Trade destinations

Welcome to STLtoday.com's forum for fans of the St. Louis Cardinals.

Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators

Post Reply
kyace
Forum User
Posts: 867
Joined: 24 May 2024 19:11 pm

Trade destinations

Post by kyace »

Just some guesses where players end up.

Nootbaar- Dodgers , I’ve said this almost all season. They seem to be a perfect fit as they need lh bats and an outfielder to replace Conforto.

Arenado- Angels, They need a third baseman and their owner likes big name players. Not Nolan’s top choice but he goes home and they can be competitive.

Gray- Braves, near home and they are looking to get back in playoffs next year.

Gorman- Rockies, They will try to unlock his power in a power hitters park.

These are the players I think have a good chance to be traded. Here are some that could be traded.

Jo Jo- Yankees, they need a good lh reliever and have lot of young pitching to deal.

Contreras- Boston or Brewers- Boston needs a first baseman and a rh bat. Brewers could use him too. I could easily see him waiving his NTC for either team

Donovan- I think they actually make him a long term offer. If he rejects it then he will be dealt
He fits on several teams. Yankees and Seattle have been after him for several years but they may have moved on. Seattle may still want him as Polonco and Suarez are free agents. Don’t rule out the Mets or even the Dodgers in a deal involving both Nootbaar and Donovan.

These will be the major names, some peripheral players are likely to be moved.i think they keep Walker and hope he finally gets it.
HorseTrader
Forum User
Posts: 2341
Joined: 18 Apr 2020 13:40 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by HorseTrader »

Good guesses, I look for Arenado and Noot to be a package, they pay down Arenado's salary and add Noot to get better prospect.
12xu
Forum User
Posts: 3763
Joined: 23 May 2024 15:46 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by 12xu »

All of your suggestions are good possibilities. What the Cardinals get in return will be very interesting and important.
2ninr
Forum User
Posts: 853
Joined: 24 May 2024 15:04 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by 2ninr »

kyace wrote: 30 Sep 2025 12:50 pm Just some guesses where players end up.

Nootbaar- Dodgers , I’ve said this almost all season. They seem to be a perfect fit as they need lh bats and an outfielder to replace Conforto.

Arenado- Angels, They need a third baseman and their owner likes big name players. Not Nolan’s top choice but he goes home and they can be competitive.

Gray- Braves, near home and they are looking to get back in playoffs next year.

Gorman- Rockies, They will try to unlock his power in a power hitters park.

These are the players I think have a good chance to be traded. Here are some that could be traded.

Jo Jo- Yankees, they need a good lh reliever and have lot of young pitching to deal.

Contreras- Boston or Brewers- Boston needs a first baseman and a rh bat. Brewers could use him too. I could easily see him waiving his NTC for either team

Donovan- I think they actually make him a long term offer. If he rejects it then he will be dealt
He fits on several teams. Yankees and Seattle have been after him for several years but they may have moved on. Seattle may still want him as Polonco and Suarez are free agents. Don’t rule out the Mets or even the Dodgers in a deal involving both Nootbaar and Donovan.

These will be the major names, some peripheral players are likely to be moved.i think they keep Walker and hope he finally gets it.
All sounds reasonable.
82birds
Forum User
Posts: 16118
Joined: 23 May 2024 18:17 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by 82birds »

12xu wrote: 30 Sep 2025 15:11 pm All of your suggestions are good possibilities. What the Cardinals get in return will be very interesting and important.
^ this of course is key
Hoosier59
Forum User
Posts: 1072
Joined: 16 Dec 2022 12:03 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by Hoosier59 »

HorseTrader wrote: 30 Sep 2025 14:45 pm Good guesses, I look for Arenado and Noot to be a package, they pay down Arenado's salary and add Noot to get better prospect.
I too think Noot and Nado will be in the same package, and think that could be the Dodgers. Really depends on what they do with Muncey. He was injured a lot. Dodgers have some young starting pitching that could move, if all of their veterans are healthy.
Bad thing is a lot of those young guys were injured too. I still think that’s the play there.

Gorman, I think, will go home to Arizona.
I think JoJo stays, at least until trade deadline.
Contreras, if he’s moved, I can see him in San Diego. They don’t really like Arraez at 1st base, plus they could use more catching.
I agree Gray to Atlanta.
Walker won’t be traded. If he has a good Spring, he’ll be back in RF. If he doesn’t, he’ll be in Memphis.
Scott will be back in CF, but with a short leash! They like his speed and defense. They will have him work a lot on his bunting this off-season, I mean a lot! If you noticed, he bunted a lot the last couple of weeks, not very successfully either I might add! Victor needs to make better use of his speed and be more of a bunt and slap type hitter, not unlike his buddy he works out with who plays for Miami. He has the perfect guy to help get better at this.
Saggese won’t be traded , he's their right handed hitter for their lefty hitting infielders.
General
Forum User
Posts: 150
Joined: 23 May 2024 12:47 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by General »

I’d expect Gorman and Walker to stay since their value is currently depressed. You play them next year and work to improve them.
2ninr
Forum User
Posts: 853
Joined: 24 May 2024 15:04 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by 2ninr »

Mets have a top farm system. Pretty sure they will be looking for a table setter. We have 2 that would be attractive to them.
hmoss859
Forum User
Posts: 751
Joined: 24 Mar 2025 23:30 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by hmoss859 »

kyace wrote: 30 Sep 2025 12:50 pm Just some guesses where players end up.

