Who would want Arenado?

[Youboughtit]

Here is a list of current starting 3B and FA by team. 3B is absolutely stacked

Rays Caminero
Guardians Ramirez
Astros Correa/Peredes
Giants Chapman
Royals Garcia
Padres Machado
Orioles Westburg
Braves Riley
Cubs Shaw
Dodgers Muncy
Mets Vientos/Baty
Jays Barger/Clement
Brewers Durbin
Twins Lewis
Tigers Keith
White Sox Vargas
Phillies Bohm
Rangers Jung
Mariners Rivas
Diamondbacks Lawler
Yankees McMahon
Red Sox Mayer
Red Hayes
Marlins Norby
As Muncy
Rockies Karros
Pirates Triolo
Bats House
Angels Guzman/Peraza
Cardinals Arenado


FA
Murakami
Bregaman
Suarez
Moncada
Kike Hernandez
Urias
Urshella

Some of the players above are top prospect rookies and with those FA where does anyone see a team with a opening for Arenado?

[rockondlouie]

Here is a list of current starting 3B and FA by team. 3B is absolutely stacked

Rays Caminero
Guardians Ramirez
Astros Correa/Peredes
Giants Chapman
Royals Garcia
Padres Machado
Orioles Westburg
Braves Riley
Cubs Shaw
Dodgers Muncy
Mets Vientos/Baty
Jays Barger/Clement
Brewers Durbin
Twins Lewis
Tigers Keith
White Sox Vargas
Phillies Bohm
Rangers Jung
Mariners Rivas
Diamondbacks Lawler
Yankees McMahon
Red Sox Mayer
Red Hayes
Marlins Norby
As Muncy
Rockies Karros
Pirates Triolo
Bats House
Angels Guzman/-Peraza
Cardinals Arenado


FA
Murakami
Bregaman
Suarez
Moncada
Like Hernandez
Urias
Urshella

Some of the players above are top prospect rookies and with those FA where does anyone see a team with a opening for Arenado?

[Talkin' Baseball]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

[Youboughtit]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

Mariners are trying to re sign Suarez
Tigers Colt is a top prospect
Phillies Bohn is better and cheaper
Rangers Jung is a stud when healthy
Diamondbacks Lawler is a top 5 MLb prospect

Even if they do move on why Arenado over those FA? I just don’t see a market for Arenado at all

[Strummer Jones]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

Mariners are trying to re sign Suarez
Tigers Colt is a top prospect
Phillies Bohn is better and cheaper
Rangers Jung is a stud when healthy
Diamondbacks Lawler is a top 5 MLb prospect

Even if they do move on why Arenado over those FA? I just don’t see a market for Arenado at all

I think in those five teams alone, there's potential among some of them.

I am not so sure the M's want Suarez back. He's spent about two and a half seasons in Seattle and one season was actually well above average. Another season was *barely* average, and his cameo back there this past season was--at least from a hitting standpoint--really bad. I don't know if a team like the Mariners will give him the contract he wants. I could see Arenado as a fit here. He might not hit a whole lot, but he doesn't really need to. They've got Raleigh, Julio, Arozarena, and a young Harry Ford who's one of the better prospects in the game. Nolan doesn't need to be THE guy there. They could probably survive with a defense first 3B, and if I were them, I'd be willing to gamble that being on a contender might bring a little more out of Nolan at this stage in his career.

Detroit--I don't see much of a fit there.

Phillies--It's not much of a secret that they don't really want Bohm anymore. He's been alright but he hasn't lived up to his hype. I don't think Bohm is all that happy there, either. Philly doesn't mind spending money, so I could see Arenado going there. But where's Philadelphia at now? They're an old team. Harper, Turner, Realmuto, Castellanos (for now)...do they want to get older and more expensive? Despite all of that, I see potential for something creative with Arenado here.

Rangers--I don't see it. If I were them, I'd see what Jung can do before Arenado.

Snakes--Lawlar hasn't shown much in either cup of coffee. He's probably in a similar spot there that Walker is here, but Lawlar has the luxury of being able to play any of the infield spots, and probably the outfield in a pinch. There's rumors that Marte might be on the way out of the desert. So there is definitely a world where Lawlar and and Arenado can coexist. And I could see the Snakes potentially seeing Arenado as a mentor for Lawlar. Maybe not a hands on "Look here son" type mentor, but in the "this is how a future hall of famer goes about his business" type mentor.

