Like "Short Haired Beatles" vs. "Long Haired Beatles".
Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Blues Talk Moderators
-
ShakeyWalton
- Forum User
- Posts: 386
- Joined: 27 May 2024 13:22 pm
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Cronin helped create for sure until he was allowed full control of the band after his second number one hit “Can’t Fight This Feeling”. Richrath was demoted and they sank like The Titanic. It was ok having a ballad or two per album, but Cronin went full on soft and killed them. They lost their contract when Gary left.netboy65 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 08:50 amI have seen them live almost 50x, including plenty with Gary. I always laugh at the notion that Cronin “destroyed” the band. He was with then during the 70s too so why wasn’t the band destroyed then? Epic was going to drop them until Hi Infidelity came out. A lot of bands had to change their sound to keep afloat. Look at Aerosmith starting with Permanent Vacation.ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026 21:18 pmMan, am I envious of you sir! I wasn’t born until 1981, so I never came close to seeing Gary. He’s my guitar idol though, just ahead of Rory Gallagher. Richrath had so much more to offer us musically, but depression, alcohol and drugs, not to mention Cronin destroying the band, did Gary in. What concerts did you see and what were the venues?blues2112 wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026 20:45 pmConsider myself blessed to have heard Gary's Guitar Solo live a few times. Absolute shredder with an ear for melody and phrasing. Hardcore Gibson with Marshall stack, no finger-tapping and only one record with whammy bar. And that crybaby wah pedal .....ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑08 Feb 2026 15:13 pmI'm listening to a live recording of theirs from 1979 right now during the Nine Lives tour. Richrath was just amazing. REO from 1977 until 1982 were hands down the best live performers out there. Don't get me started on that dreadful Wheels album...netboy65 wrote: ↑08 Feb 2026 13:02 pmAs a huge REO fan, the Live album is their best by a country mile.blues2112 wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 21:32 pmTuna, Nine Lives, HiFi, Good Trouble (kinda, not really), Wheels, great string of records. Same for Styx until Kilroy. And Rush. And Journey.Aesa wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 20:55 pmHey Jack... did you mean Hot Tuna or You Can Tune a Piano But You Can't Tuna Fish?Inglewood Jack wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 20:37 pm Ohh darn, I thought the Rumors were that they were being traded for REO Speedwagon, or Tuna Fish..... Is that an E4?![]()
Having said that, truly, the amount of great "new" rock music the past 20 years is overwhelming: Red Sun Rising, Shinedown, Sleep Token, Seether, A Perfect Circle, anything with Chris Cornell, etc.
I listened to old stuff either through nostalgia or forced from canned music at grocery store!
As far as the earlier posts about Boston’s debut, it WAS great until radio beat it to death for the last 50 years. I much prefer Don’t Look Back now. Tunes like, Used to Bad News, A Man I’ll Never Be, Party, Feelin Satisfied, great stuff.
-
Inglewood Jack
- Forum User
- Posts: 283
- Joined: 23 May 2024 13:42 pm
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Speaking of a "Gary", albeit a different one. I grew up a huge Rush fan, and went to the Grace Under Pressure tour. The opening act was this guitarist who just blew my socks off. Left the show going "who the heck was that!?!" as I thought he put on a better show than Rush that evening. I hadn't expanded my music taste at that point, but Gary Moore definitely got me started on a journey... Still ongoing...
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Gary left mostly because he still wanted the rock and roll lifestyle and the rest of the band were trying to clean themselves up.ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 15:35 pmCronin helped create for sure until he was allowed full control of the band after his second number one hit “Can’t Fight This Feeling”. Richrath was demoted and they sank like The Titanic. It was ok having a ballad or two per album, but Cronin went full on soft and killed them. They lost their contract when Gary left.netboy65 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 08:50 amI have seen them live almost 50x, including plenty with Gary. I always laugh at the notion that Cronin “destroyed” the band. He was with then during the 70s too so why wasn’t the band destroyed then? Epic was going to drop them until Hi Infidelity came out. A lot of bands had to change their sound to keep afloat. Look at Aerosmith starting with Permanent Vacation.ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026 21:18 pmMan, am I envious of you sir! I wasn’t born until 1981, so I never came close to seeing Gary. He’s my guitar idol though, just ahead of Rory Gallagher. Richrath had so much more to offer us musically, but depression, alcohol and drugs, not to mention Cronin destroying the band, did Gary in. What concerts did you see and what were the venues?blues2112 wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026 20:45 pmConsider myself blessed to have heard Gary's Guitar Solo live a few times. Absolute shredder with an ear for melody and phrasing. Hardcore Gibson with Marshall stack, no finger-tapping and only one record with whammy bar. And that crybaby wah pedal .....ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑08 Feb 2026 15:13 pmI'm listening to a live recording of theirs from 1979 right now during the Nine Lives tour. Richrath was just amazing. REO from 1977 until 1982 were hands down the best live performers out there. Don't get me started on that dreadful Wheels album...netboy65 wrote: ↑08 Feb 2026 13:02 pmAs a huge REO fan, the Live album is their best by a country mile.blues2112 wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 21:32 pmTuna, Nine Lives, HiFi, Good Trouble (kinda, not really), Wheels, great string of records. Same for Styx until Kilroy. And Rush. And Journey.Aesa wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 20:55 pmHey Jack... did you mean Hot Tuna or You Can Tune a Piano But You Can't Tuna Fish?Inglewood Jack wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 20:37 pm Ohh darn, I thought the Rumors were that they were being traded for REO Speedwagon, or Tuna Fish..... Is that an E4?![]()
Having said that, truly, the amount of great "new" rock music the past 20 years is overwhelming: Red Sun Rising, Shinedown, Sleep Token, Seether, A Perfect Circle, anything with Chris Cornell, etc.
