Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/mlb/do ... ccd8&ei=24
Aren't Nootbaar and Ohtani buddies? That's quite a speculated return from the Dodgers to the Guardians. Especially De Paula. The Cardinals could use that kind of a deal.
Aren't Nootbaar and Ohtani buddies? That's quite a speculated return from the Dodgers to the Guardians. Especially De Paula. The Cardinals could use that kind of a deal.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 823
- Joined: 02 May 2025 19:12 pm
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
1. Asian connection overblown, as usualShady wrote: ↑19 Jul 2025 14:57 pm https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/mlb/do ... ccd8&ei=24
Aren't Nootbaar and Ohtani buddies? That's quite a speculated return from the Dodgers to the Guardians. The Cardinals could use that kind of a deal.
2. Clase > Helsley
3. Noot < Kwan
4. Speculated return overblown, as usual
5. MSN irrelevant source
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
Wtf is sterling Bennett?
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 17
- Joined: 24 Jan 2025 22:05 pm
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
No they would not be compable. Whatever that means!
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 13154
- Joined: 20 Nov 2018 23:31 pm
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 1233
- Joined: 23 May 2024 18:37 pm
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
One of the best closers in baseball that has 3 years of team control or a failing closer that is FA at the end of the year?
An All-star left fielder, doesnt strike out, and plays GG defense OR a highly overrated outfielder who constantly gets hurts and is batting .227 this season?
Hmmm I dont know, are they comparable? Not even close lol
An All-star left fielder, doesnt strike out, and plays GG defense OR a highly overrated outfielder who constantly gets hurts and is batting .227 this season?
Hmmm I dont know, are they comparable? Not even close lol
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
but they might be Compablevegascardsfan5890 wrote: ↑19 Jul 2025 18:27 pm One of the best closers in baseball that has 3 years of team control or a failing closer that is FA at the end of the year?
An All-star left fielder, doesnt strike out, and plays GG defense OR a highly overrated outfielder who constantly gets hurts and is batting .227 this season?
Hmmm I dont know, are they comparable? Not even close lol
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 1072
- Joined: 13 May 2018 08:13 am
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
people continue to give away talent to dodgers for their overrated prospects and majority of their top ones are 24, not exactly kids.
majority of them have a big year in la, then peter completely out, especially pitchers. i wouldnt buy anyone from them but ohtani and the the moto guy.
majority of them have a big year in la, then peter completely out, especially pitchers. i wouldnt buy anyone from them but ohtani and the the moto guy.
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
More like a Donovan and Helsley trade. Dodgers would love to have Donovan, plays multi positions and hits left handed. They could use him at third, left field and second base.
I would ask for Hope,Quintero, Morales and Bobby Miller. Hope is a 20 tear old power left handed outfield bat. Quintero is 19 year old right hand power bat who can play center. Morales is an 18 year old right handed 6’3 shortstop that likely ends up at third. All three prospects would fall into Cards top 10 with Hope and Quintero in top 5.
These three position prospects are couple of years away but all 3 have upside to be above average players and Hope has the potential to be a star
I would ask for Hope,Quintero, Morales and Bobby Miller. Hope is a 20 tear old power left handed outfield bat. Quintero is 19 year old right hand power bat who can play center. Morales is an 18 year old right handed 6’3 shortstop that likely ends up at third. All three prospects would fall into Cards top 10 with Hope and Quintero in top 5.
These three position prospects are couple of years away but all 3 have upside to be above average players and Hope has the potential to be a star
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
And you might be totally obsessed.craviduce wrote: ↑19 Jul 2025 18:30 pmbut they might be Compablevegascardsfan5890 wrote: ↑19 Jul 2025 18:27 pm One of the best closers in baseball that has 3 years of team control or a failing closer that is FA at the end of the year?
An All-star left fielder, doesnt strike out, and plays GG defense OR a highly overrated outfielder who constantly gets hurts and is batting .227 this season?
Hmmm I dont know, are they comparable? Not even close lol
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
"Hope,Quintero, Morales and Bobby Miller". That would be a haul for the Cardinals. Very hard to turn down. Wish they could get a couple of them for Helsley and Nootbaar instead.kyace wrote: ↑19 Jul 2025 19:08 pm More like a Donovan and Helsley trade. Dodgers would love to have Donovan, plays multi positions and hits left handed. They could use him at third, left field and second base.
I would ask for Hope,Quintero, Morales and Bobby Miller. Hope is a 20 tear old power left handed outfield bat. Quintero is 19 year old right hand power bat who can play center. Morales is an 18 year old right handed 6’3 shortstop that likely ends up at third. All three prospects would fall into Cards top 10 with Hope and Quintero in top 5.
These three position prospects are couple of years away but all 3 have upside to be above average players and Hope has the potential to be a star
Re: Wouldn't Helsley and Noot be compable to this speculated deal?
The Dodgers and Phillies both need relievers. Come on Mo, make something happen.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 569
- Joined: 26 May 2024 10:10 am