[Talkin' Baseball]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

Mariners are trying to re sign Suarez
Tigers Colt is a top prospect
Phillies Bohn is better and cheaper
Rangers Jung is a stud when healthy
Diamondbacks Lawler is a top 5 MLb prospect

Even if they do move on why Arenado over those FA? I just don’t see a market for Arenado at all

We'll see

[Youboughtit]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

Mariners are trying to re sign Suarez
Tigers Colt is a top prospect
Phillies Bohn is better and cheaper
Rangers Jung is a stud when healthy
Diamondbacks Lawler is a top 5 MLb prospect

Even if they do move on why Arenado over those FA? I just don’t see a market for Arenado at all

I think in those five teams alone, there's potential among some of them.

I am not so sure the M's want Suarez back. He's spent about two and a half seasons in Seattle and one season was actually well above average. Another season was *barely* average, and his cameo back there this past season was--at least from a hitting standpoint--really bad. I don't know if a team like the Mariners will give him the contract he wants. I could see Arenado as a fit here. He might not hit a whole lot, but he doesn't really need to. They've got Raleigh, Julio, Arozarena, and a young Harry Ford who's one of the better prospects in the game. Nolan doesn't need to be THE guy there. They could probably survive with a defense first 3B, and if I were them, I'd be willing to gamble that being on a contender might bring a little more out of Nolan at this stage in his career.

Detroit--I don't see much of a fit there.

Phillies--It's not much of a secret that they don't really want Bohm anymore. He's been alright but he hasn't lived up to his hype. I don't think Bohm is all that happy there, either. Philly doesn't mind spending money, so I could see Arenado going there. But where's Philadelphia at now? They're an old team. Harper, Turner, Realmuto, Castellanos (for now)...do they want to get older and more expensive? Despite all of that, I see potential for something creative with Arenado here.

Rangers--I don't see it. If I were them, I'd see what Jung can do before Arenado.

Snakes--Lawlar hasn't shown much in either cup of coffee. He's probably in a similar spot there that Walker is here, but Lawlar has the luxury of being able to play any of the infield spots, and probably the outfield in a pinch. There's rumors that Marte might be on the way out of the desert. So there is definitely a world where Lawlar and and Arenado can coexist. And I could see the Snakes potentially seeing Arenado as a mentor for Lawlar. Maybe not a hands on "Look here son" type mentor, but in the "this is how a future hall of famer goes about his business" type mentor.

Well Murakami Suarez and Bregman will take 3 spots from my list for sure so that won’t leave many options.

[IndCard75]

I think Bloom will have to get creative to move Arenado.
I know people don’t like it but it might take packaging Arenado with someone like Donovan to get it done.
My proposal-
Arenado Donovan and Walker to Red Sox for Duran and a prospect.
Arenado is friends with Story. The Red Sox have depth in OF.
Donovan can play multiple positions. They can put Walker in AAA
for the season to try to improve his development.

[Strummer Jones]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

Mariners are trying to re sign Suarez
Tigers Colt is a top prospect
Phillies Bohn is better and cheaper
Rangers Jung is a stud when healthy
Diamondbacks Lawler is a top 5 MLb prospect

Even if they do move on why Arenado over those FA? I just don’t see a market for Arenado at all

I think in those five teams alone, there's potential among some of them.

I am not so sure the M's want Suarez back. He's spent about two and a half seasons in Seattle and one season was actually well above average. Another season was *barely* average, and his cameo back there this past season was--at least from a hitting standpoint--really bad. I don't know if a team like the Mariners will give him the contract he wants. I could see Arenado as a fit here. He might not hit a whole lot, but he doesn't really need to. They've got Raleigh, Julio, Arozarena, and a young Harry Ford who's one of the better prospects in the game. Nolan doesn't need to be THE guy there. They could probably survive with a defense first 3B, and if I were them, I'd be willing to gamble that being on a contender might bring a little more out of Nolan at this stage in his career.

Detroit--I don't see much of a fit there.

Phillies--It's not much of a secret that they don't really want Bohm anymore. He's been alright but he hasn't lived up to his hype. I don't think Bohm is all that happy there, either. Philly doesn't mind spending money, so I could see Arenado going there. But where's Philadelphia at now? They're an old team. Harper, Turner, Realmuto, Castellanos (for now)...do they want to get older and more expensive? Despite all of that, I see potential for something creative with Arenado here.

