Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Greatest postseason game ever?
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
Re: Greatest postseason game ever?
kinda like Panda hitting 3 in a WS game ?sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 10:45 am Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Re: Greatest postseason game ever?
Giants fan?dugoutrex wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 13:18 pmkinda like Panda hitting 3 in a WS game ?sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 10:45 am Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Panda followed Pujols the next year by going 4 for 4 in game 1 of the WS, with 3 runs, 4 RBI, 3 HRs, and 13 TB. So he tied only one of the records that Pujols holds listed above.
Re: Greatest postseason game ever?
Excellent point.sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 10:45 am Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Here is another MLB playoff game probably unmatched in history.
1982 WS Game 3.
Rookie Willie McGee hit 2 HR, scored 2, drove in 4.
He also took a HR away from Gorman Thomas with one of the best leaping catches in WS history.
And he took a double or triple away from Paul Molitor by climbing the CF wall.
Perhaps the best offense/defense single game performance ever produced in the World Series.
Re: Greatest postseason game ever?
Good recall. Brooks Robinson had similar all around games in 1970Melville wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 14:41 pmExcellent point.sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 10:45 am Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Here is another MLB playoff game probably unmatched in history.
1982 WS Game 3.
Rookie Willie McGee hit 2 HR, scored 2, drove in 4.
He also took a HR away from Gorman Thomas with one of the best leaping catches in WS history.
And he took a double or triple away from Paul Molitor by climbing the CF wall.
Perhaps the best offense/defense single game performance ever produced in the World Series.
Re: Greatest postseason game ever?
no - but for me it did kinda dampen Pujols doing it a year priorsp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 13:55 pmGiants fan?dugoutrex wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 13:18 pmkinda like Panda hitting 3 in a WS game ?sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 10:45 am Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Panda followed Pujols the next year by going 4 for 4 in game 1 of the WS, with 3 runs, 4 RBI, 3 HRs, and 13 TB. So he tied only one of the records that Pujols holds listed above.
Re: Greatest postseason game ever?
Outstanding point.sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 15:02 pmGood recall. Brooks Robinson had similar all around games in 1970Melville wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 14:41 pmExcellent point.sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 10:45 am Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Here is another MLB playoff game probably unmatched in history.
1982 WS Game 3.
Rookie Willie McGee hit 2 HR, scored 2, drove in 4.
He also took a HR away from Gorman Thomas with one of the best leaping catches in WS history.
And he took a double or triple away from Paul Molitor by climbing the CF wall.
Perhaps the best offense/defense single game performance ever produced in the World Series.
Unbelievable performance by Robinson in that series.
Re: Greatest postseason game ever?
Yeah, have to admit I felt the same way. And to think, if the Cardinals hadn't blown a 3-1 lead in the NLCS, Panda wouldn't have even been in that WS.dugoutrex wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 15:04 pmno - but for me it did kinda dampen Pujols doing it a year priorsp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 13:55 pmGiants fan?dugoutrex wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 13:18 pmkinda like Panda hitting 3 in a WS game ?sp25 wrote: ↑18 Oct 2025 10:45 am Ohtani certainly had a great game, and his pitching combined with his hitting makes his performance unique.
However, here are single game records for hitting in a World Series game:
Hits - 5, held by two players
Runs - 4, held by 11 players
HR - 3, held by 4 players
RBI - 6, held by 4 players
TB - 14, held by one player
In 2011 game 3, Albert Pujols set or tied every one of these records. He didn't pitch, of course, but to me this game is not talked about enough, even by Cardinals fans.
The single best offensive performance in World Series history.
Panda followed Pujols the next year by going 4 for 4 in game 1 of the WS, with 3 runs, 4 RBI, 3 HRs, and 13 TB. So he tied only one of the records that Pujols holds listed above.