Pick the Cardinals 2026 all star

[CCard]

Any guesses? SS and IB is absolutely stacked with elite talent. I would say a pitcher but who?

Masyn Winn

I think he has the hardest path. Will need to be a dominant hitter in the first half. I’m don’t see it.

Hmm... Who else could it be? I guess there's a chance Burleson might make it as a reserve. Winn is one of the best SS in baseball and he's probably going to get better for a while.

[Youboughtit]

Any guesses? SS and IB is absolutely stacked with elite talent. I would say a pitcher but who?

Masyn Winn

I think he has the hardest path. Will need to be a dominant hitter in the first half. I’m don’t see it.

Hmm... Who else could it be? I guess there's a chance Burleson might make it as a reserve. Winn is one of the best SS in baseball and he's probably going to get better for a while.

Betts will be starter because Dodgers get more fan votes than any other team. Dela Cruz will definatly be there. Perdermo was the second best SS in baseball behind Witt last season. Lindor plays for the Mets. Turner will likely make its as well because in a huge market. 5 SS have never made it before. Usually 3 for each position. He would have to be top 3 in votes to make it likely. Even as a managers choice they don’t choose the 6th most votes

[CCard]

Any guesses? SS and IB is absolutely stacked with elite talent. I would say a pitcher but who?

Masyn Winn

I think he has the hardest path. Will need to be a dominant hitter in the first half. I’m don’t see it.

Hmm... Who else could it be? I guess there's a chance Burleson might make it as a reserve. Winn is one of the best SS in baseball and he's probably going to get better for a while.

Betts will be starter because Dodgers get more fan votes than any other team. Dela Cruz will definatly be there. Perdermo was the second best SS in baseball behind Witt last season. Lindor plays for the Mets. Turner will likely make its as well because in a huge market. 5 SS have never made it before. Usually 3 for each position. He would have to be top 3 in votes to make it likely. Even as a managers choice they don’t choose the 6th most votes

With the way the team has been gutted you're probably right. Not going to be fans enough to swing any vote. Maybe I've overestimated Masyn. There are a lot of good SS. I don't know who would represent St Louis in the all-star game. They have to have one player though so it will be interesting.

[12xu]

It could be Wetherholt, if he gets off to a blazing hot start. If not, it will be a pitcher picked just because each team must be represented.

[CCard]

How far a team has fallen when you can't even pick a player to represent them in the all-star game. Shameful.

[Youboughtit]

Any guesses? SS and IB is absolutely stacked with elite talent. I would say a pitcher but who?

Masyn Winn

I think he has the hardest path. Will need to be a dominant hitter in the first half. I’m don’t see it.

Hmm... Who else could it be? I guess there's a chance Burleson might make it as a reserve. Winn is one of the best SS in baseball and he's probably going to get better for a while.

Betts will be starter because Dodgers get more fan votes than any other team. Dela Cruz will definatly be there. Perdermo was the second best SS in baseball behind Witt last season. Lindor plays for the Mets. Turner will likely make its as well because in a huge market. 5 SS have never made it before. Usually 3 for each position. He would have to be top 3 in votes to make it likely. Even as a managers choice they don’t choose the 6th most votes

With the way the team has been gutted you're probably right. Not going to be fans enough to swing any vote. Maybe I've overestimated Masyn. There are a lot of good SS. I don't know who would represent St Louis in the all-star game. They have to have one player though so it will be interesting.

Usually a pitcher makes it for bad teams but I don’t even think they have one that will be good enough. Likely Hererra or Burleson as a DH manager selection

[scoutyjones2]

for Rock.... Mason Wynn

[scoutyjones2]

Just send JJ ... give him some national exposure.. pinch hit, pinch runner ?

That's not how it works

[scoutyjones2]

O'Brien

[Youboughtit]

O'Brien

Could be him Romero or Svanson if one separates as everyday closer. If they split it won’t happen.

[RunSup]

Winn and JJW.

If Wetherholt is legit considered an all star in 2026, then would be in the running for ROY. If he wins that the cardinals net a PPI pick in 2027.

No pressure, JJW.