Rangers--I don't see it. If I were them, I'd see what Jung can do before Arenado.

Snakes--Lawlar hasn't shown much in either cup of coffee. He's probably in a similar spot there that Walker is here, but Lawlar has the luxury of being able to play any of the infield spots, and probably the outfield in a pinch. There's rumors that Marte might be on the way out of the desert. So there is definitely a world where Lawlar and and Arenado can coexist. And I could see the Snakes potentially seeing Arenado as a mentor for Lawlar. Maybe not a hands on "Look here son" type mentor, but in the "this is how a future hall of famer goes about his business" type mentor.

Well Murakami Suarez and Bregman will take 3 spots from my list for sure so that won’t leave many options.

Lot of speculation that Arenado is willing to waive his no-trade clause.

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... build.html

[Cranny]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

Mariners are trying to re sign Suarez
Tigers Colt is a top prospect
Phillies Bohn is better and cheaper
Rangers Jung is a stud when healthy
Diamondbacks Lawler is a top 5 MLb prospect

Even if they do move on why Arenado over those FA? I just don’t see a market for Arenado at all

I think in those five teams alone, there's potential among some of them.

I am not so sure the M's want Suarez back. He's spent about two and a half seasons in Seattle and one season was actually well above average. Another season was *barely* average, and his cameo back there this past season was--at least from a hitting standpoint--really bad. I don't know if a team like the Mariners will give him the contract he wants. I could see Arenado as a fit here. He might not hit a whole lot, but he doesn't really need to. They've got Raleigh, Julio, Arozarena, and a young Harry Ford who's one of the better prospects in the game. Nolan doesn't need to be THE guy there. They could probably survive with a defense first 3B, and if I were them, I'd be willing to gamble that being on a contender might bring a little more out of Nolan at this stage in his career.

Detroit--I don't see much of a fit there.

Phillies--It's not much of a secret that they don't really want Bohm anymore. He's been alright but he hasn't lived up to his hype. I don't think Bohm is all that happy there, either. Philly doesn't mind spending money, so I could see Arenado going there. But where's Philadelphia at now? They're an old team. Harper, Turner, Realmuto, Castellanos (for now)...do they want to get older and more expensive? Despite all of that, I see potential for something creative with Arenado here.

Rangers--I don't see it. If I were them, I'd see what Jung can do before Arenado.

Snakes--Lawlar hasn't shown much in either cup of coffee. He's probably in a similar spot there that Walker is here, but Lawlar has the luxury of being able to play any of the infield spots, and probably the outfield in a pinch. There's rumors that Marte might be on the way out of the desert. So there is definitely a world where Lawlar and and Arenado can coexist. And I could see the Snakes potentially seeing Arenado as a mentor for Lawlar. Maybe not a hands on "Look here son" type mentor, but in the "this is how a future hall of famer goes about his business" type mentor.

Well Murakami Suarez and Bregman will take 3 spots from my list for sure so that won’t leave many options.

Lot of speculation that Arenado is willing to waive his no-trade clause.

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... build.html

Rumors flying that there isn't much excitement in the market over Arenado, Gray, or Nootbaar.

[ramfandan]

Mariners, Tigers, Angels, Phillies, Rangers, Diamondbacks in no particular order.

Mariners are trying to re sign Suarez
Tigers Colt is a top prospect
Phillies Bohn is better and cheaper
Rangers Jung is a stud when healthy
Diamondbacks Lawler is a top 5 MLb prospect

Even if they do move on why Arenado over those FA? I just don’t see a market for Arenado at all

I think in those five teams alone, there's potential among some of them.

I am not so sure the M's want Suarez back. He's spent about two and a half seasons in Seattle and one season was actually well above average. Another season was *barely* average, and his cameo back there this past season was--at least from a hitting standpoint--really bad. I don't know if a team like the Mariners will give him the contract he wants. I could see Arenado as a fit here. He might not hit a whole lot, but he doesn't really need to. They've got Raleigh, Julio, Arozarena, and a young Harry Ford who's one of the better prospects in the game. Nolan doesn't need to be THE guy there. They could probably survive with a defense first 3B, and if I were them, I'd be willing to gamble that being on a contender might bring a little more out of Nolan at this stage in his career.

