Answer my question: What other names/pseudonyms are you posting under?DoneLurking wrote: ↑26 Nov 2025 08:55 amShow me anything from anyone who isn’t a forum fan that claims Shattenkirk was at any point in his career a better player than Pietrangelo. We can start there.Old_Goat wrote: ↑26 Nov 2025 08:51 amNot a joke at all.DoneLurking wrote: ↑26 Nov 2025 08:26 amThis a joke? Because the first bolded is simply not true.Old_Goat wrote: ↑26 Nov 2025 08:09 amtheograce wrote: ↑25 Nov 2025 20:49 pmdesperate is trying to replace a legend like Pietrangelo with 90+ mil on 2 midgets … my manIsDurbanodoingtime wrote: ↑25 Nov 2025 20:45 pmNo desperate was your lakehouse buddy giving jack campbell a five year 25 million deal.theograce wrote: ↑25 Nov 2025 20:42 pmDesperate was Krug/faulk/bchnevich. That was desperate and expensive.IsDurbanodoingtime wrote: ↑25 Nov 2025 20:40 pm The comments to the op's links from the oilers fans are kind of funny. Any universe where we trade Binnie and Skinner is part of the return ... I would be done. They are probably getting a more desperate than Leafs fans given the expectations and skinner letting in two of the first five shots he has faced tonite.
The blues aren’t winning a cup in binningtons time left. Why keep him? Nostalgia?
"A Legend?" Hilarious! Shattenkirk was viewed as the better more reliable D-man over Pietrangelo for years. O'Reilly was the defacto Leader of the Cup-Winning team. Boumeister and Parayko were the two leading D-men during the Championship run. Bortuzzo's and Gunnarson's goals scored in the playoffs in that year were more timely and impactful in winning two critical games than Pietrangelo's in game 7. And Management took Backes' recommendation for whom to name the Captain as he left. Note, I liked Backes as a player, have no dislike for Pietrangelo as a player, but my sense is neither were leaders in the sense of gathering the team together and increasing its bonding. Management blew it by not understanding the real team dynamic and the actual informal leaders when they picked Petro. Lucky O'Reilly showed up.
Think of the Cardinals "The Heat Is On" theme song in 1985. Or Pittsburgh Pirates Willy Stargell led "We Are Family" in 1979...And one of the most iconic examples of an inspiring song for a Championship Team came as a result of 5 players, while the Team Captain was nowhere to be found, Fabbri, Bortuzzo, Steen, Edmundson and Schwartz gathered in a Philly bar and even pumped up another teams fans there with "Gloria." That's a legend!
Theo, you are beyond desperate my man.
The second bolded requires a citation because otherwise it's unsupported conjecture.
The third bolded suggests that "timely" goals are the only things to consider when evaluating a playoff run.
The fourth bolded suggests that Pietrangelo is only captain because an exiting Backes said he should be, which again, isn't true.
Must be a joke post.
-Shattenkirk was viewed by some as the better player. So for them it's true. Not simply conjecture.
-You don't understand the concept of Informal Leadership. And I am not going to provide you a complimentary lesson in the concept nor any aspect of Leadership or Organizational Development.
-I never said that timely goals are the only things to consider when evaluating a playoff run. Do not twist my words. I was not evaluating the run.
-I did not boldly suggest that Pietrangelo was ONLY captain based upon Backes' recommendation. Again you are twisting my words. That is a fact, it was stated by Management at the time. And do not tell me to go find the quote. You go find it to prove that you have NOT twisted my words. What I boldly stated was that Management took his recommendation, but they blew it by picking him over other members of the team at the time.
Your style and illogical sense of communication, twisted words, etc. are very familiar...What other names/pseudonyms do you use to identify when you post on this site? I've noticed this before when responding to nonsensical postings to "theograce," from which others like you are quick to counterattack with untruths. (I'll bet it's you.)
I'm not going to invade privacy nor introduce to you close associates whom are former NHL players & coaches whom have shared their views with me directly, first-hand. I will end there.