I listened to old stuff either through nostalgia or forced from canned music at grocery store!
As far as the earlier posts about Boston’s debut, it WAS great until radio beat it to death for the last 50 years. I much prefer Don’t Look Back now. Tunes like, Used to Bad News, A Man I’ll Never Be, Party, Feelin Satisfied, great stuff.
Fact is Kevin and Gary truly needed each other. Neither did squat without the other.
-
ShakeyWalton
- Forum User
- Posts: 386
- Joined: 27 May 2024 13:22 pm
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Very true.netboy65 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 16:30 pmGary left mostly because he still wanted the rock and roll lifestyle and the rest of the band were trying to clean themselves up.ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 15:35 pmCronin helped create for sure until he was allowed full control of the band after his second number one hit “Can’t Fight This Feeling”. Richrath was demoted and they sank like The Titanic. It was ok having a ballad or two per album, but Cronin went full on soft and killed them. They lost their contract when Gary left.netboy65 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 08:50 amI have seen them live almost 50x, including plenty with Gary. I always laugh at the notion that Cronin “destroyed” the band. He was with then during the 70s too so why wasn’t the band destroyed then? Epic was going to drop them until Hi Infidelity came out. A lot of bands had to change their sound to keep afloat. Look at Aerosmith starting with Permanent Vacation.ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026 21:18 pmMan, am I envious of you sir! I wasn’t born until 1981, so I never came close to seeing Gary. He’s my guitar idol though, just ahead of Rory Gallagher. Richrath had so much more to offer us musically, but depression, alcohol and drugs, not to mention Cronin destroying the band, did Gary in. What concerts did you see and what were the venues?blues2112 wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026 20:45 pmConsider myself blessed to have heard Gary's Guitar Solo live a few times. Absolute shredder with an ear for melody and phrasing. Hardcore Gibson with Marshall stack, no finger-tapping and only one record with whammy bar. And that crybaby wah pedal .....ShakeyWalton wrote: ↑08 Feb 2026 15:13 pmI'm listening to a live recording of theirs from 1979 right now during the Nine Lives tour. Richrath was just amazing. REO from 1977 until 1982 were hands down the best live performers out there. Don't get me started on that dreadful Wheels album...netboy65 wrote: ↑08 Feb 2026 13:02 pmAs a huge REO fan, the Live album is their best by a country mile.blues2112 wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 21:32 pmTuna, Nine Lives, HiFi, Good Trouble (kinda, not really), Wheels, great string of records. Same for Styx until Kilroy. And Rush. And Journey.Aesa wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 20:55 pmHey Jack... did you mean Hot Tuna or You Can Tune a Piano But You Can't Tuna Fish?Inglewood Jack wrote: ↑07 Feb 2026 20:37 pm Ohh darn, I thought the Rumors were that they were being traded for REO Speedwagon, or Tuna Fish..... Is that an E4?![]()
Having said that, truly, the amount of great "new" rock music the past 20 years is overwhelming: Red Sun Rising, Shinedown, Sleep Token, Seether, A Perfect Circle, anything with Chris Cornell, etc.
I listened to old stuff either through nostalgia or forced from canned music at grocery store!
As far as the earlier posts about Boston’s debut, it WAS great until radio beat it to death for the last 50 years. I much prefer Don’t Look Back now. Tunes like, Used to Bad News, A Man I’ll Never Be, Party, Feelin Satisfied, great stuff.
Fact is Kevin and Gary truly needed each other. Neither did squat without the other.
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Was the stage a revolving turntable?leedog68 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 18:14 pm I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
If so, I was there!
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Not quite. The three LP's released after Green left all had their moments, especially those featuring Danny Kirwan.
