Is Broberg a player you build around?

Join the discussion about the Blues.

[Complete Blues coverage on STLtoday.com]

Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Blues Talk Moderators

Post Reply
Harry S Deals
Forum User
Posts: 2359
Joined: 23 May 2024 14:25 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by Harry S Deals »

Lol you guys must be watching a different Broberg than me idk what you are talking about. Broberg is a stud 24 yr old lhd for years to come. He has 170 NHL games he hasn't even scratched the surface. Right now today Broberg may be the Blues best defender. He'd be pacing for 40 pts easy if the Blues had any semblance of offense attack. In no universe is Broberg not worth three or 4x what the Blues paid. Delusional
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 5651
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by theograce »

Harry S Deals wrote: 22 Nov 2025 21:55 pm you guys must be watching a different Broberg
You said best dman since Pronger.

Yup you see weird things

Ask the tat what he thinks
Red7
Forum User
Posts: 3657
Joined: 18 Dec 2018 18:09 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by Red7 »

I think the comparison to Jaybo is apt. Too many of you base your view of Jaybo on his last year as a Blue. Until Chief took over and Robinson came on board, he was soft as cream cheese back there. When Berube took over, both Parakyo and Jaybo both began to use their strength. Now, neither were big hitters or fighters, traditionally the marks of a “physical” player. However, they became stronger on the stick and suddenly were scary in puck battles, overpowering opposing forwards, be it in the corners, along the boards, or in front and behind the nets. Jaybo played his best hockey as a Blue from when Berube took over until he collapsed on the bench. Broberg has the size and strength to become that same kind of player. Does he have the want to?
ChooseBlues
E-Mail Issues
Posts: 868
Joined: 06 Jan 2019 21:22 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by ChooseBlues »

Harry S Deals wrote: 22 Nov 2025 21:55 pm Lol you guys must be watching a different Broberg than me idk what you are talking about. Broberg is a stud 24 yr old lhd for years to come. He has 170 NHL games he hasn't even scratched the surface. Right now today Broberg may be the Blues best defender. He'd be pacing for 40 pts easy if the Blues had any semblance of offense attack. In no universe is Broberg not worth three or 4x what the Blues paid. Delusional
+1
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 5651
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by theograce »

I guess the PP is not in his future. It’s weird.

Maybe he will aspire to be a Jaybo lite
seattleblue
Forum User
Posts: 2131
Joined: 08 Feb 2025 12:01 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by seattleblue »

We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 5651
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by theograce »

seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
Yup. “Can we win with this guy” is in full test mode right now
stlblue06
Forum User
Posts: 609
Joined: 24 May 2024 13:44 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by stlblue06 »

seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 5651
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by theograce »

stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
stlblue06
Forum User
Posts: 609
Joined: 24 May 2024 13:44 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by stlblue06 »

theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:54 am
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
Well the not effective on the PP doesn’t make sense as you would need to have the opportunity to be non effective first.

I just mean so far he’s mainly focused on developing his play in his own end. You see spurts of jumping in on the rush or pitching from the point but to me it’s either a confidence issue or he’s simply more concerned about being defensively responsible.

The start of last season is a prime example. If he starts using his speed on rushes or starts scoring some goals, the points will take off.
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 5651
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by theograce »

stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:27 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:54 am
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
Well the not effective on the PP doesn’t make sense as you would need to have the opportunity to be non effective first.

I just mean so far he’s mainly focused on developing his play in his own end. You see spurts of jumping in on the rush or pitching from the point but to me it’s either a confidence issue or he’s simply more concerned about being defensively responsible.

The start of last season is a prime example. If he starts using his speed on rushes or starts scoring some goals, the points will take off.
The best Defenders rack up points on PP. makar and Hughes have a 1/3 - 1/2 their points on the PP this year. Points don’t just take off at ES typically for defenders. 18-year-old 1st overall Schaefer has about 45% of his points off the PP to start.

And I’m guessing there’s reasons they are keeping him off the pp.
Walter Sobchak00
Forum User
Posts: 418
Joined: 24 Jun 2018 09:25 am

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by Walter Sobchak00 »

theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:37 pm
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:27 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:54 am
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
Well the not effective on the PP doesn’t make sense as you would need to have the opportunity to be non effective first.

I just mean so far he’s mainly focused on developing his play in his own end. You see spurts of jumping in on the rush or pitching from the point but to me it’s either a confidence issue or he’s simply more concerned about being defensively responsible.

The start of last season is a prime example. If he starts using his speed on rushes or starts scoring some goals, the points will take off.
The best Defenders rack up points on PP. makar and Hughes have a 1/3 - 1/2 their points on the PP this year. Points don’t just take off at ES typically for defenders. 18-year-old 1st overall Schaefer has about 45% of his points off the PP to start.

And I’m guessing there’s reasons they are keeping him off the pp.
Reason: he'd be playing over 30 a night
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 5651
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by theograce »

Walter Sobchak00 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:51 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:37 pm
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:27 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:54 am
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
Well the not effective on the PP doesn’t make sense as you would need to have the opportunity to be non effective first.

I just mean so far he’s mainly focused on developing his play in his own end. You see spurts of jumping in on the rush or pitching from the point but to me it’s either a confidence issue or he’s simply more concerned about being defensively responsible.

