Anyone think Goldschmidt qualifies for the coveted Red Jacket in St. Louis.

[Bully4you]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

[Adam2]

I think he will end up getting one because the fans tend to have a recency bias. If he goes on the ballot in say the next decade he will be more fresh in peoples minds and probably get a more popular vote.

I personally probably wouldn't vote for him because he wasn't here all that long. Granted the MVP moves the needle. However, i wouldn't be upset if he did get in

[Ronnie Dobbs]

Of course he will. He's got, what, 15 years in the majors? Six with the Cardinals? Borderline HOFer?

Yes, he'll be a Cardinal HOFer.

[scoutyjones2]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

Yes. It's like Oprah...everyone gets one

[Bully4you]

I think he will end up getting one because the fans tend to have a recency bias. If he goes on the ballot in say the next decade he will be more fresh in peoples minds and probably get a more popular vote.

I personally probably wouldn't vote for him because he wasn't here all that long. Granted the MVP moves the needle. However, i wouldn't be upset if he did get in

I'd be okay with giving him that status if we had won.
But we were okay for most of his tenure here, but okay isn't good enough.
So, no. I agree, No.

[Youboughtit]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

More than some that are on there now. So Les say 5 years from now who will be left when the team has been bad? Lean years ahead

[Bully4you]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

More than some that are on there now

I can't think of all that are there undeservingly.
Whom are they?

[Bully4you]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

Yes. It's like Oprah...everyone gets one

pARTICIpAtION tROPhY tImE

[rockondlouie]

He's got a strong shot at being a Hall of Famer.

Yes, he gets a Red Jacket.

[Bomber1]

NO

[Quincy Varnish]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

More than some that are on there now

I can't think of all that are there undeservingly.
Whom are they?

Hrabosky in this year

[Bully4you]

He's got a strong shot at being a Hall of Famer.

Yes, he gets a Red Jacket.

Mic Drop.
Thread just ended folks.
I'm serious about that.
Shut down the thread.

[Bully4you]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

More than some that are on there now

I can't think of all that are there undeservingly.
Whom are they?

Hrabosky in this year

Al?
Hrabosky deserves it for nothing less than his attitude.
I'd vote him in.

[Carp4Cy]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

Reteria got in. Goldy did a lot more.

[Bully4you]

Won the MVP
Had a lot of nice seasons.
But in all honesty, it wasn't quite good enough was it.
Maybe if they had won a WS.
Then I could see it.

Reteria got in. Goldy did a lot more.

Dude, he was part of a historic team.
They won [shirt], you know.
He was a beast in the playoffs.
That [shirt] matter bro.
But like Rock said, he's a HOFer.
That might solidify it.

[MIDMOBIRDTWO]

Get in line behind Steve Carlton who actually won something during his time in St. Louis. Two World Series, one World Championship.