no solution.
I am sure you are too clueless to realize Siani is hitting 263/348/451/800 at Memphis...
Meanwhile, Argo keeps sinking to depth not seen before:
June, 9 games: 120/290/120/410
Siani can hit in Memphis. That's your play? LOL As for who could they call up? I don't follow the minors but I'm sure some could show you some examples of people that deserve a try and could be much better. Like I said, if not then go out and make a trade. Stop putting these no hit turds in the starting lineup.
No, that's not my play. But Argo isn't hitting up here and no need for Villade...why not Siani? Who else can they call up to take over in CF and keep the defensive above average?
So you just like to criticize but not do any investigation who else could be a possible solution...got it.
The Cards are full of non hitting players. Nothing to get worked up over in the minors.
You just never know when you give a young player a chance. As I said, McGee and Albert both were just supposed to fill in. Enough with Siani, he was given a lot of rope and he hung himself with it. I don't care if they bring up a young guy and give him a chance. Siani failed in Cincy and he failed in St Louis. Enough with the love for a no hit CF that plays a little above avg defense. They keep running these cast offs out there because they're cheap. They don't want to start the clock on a young guy. You know it and I know it. Gorman should go to the minors, everyone knows it. Noot isn't cutting it, everyone knows it. While Arenado is struggling toward the end of his career, at least he was a star. Who the hell wants to pay money to watch Siani or Vlade play. Not me.
Siani was just brought up because they needed an OFer. It’s not like Oli declared him a starter.
Siani barely played in April
Siani barely played because he can't hit and people were (bleep) about it, add with that Scott playing good and there you go. You just know they're going to stick him in every chance they get.
He played so much in 2024 because the team had no one else.
He played so little in April because they had someone else (Scott).
And looky here, Siani was just optioned to AAA.
Your panic about Siani was wrong and laughable.
You love Siani. I get it.
That’s a cop out. And you know it.
And no, I don’t love Siani. At all.
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 15 Jun 2025 08:30 am
by CCard
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 23:44 pm
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 21:33 pm
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 18:23 pm
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 11:29 am
ecleme22 wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:36 am
CCard wrote: ↑14 Jun 2025 06:02 am
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 18:42 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 16:10 pm
scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 12:06 pm
CCard wrote: ↑13 Jun 2025 10:30 am
Come on Cards management. The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again? This is disrespectful to the fans. How are you going to sell tickets with these below avg players you keep putting in? Winning breeds ticket sales. You can't win with guys that can't hit. Disgraceful. If we have no minor league outfielders then trade for one.
So who should be called up? One thing to (bleep) and moan and make statement like "The minors is full of outfielders and we have to suffer through Vilade and now Siani again?" but offer no solution.
I am sure you are too clueless to realize Siani is hitting 263/348/451/800 at Memphis...
Meanwhile, Argo keeps sinking to depth not seen before:
June, 9 games: 120/290/120/410
Siani can hit in Memphis. That's your play? LOL As for who could they call up? I don't follow the minors but I'm sure some could show you some examples of people that deserve a try and could be much better. Like I said, if not then go out and make a trade. Stop putting these no hit turds in the starting lineup.
No, that's not my play. But Argo isn't hitting up here and no need for Villade...why not Siani? Who else can they call up to take over in CF and keep the defensive above average?
So you just like to criticize but not do any investigation who else could be a possible solution...got it.
The Cards are full of non hitting players. Nothing to get worked up over in the minors.
You just never know when you give a young player a chance. As I said, McGee and Albert both were just supposed to fill in. Enough with Siani, he was given a lot of rope and he hung himself with it. I don't care if they bring up a young guy and give him a chance. Siani failed in Cincy and he failed in St Louis. Enough with the love for a no hit CF that plays a little above avg defense. They keep running these cast offs out there because they're cheap. They don't want to start the clock on a young guy. You know it and I know it. Gorman should go to the minors, everyone knows it. Noot isn't cutting it, everyone knows it. While Arenado is struggling toward the end of his career, at least he was a star. Who the hell wants to pay money to watch Siani or Vlade play. Not me.
Siani was just brought up because they needed an OFer. It’s not like Oli declared him a starter.
Siani barely played in April
Siani barely played because he can't hit and people were (bleep) about it, add with that Scott playing good and there you go. You just know they're going to stick him in every chance they get.
He played so much in 2024 because the team had no one else.
He played so little in April because they had someone else (Scott).
And looky here, Siani was just optioned to AAA.
Your panic about Siani was wrong and laughable.
You love Siani. I get it.
That’s a cop out. And you know it.
And no, I don’t love Siani. At all.
He failed in Cincy. He failed in St Louis. They finally sent him to AAA. Then they brought him back when Vlade was even worse. You can see why I would be cynical and believe they could and should visit other options. Right?
Re: Siani for Vilade.....We're saved!!!!!
Posted: 18 Jun 2025 07:12 am
by Absolut
The temptation has been removed
• OF Ryan Vilade: Claimed by Reds after being designated for assignment on June 12