Which Cruz?

[C-Unit]

Oneil vs Elly

Elly has had more hype all along it seems. It has appeared several times that he is on the verge of a breakout season, or in the midst of one. But his offensive numbers have not yet been anywhere near what people think he's capable of.

Oneil on the other hand, you can argue has disappointed or just not materialized. But he comes into 2026 participating in a lineup that has a few more names in it including Marcell Ozuna. What are the odds Elly has another similar season to the ones he's already had and Oneil Cruz hits 35 homers? And I think they'll shift him to right and have Jhostynxin Garcia in center.

Speaking of Ozuna, I imagine it's possible either Cruz could end up having a similar later career peak.

[scoutyjones2]

Oneal Cruz can't sniff Ellys junk

[BrummerStealsHome]

Jose

[Cardinals4Life]

Oneil vs Elly

Elly has had more hype all along it seems. It has appeared several times that he is on the verge of a breakout season, or in the midst of one. But his offensive numbers have not yet been anywhere near what people think he's capable of.

Oneil on the other hand, you can argue has disappointed or just not materialized. But he comes into 2026 participating in a lineup that has a few more names in it including Marcell Ozuna. What are the odds Elly has another similar season to the ones he's already had and Oneil Cruz hits 35 homers? And I think they'll shift him to right and have Jhostynxin Garcia in center.

Speaking of Ozuna, I imagine it's possible either Cruz could end up having a similar later career peak.

Both are severely overrated. All flash, very little sizzle. Dime a dozen.

[Melville]

Oneal Cruz can't sniff Ellys junk

Probably a good thing.
Both likely prefer it that way.

[C-Unit]

Oneil vs Elly

Elly has had more hype all along it seems. It has appeared several times that he is on the verge of a breakout season, or in the midst of one. But his offensive numbers have not yet been anywhere near what people think he's capable of.

Oneil on the other hand, you can argue has disappointed or just not materialized. But he comes into 2026 participating in a lineup that has a few more names in it including Marcell Ozuna. What are the odds Elly has another similar season to the ones he's already had and Oneil Cruz hits 35 homers? And I think they'll shift him to right and have Jhostynxin Garcia in center.

Speaking of Ozuna, I imagine it's possible either Cruz could end up having a similar later career peak.

Both are severely overrated. All flash, very little sizzle. Dime a dozen.

How long do they last in MLB. Grichuk just notched his 10th season, why wouldn't these two have nice long careers?

[Cardinals4Life]

Oneil vs Elly

Elly has had more hype all along it seems. It has appeared several times that he is on the verge of a breakout season, or in the midst of one. But his offensive numbers have not yet been anywhere near what people think he's capable of.

Oneil on the other hand, you can argue has disappointed or just not materialized. But he comes into 2026 participating in a lineup that has a few more names in it including Marcell Ozuna. What are the odds Elly has another similar season to the ones he's already had and Oneil Cruz hits 35 homers? And I think they'll shift him to right and have Jhostynxin Garcia in center.

Speaking of Ozuna, I imagine it's possible either Cruz could end up having a similar later career peak.

Both are severely overrated. All flash, very little sizzle. Dime a dozen.

How long do they last in MLB. Grichuk just notched his 10th season, why wouldn't these two have nice long careers?

They might, but they will get several years because of the "hype" alone.

[kscardsfan]

Jose

Took my answer. Not to forget Heity.

[moose-and-squirrel]

Jose

Took my answer. Not to forget Heity.

and you just took my reply lol

there was a 3rd one, right?

[kscardsfan]

Jose

Took my answer. Not to forget Heity.

and you just took my reply lol

there was a 3rd one, right?

Tommy.

[Just Whit]

Pablo

[dugoutrex]

Ted as a 'supreme' - lmfao

[Talkin' Baseball]

Oneil vs Elly

Elly has had more hype all along it seems. It has appeared several times that he is on the verge of a breakout season, or in the midst of one. But his offensive numbers have not yet been anywhere near what people think he's capable of.

Oneil on the other hand, you can argue has disappointed or just not materialized. But he comes into 2026 participating in a lineup that has a few more names in it including Marcell Ozuna. What are the odds Elly has another similar season to the ones he's already had and Oneil Cruz hits 35 homers? And I think they'll shift him to right and have Jhostynxin Garcia in center.

Speaking of Ozuna, I imagine it's possible either Cruz could end up having a similar later career peak.

Both are severely overrated. All flash, very little sizzle. Dime a dozen.

Agree. Severely overrated.

[kscardsfan]

Oneal Cruz can't sniff Ellys junk

Why would he try? Would you?

[BrummerStealsHome]

Jose

Took my answer. Not to forget Heity.

I liked Heity. Before he was Heity he was Hector, and led the Cardinals in home runs one year . . . with 13!

[kscardsfan]

Jose

Took my answer. Not to forget Heity.

I liked Heity. Before he was Heity he was Hector, and led the Cardinals in home runs one year . . . with 13!

Would have been nice to have kept Jose. Good hitter. Could run.