The start of last season is a prime example. If he starts using his speed on rushes or starts scoring some goals, the points will take off.
The best Defenders rack up points on PP. makar and Hughes have a 1/3 - 1/2 their points on the PP this year. Points don’t just take off at ES typically for defenders. 18-year-old 1st overall Schaefer has about 45% of his points off the PP to start.

And I’m guessing there’s reasons they are keeping him off the pp.
Reason: he'd be playing over 30 a night
No that’s not it lol
Walter Sobchak00
Forum User
Posts: 418
Joined: 24 Jun 2018 09:25 am

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by Walter Sobchak00 »

theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:54 pm
Walter Sobchak00 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:51 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:37 pm
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:27 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:54 am
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
Well the not effective on the PP doesn’t make sense as you would need to have the opportunity to be non effective first.

I just mean so far he’s mainly focused on developing his play in his own end. You see spurts of jumping in on the rush or pitching from the point but to me it’s either a confidence issue or he’s simply more concerned about being defensively responsible.

The start of last season is a prime example. If he starts using his speed on rushes or starts scoring some goals, the points will take off.
The best Defenders rack up points on PP. makar and Hughes have a 1/3 - 1/2 their points on the PP this year. Points don’t just take off at ES typically for defenders. 18-year-old 1st overall Schaefer has about 45% of his points off the PP to start.

And I’m guessing there’s reasons they are keeping him off the pp.
Reason: he'd be playing over 30 a night
No that’s not it lol
Just had a quick text exchange with DA, he told me the reason Broberg was isn't getting any PP time is there is a moronic troll on the Stltoday forums that needs material to obsess over and attempt to goat people into an arguments. Doug felt if the Blues were to take that away from this freak he feared for the reaction and breaking the last string of sanity this guy has left.


And there you have it straight from the horses mouth...
theograce
Forum User
Posts: 5651
Joined: 27 Apr 2024 20:56 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by theograce »

Walter Sobchak00 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 13:11 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:54 pm
Walter Sobchak00 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:51 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:37 pm
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:27 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:54 am
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
Well the not effective on the PP doesn’t make sense as you would need to have the opportunity to be non effective first.

I just mean so far he’s mainly focused on developing his play in his own end. You see spurts of jumping in on the rush or pitching from the point but to me it’s either a confidence issue or he’s simply more concerned about being defensively responsible.

The start of last season is a prime example. If he starts using his speed on rushes or starts scoring some goals, the points will take off.
The best Defenders rack up points on PP. makar and Hughes have a 1/3 - 1/2 their points on the PP this year. Points don’t just take off at ES typically for defenders. 18-year-old 1st overall Schaefer has about 45% of his points off the PP to start.

And I’m guessing there’s reasons they are keeping him off the pp.
Reason: he'd be playing over 30 a night
No that’s not it lol
Just had a quick text exchange with DA, he told me the reason Broberg was isn't getting any PP time is there is a moronic troll on the Stltoday forums that needs material to obsess over and attempt to goat people into an arguments. Doug felt if the Blues were to take that away from this freak he feared for the reaction and breaking the last string of sanity this guy has left.


And there you have it straight from the horses mouth...
That’s your response to it not being the reason? Because it’s not the reason.
Harry S Deals
Forum User
Posts: 2359
Joined: 23 May 2024 14:25 pm

Re: Is Broberg a player you build around?

Post by Harry S Deals »

Walter Sobchak00 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 13:11 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:54 pm
Walter Sobchak00 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:51 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:37 pm
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 12:27 pm
theograce wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:54 am
stlblue06 wrote: 23 Nov 2025 11:47 am
seattleblue wrote: 23 Nov 2025 10:14 am We should acknowledge that right at the moment he is getting a lot of minutes so they can test this very appropriate question before they sign him to a long term deal (which they will).

If it develops the Blues way and he's an anchor defenseman in his performance, I am very open to that. He seems to have a lot more offensive intention than later-career Jaybo. More direct net attacks.
They didn’t give him over 27 minutes yesterday because Monty was thinking about his next contract. After Colt our defensive options are questionable at best. Broberg is developing into an extremely smart defender with a lot of untapped offensive upside
What does untapped offensive upside mean? He doesn’t have much of a shot. He’s a rush defender and uses his legs. I’m pretty disappointed he’s not effective on the PP, but is what it is.
Well the not effective on the PP doesn’t make sense as you would need to have the opportunity to be non effective first.

I just mean so far he’s mainly focused on developing his play in his own end. You see spurts of jumping in on the rush or pitching from the point but to me it’s either a confidence issue or he’s simply more concerned about being defensively responsible.

The start of last season is a prime example. If he starts using his speed on rushes or starts scoring some goals, the points will take off.
The best Defenders rack up points on PP. makar and Hughes have a 1/3 - 1/2 their points on the PP this year. Points don’t just take off at ES typically for defenders. 18-year-old 1st overall Schaefer has about 45% of his points off the PP to start.

And I’m guessing there’s reasons they are keeping him off the pp.
Reason: he'd be playing over 30 a night
No that’s not it lol
Just had a quick text exchange with DA, he told me the reason Broberg was isn't getting any PP time is there is a moronic troll on the Stltoday forums that needs material to obsess over and attempt to goat people into an arguments. Doug felt if the Blues were to take that away from this freak he feared for the reaction and breaking the last string of sanity this guy has left.


And there you have it straight from the horses mouth...
There will come a time when Broberg is also manning the point but right now with the weird third pairing decisions Monty has to lean on Broberg and CP so much 5v5 that Broberg cannot play 32 minutes a night
Post Reply