Detroit--I don't see much of a fit there.

Phillies--It's not much of a secret that they don't really want Bohm anymore. He's been alright but he hasn't lived up to his hype. I don't think Bohm is all that happy there, either. Philly doesn't mind spending money, so I could see Arenado going there. But where's Philadelphia at now? They're an old team. Harper, Turner, Realmuto, Castellanos (for now)...do they want to get older and more expensive? Despite all of that, I see potential for something creative with Arenado here.

Rangers--I don't see it. If I were them, I'd see what Jung can do before Arenado.

Snakes--Lawlar hasn't shown much in either cup of coffee. He's probably in a similar spot there that Walker is here, but Lawlar has the luxury of being able to play any of the infield spots, and probably the outfield in a pinch. There's rumors that Marte might be on the way out of the desert. So there is definitely a world where Lawlar and and Arenado can coexist. And I could see the Snakes potentially seeing Arenado as a mentor for Lawlar. Maybe not a hands on "Look here son" type mentor, but in the "this is how a future hall of famer goes about his business" type mentor.

Well Murakami Suarez and Bregman will take 3 spots from my list for sure so that won’t leave many options.

Lot of speculation that Arenado is willing to waive his no-trade clause.

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... build.html

Rumors flying that there isn't much excitement in the market over Arenado, Gray, or Nootbaar.

Makes sense that there isn't much excitement ... Two of the three have hefty contracts . The players themselves have talent to be attractive within their role but Cardinals will have to eat considerable payroll.
If I am a team wanting Arenado and or Gray , I certainly wouldn't 'act' too excited as You want to play your poker hand as ' for the right price I may have some interest ' .. always downplay your interest . Part of the game all GM's play. Never act too excited or worse yet let it leak you are 'very interested' in a player regardless of their current playing level as all you do is keep the other team's asking price a bit higher.
Similar to going into a 'used car lot' and telling the sales man Boy, I love that blue sports car . How much off will give me ? The sales guy just found out you 'love that car' more than any on his lot . Of course , he will lower the price as lttle as possible to get you to buy it .
In fact, the salesman could [nonsense] you and say Boy, can't come down much at all. Just had 3 guys in there today looking at that beauty and it's going to go fast. LOL

[cardstatman]

Arenado wants a ring before he retires. Two years with LAD is his best shot at one.

The Dodgers could use a platoon partner for Muncy. Muncy still kills RHP but hit .157 .250 .314 .564 against LHP in 2025.

It is as easy as 1, 2, 3.

1. Arenado needs to swallow his pride and accept a weak side platoon and late game defensive replacement job.
2. Cardinals need to swallow $20M and not expect much in return.
3. Dodgers need to just keep on being the Dodgers. They can afford to pay Arenado $7M x 2 years to be Muncy's platoon partner and insurance policy.

[redbirdfan51]

Cards will need to sweeten the deal trading Nado. Perhaps a prospect and paying part of his salary. Phillies ,Red Sox and maybe the Mariners seem to be the most likely.

[greyhawk]

Arenado can still play defense -- and if he is your #7 or #8 hitter when healthy he can likely give you decent production from one of those spots. It's all gonna depend on what other teams think he can offer and if he is worth the price.

[Talkin' Baseball]

Cards will need to sweeten the deal trading Nado. Perhaps a prospect and paying part of his salary. Phillies ,Red Sox and maybe the Mariners seem to be the most likely.

The Mariners are the best fit for the Cardinals. They won't be in on signing Alex Bregman, so they could make a move sooner than later. The Phillies and Red Sox will try to sign Bregman and could wait nearly until spring training to find out what he will do.

[Youboughtit]

Arenado wants a ring before he retires. Two years with LAD is his best shot at one.

The Dodgers could use a platoon partner for Muncy. Muncy still kills RHP but hit .157 .250 .314 .564 against LHP in 2025.

It is as easy as 1, 2, 3.

1. Arenado needs to swallow his pride and accept a weak side platoon and late game defensive replacement job.
2. Cardinals need to swallow $20M and not expect much in return.
3. Dodgers need to just keep on being the Dodgers. They can afford to pay Arenado $7M x 2 years to be Muncy's platoon partner and insurance policy.

Dodgers have 9 FA and rumor is they want to go young instead of veterans