Nootbaar- Dodgers , I’ve said this almost all season. They seem to be a perfect fit as they need lh bats and an outfielder to replace Conforto.

Arenado- Angels, They need a third baseman and their owner likes big name players. Not Nolan’s top choice but he goes home and they can be competitive.

Gray- Braves, near home and they are looking to get back in playoffs next year.

Gorman- Rockies, They will try to unlock his power in a power hitters park.

These are the players I think have a good chance to be traded. Here are some that could be traded.

Jo Jo- Yankees, they need a good lh reliever and have lot of young pitching to deal.

Contreras- Boston or Brewers- Boston needs a first baseman and a rh bat. Brewers could use him too. I could easily see him waiving his NTC for either team

Donovan- I think they actually make him a long term offer. If he rejects it then he will be dealt
He fits on several teams. Yankees and Seattle have been after him for several years but they may have moved on. Seattle may still want him as Polonco and Suarez are free agents. Don’t rule out the Mets or even the Dodgers in a deal involving both Nootbaar and Donovan.

These will be the major names, some peripheral players are likely to be moved.i think they keep Walker and hope he finally gets it.
Excellent summation on all fronts.

Keep in mind that Donovan beat Cardinals in arbitration and they usually trade those folks.
JuanAgosto
Forum User
Posts: 6120
Joined: 01 Jul 2021 21:30 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by JuanAgosto »

I look for Donovan to be traded for a SP.

The suggestion of Arenado and Noot being packaged is interesting.

Gray to Atlanta makes sense.

Contreras to Mets if Alonso walks?

Gorman and Walker will be back.
sikeston bulldog2
Forum User
Posts: 13448
Joined: 11 Aug 2023 16:20 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by sikeston bulldog2 »

kyace wrote: 30 Sep 2025 12:50 pm Just some guesses where players end up.

Nootbaar- Dodgers , I’ve said this almost all season. They seem to be a perfect fit as they need lh bats and an outfielder to replace Conforto.

Arenado- Angels, They need a third baseman and their owner likes big name players. Not Nolan’s top choice but he goes home and they can be competitive.

Gray- Braves, near home and they are looking to get back in playoffs next year.

Gorman- Rockies, They will try to unlock his power in a power hitters park.

These are the players I think have a good chance to be traded. Here are some that could be traded.

Jo Jo- Yankees, they need a good lh reliever and have lot of young pitching to deal.

Contreras- Boston or Brewers- Boston needs a first baseman and a rh bat. Brewers could use him too. I could easily see him waiving his NTC for either team

Donovan- I think they actually make him a long term offer. If he rejects it then he will be dealt
He fits on several teams. Yankees and Seattle have been after him for several years but they may have moved on. Seattle may still want him as Polonco and Suarez are free agents. Don’t rule out the Mets or even the Dodgers in a deal involving both Nootbaar and Donovan.

These will be the major names, some peripheral players are likely to be moved.i think they keep Walker and hope he finally gets it.
You didn’t mention Burleson. Is he heir apparent for first base.
StlMike1969
Forum User
Posts: 254
Joined: 24 May 2024 11:01 am

Re: Trade destinations

Post by StlMike1969 »

Not really understanding the logic behind letting Walker and Gorman continue to get MLB at bats without showing they have adjusted first. Bloom and this team have no investment in either one financially. There was only instruction from Moz that they get playing time. I think Bloom unloads Gorman in a trade and Walker if not traded also will be spending his last option in AAA proving he can hit or finding a new groove.

Donovan - Even if he goes to Arbitration and wins again he is still cheaper than a long term deal. They stick him in RF or LF and call it his. You still get a .285+ hitter capable of 20HR's. he becomes a key 5 or 6 hole hitter. They work out a long term deal if he produces again once the lockout is over, however with him having less time before free agency they could do a deal next year.

Contreras - Traded because the team is high on Burleson who hits for better numbers and younger. He needs to have a permanent spot that makes sense.

Burleson - Takes over 1st. He will become a league average fielder or maybe even above average. Sign him to a 3 to 5 year deal and just let him hit. A good 5 or 6 hole hitter along with Donovan. Most likely a deal happens after lockout also.

Arenado - Traded

Gray - 50/50 being traded due to the lack of rotation guys and his willingness to stay if need be.

Wetherholt - Starts the year at 2B and becomes the 2 hole hitter.

Scott - Unless he shows he can hit he will be back in AAA quickly. The team has options in Church or other guys to get at bats,

Nootbar - Traded in a package with one of the other guys, most likely Arenado to sweeten a return. The team says they like him long term however he is injured too often, produces too little and the team needs to give a serviceable MLB ready player with Arenado to get anything in return without eating the whole contract.