Station Man
https://youtu.be/ulcrYsi64zo?si=-hzeNwnXZHargeyy
-
ShakeyWalton
- Forum User
- Posts: 386
- Joined: 27 May 2024 13:22 pm
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
I’d have done anything to be born in 1951 or 1961 instead of ‘81. I’m decades late seeing my favorite bands in their prime, and I’m super envious of anyone that got to see the great, and by far most underrated guitarist in rock, Gary Richrath. I do have a guitar pic, signed albums, and several original REO posters from the ‘78-‘81 era I’ve found over the years. I’m facebook friends with their sound engineer from the glory years. He has boxes and boxes of live REO recordings just waiting to be uploaded on YouTube, but he only drops stuff super occasionally. I’ve been trying to find a way to get these recordings from him and do the work myself, but no luck thus far. My nightmare scenario has him passing away and nobody has any clue what he left behind…leedog68 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 18:14 pm I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
No, the Big Kahuna was just a regular stage. You might be thinking of the Westport Playhouse in Westport Plaza. Same area and they did have a revolving stage. I saw several concerts there, Robin Trower, America, Three Dog Night, Al Stewart etc. Wasn't aware of Gary ever playing there or I would have gone for sure!blues2112 wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 18:39 pmWas the stage a revolving turntable?leedog68 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 18:14 pm I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
If so, I was there!
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
I was born in 63 and graduated from high school in 81! hahaShakeyWalton wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 20:49 pmI’d have done anything to be born in 1951 or 1961 instead of ‘81. I’m decades late seeing my favorite bands in their prime, and I’m super envious of anyone that got to see the great, and by far most underrated guitarist in rock, Gary Richrath. I do have a guitar pic, signed albums, and several original REO posters from the ‘78-‘81 era I’ve found over the years. I’m facebook friends with their sound engineer from the glory years. He has boxes and boxes of live REO recordings just waiting to be uploaded on YouTube, but he only drops stuff super occasionally. I’ve been trying to find a way to get these recordings from him and do the work myself, but no luck thus far. My nightmare scenario has him passing away and nobody has any clue what he left behind…leedog68 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 18:14 pm I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
That makes sense! One of the band members wore an 80s-ish head band, and I wondered when did Gary concede his capons.leedog68 wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 21:31 pmNo, the Big Kahuna was just a regular stage. You might be thinking of the Westport Playhouse in Westport Plaza. Same area and they did have a revolving stage. I saw several concerts there, Robin Trower, America, Three Dog Night, Al Stewart etc. Wasn't aware of Gary ever playing there or I would have gone for sure!blues2112 wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 18:39 pmWas the stage a revolving turntable?leedog68 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 18:14 pm I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
If so, I was there!
-
ShakeyWalton
- Forum User
- Posts: 386
- Joined: 27 May 2024 13:22 pm
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
I apologize for somehow missing this post. Gary Moore was absolutely freaking phenomenal!! He’s in my Mount Rushmore for sure. What a talent!Inglewood Jack wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 16:19 pm Speaking of a "Gary", albeit a different one. I grew up a huge Rush fan, and went to the Grace Under Pressure tour. The opening act was this guitarist who just blew my socks off. Left the show going "who the heck was that!?!" as I thought he put on a better show than Rush that evening. I hadn't expanded my music taste at that point, but Gary Moore definitely got me started on a journey... Still ongoing...
-
ShakeyWalton
- Forum User
- Posts: 386
- Joined: 27 May 2024 13:22 pm
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Robin Trower. Another absolute STUD!leedog68 wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 21:31 pmNo, the Big Kahuna was just a regular stage. You might be thinking of the Westport Playhouse in Westport Plaza. Same area and they did have a revolving stage. I saw several concerts there, Robin Trower, America, Three Dog Night, Al Stewart etc. Wasn't aware of Gary ever playing there or I would have gone for sure!blues2112 wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 18:39 pmWas the stage a revolving turntable?leedog68 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 18:14 pm I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
If so, I was there!
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
Don't Let Your Friends Post-ToastedShakeyWalton wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 22:28 pmRobin Trower. Another absolute STUD!leedog68 wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 21:31 pmNo, the Big Kahuna was just a regular stage. You might be thinking of the Westport Playhouse in Westport Plaza. Same area and they did have a revolving stage. I saw several concerts there, Robin Trower, America, Three Dog Night, Al Stewart etc. Wasn't aware of Gary ever playing there or I would have gone for sure!blues2112 wrote: ↑20 Feb 2026 18:39 pmWas the stage a revolving turntable?leedog68 wrote: ↑19 Feb 2026 18:14 pm I was a huge REO fan also. You Get What You Play For is one of my all time favorite albums. I saw them for the first time at Super Jam 77 at Busch Stadium. My first concert. And several times after that. I saw Gary with his band Richrath at the Big Kahuna, a bar at Page and Schuetz for free and enjoyed it much more than any time I saw REO without him. I hate Cronin for ruining the mighty Speedwagon with his drivel. I did love his singing on the live album and the studio albums leading up to Hi Infidelity.
If so, I was there!
Re: Fleetwood Mac Rumors
My bad. I confused Tommy Bolin with Trower. I know, I know... not even in the same ballpark.
Trower's "Bridge Of Sighs" album was freakin' awesome!!!
Trower's "Bridge Of Sighs" album was freakin' awesome!!!