Walker - AAA bound. He has to be. He cannot continue to be allowed to be a black hole in the lineup and allowed to fail so much. It helps no one least of all Walker.

Gorman - Traded. Too much time spent in AAA and the MLB team to not produce. I am sure he has at least a little value to a team like a Pittsburgh, Colorado or elsewhere.

Rest of the teams needs like 3B and rotation will be worked out through the trades, 1 year deals and call ups.
sikeston bulldog2
Forum User
Posts: 13448
Joined: 11 Aug 2023 16:20 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by sikeston bulldog2 »

StlMike1969 wrote: 01 Oct 2025 05:49 am Not really understanding the logic behind letting Walker and Gorman continue to get MLB at bats without showing they have adjusted first. Bloom and this team have no investment in either one financially. There was only instruction from Moz that they get playing time. I think Bloom unloads Gorman in a trade and Walker if not traded also will be spending his last option in AAA proving he can hit or finding a new groove.

Donovan - Even if he goes to Arbitration and wins again he is still cheaper than a long term deal. They stick him in RF or LF and call it his. You still get a .285+ hitter capable of 20HR's. he becomes a key 5 or 6 hole hitter. They work out a long term deal if he produces again once the lockout is over, however with him having less time before free agency they could do a deal next year.

Contreras - Traded because the team is high on Burleson who hits for better numbers and younger. He needs to have a permanent spot that makes sense.

Burleson - Takes over 1st. He will become a league average fielder or maybe even above average. Sign him to a 3 to 5 year deal and just let him hit. A good 5 or 6 hole hitter along with Donovan. Most likely a deal happens after lockout also.

Arenado - Traded

Gray - 50/50 being traded due to the lack of rotation guys and his willingness to stay if need be.

Wetherholt - Starts the year at 2B and becomes the 2 hole hitter.

Scott - Unless he shows he can hit he will be back in AAA quickly. The team has options in Church or other guys to get at bats,

Nootbar - Traded in a package with one of the other guys, most likely Arenado to sweeten a return. The team says they like him long term however he is injured too often, produces too little and the team needs to give a serviceable MLB ready player with Arenado to get anything in return without eating the whole contract.

Walker - AAA bound. He has to be. He cannot continue to be allowed to be a black hole in the lineup and allowed to fail so much. It helps no one least of all Walker.

Gorman - Traded. Too much time spent in AAA and the MLB team to not produce. I am sure he has at least a little value to a team like a Pittsburgh, Colorado or elsewhere.

Rest of the teams needs like 3B and rotation will be worked out through the trades, 1 year deals and call ups.
Not bad. I’m with Donovan or JJ at third and second. Gives me a GG caliber infield which greatly assist the pitching. Also, which ever plays third, I may get a 20 home run hitting corner.

Herrera. I’m not hip to him catching. I like LF if he must play a position.
scoutyjones2
Forum User
Posts: 8242
Joined: 23 May 2024 14:43 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by scoutyjones2 »

hmoss859 wrote: 30 Sep 2025 18:34 pm
kyace wrote: 30 Sep 2025 12:50 pm Just some guesses where players end up.

Nootbaar- Dodgers , I’ve said this almost all season. They seem to be a perfect fit as they need lh bats and an outfielder to replace Conforto.

Arenado- Angels, They need a third baseman and their owner likes big name players. Not Nolan’s top choice but he goes home and they can be competitive.

Gray- Braves, near home and they are looking to get back in playoffs next year.

Gorman- Rockies, They will try to unlock his power in a power hitters park.

These are the players I think have a good chance to be traded. Here are some that could be traded.

Jo Jo- Yankees, they need a good lh reliever and have lot of young pitching to deal.

Contreras- Boston or Brewers- Boston needs a first baseman and a rh bat. Brewers could use him too. I could easily see him waiving his NTC for either team

Donovan- I think they actually make him a long term offer. If he rejects it then he will be dealt
He fits on several teams. Yankees and Seattle have been after him for several years but they may have moved on. Seattle may still want him as Polonco and Suarez are free agents. Don’t rule out the Mets or even the Dodgers in a deal involving both Nootbaar and Donovan.

These will be the major names, some peripheral players are likely to be moved.i think they keep Walker and hope he finally gets it.
Excellent summation on all fronts.

Keep in mind that Donovan beat Cardinals in arbitration and they usually trade those folks.
Hurdy Gurdy lost his arb case (bleep)
rockondlouie
Forum User
Posts: 12364
Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by rockondlouie »

Not sure C. Bloom wants to deal S. Gray:

Bloom does feel there is a more realistic pathway to the veteran right-hander’s return to St. Louis next season.
-J. Denton
Bomber1
Forum User
Posts: 1308
Joined: 23 May 2024 16:27 pm

Re: Trade destinations

Post by Bomber1 »

General wrote: 30 Sep 2025 18:19 pm I’d expect Gorman and Walker to stay since their value is currently depressed. You play them next year and work to improve them.
That’s exactly what Mozeliak would do.

I hope Bloom gets rid of Gorman while keeping Walker in the minors unless/until he proves he can actually hit.
Post Reply