Winns offense

[jbrach]

he teases us with these short bursts where he looks like he might be an 800 OPS with 15 homers then he seems to fall back to high 600s OPS....he runs well and is a great glove the question is what is he going to be going forward?

[sp25]

An 8th place hitter.

[KeeptheRamsinSTL]

He might be traded. I could see JJ replacing him.

[sp25]

An 8th place hitter.

To elaborate, nothing necessarily wrong with that if the rest of the lineup has potency.

[Swuhgen]

He might be traded. I could see JJ replacing him.

lol

Ok. Sure.

[icon]

He might be traded. I could see JJ replacing him.

lol

Ok. Sure.

No kidding. He has 2.4 fWAR right now based mostly on his glove. 14 OAA. But a wRC+ of 97 isn't awful.

However, that OBP doesn't play in the 2 hole. The last 30 games have been a real struggle.

[Ozziesfan41]

He’s good as is. He may never be great but he has gold glove caliber defense and hits some. He’s miscast as a leadoff man or number two hitter but he’s hitting .255 that’s not bad. I’ll take him and Scotts defense with them hitting 8th and 9th. The problem is if a player isn’t a star some on cards talk think they suck and should be traded.

[vegascardsfan5890]

He's better than Volpe and Yankees are committed to him long term

[jbrach]

He’s good as is. He may never be great but he has gold glove caliber defense and hits some. He’s miscast as a leadoff man or number two hitter but he’s hitting .255 that’s not bad. I’ll take him and Scotts defense with them hitting 8th and 9th. The problem is if a player isn’t a star some on cards talk think they suck and should be traded.

a good offense cant carry a shortstop ,CF and catcher who cant hit...one maybe but not 3

[scoutyjones2]

He’s good as is. He may never be great but he has gold glove caliber defense and hits some. He’s miscast as a leadoff man or number two hitter but he’s hitting .255 that’s not bad. I’ll take him and Scotts defense with them hitting 8th and 9th. The problem is if a player isn’t a star some on cards talk think they suck and should be traded.

He will never winn a GG

See what I did there

[Ozziesfan41]

He’s good as is. He may never be great but he has gold glove caliber defense and hits some. He’s miscast as a leadoff man or number two hitter but he’s hitting .255 that’s not bad. I’ll take him and Scotts defense with them hitting 8th and 9th. The problem is if a player isn’t a star some on cards talk think they suck and should be traded.

He will never winn a GG

See what I did there

Good for you don’t care about your opinion he still play gold glove caliber defense scouts say it baseball analysts say it managers say it coaches say it just because scouty says he doesn’t doesn’t me anything to anyone but scouty

[Wattage]

He’s good as is. He may never be great but he has gold glove caliber defense and hits some. He’s miscast as a leadoff man or number two hitter but he’s hitting .255 that’s not bad. I’ll take him and Scotts defense with them hitting 8th and 9th. The problem is if a player isn’t a star some on cards talk think they suck and should be traded.

a good offense cant carry a shortstop ,CF and catcher who cant hit...one maybe but not 3

Masyn winn had a .730 ops last year. The mlb average is .716. Its not lut of question he could fi ish above or at that again. Yes pafes cant be the catcher. Thats no question.

Scott might improve too.

[Ozziesfan41]

He’s good as is. He may never be great but he has gold glove caliber defense and hits some. He’s miscast as a leadoff man or number two hitter but he’s hitting .255 that’s not bad. I’ll take him and Scotts defense with them hitting 8th and 9th. The problem is if a player isn’t a star some on cards talk think they suck and should be traded.

a good offense cant carry a shortstop ,CF and catcher who cant hit...one maybe but not 3

Just how good do you think 8th and 9th hitters are in the majors?

[Pestalozzi]

JFC, I love Cardinals fans but there is a portion of our fan base that is completely retarded.

Masyn Winn is 23. S[top] T[hose] F[raudulent] U[tterances]

[scoutyjones2]

He’s good as is. He may never be great but he has gold glove caliber defense and hits some. He’s miscast as a leadoff man or number two hitter but he’s hitting .255 that’s not bad. I’ll take him and Scotts defense with them hitting 8th and 9th. The problem is if a player isn’t a star some on cards talk think they suck and should be traded.

He will never winn a GG

See what I did there

Good for you don’t care about your opinion he still play gold glove caliber defense scouts say it baseball analysts say it managers say it coaches say it just because scouty says he doesn’t doesn’t me anything to anyone but scouty

Obviously you do care about my opinion by the response.

Sorry if this causes you distress, but MLB is loaded with young, stud SS's. Never seen anything like this...

Nick Allen for the Braves is the best fielding SS right now. They even acknowledged it on the broadcast.

Not a slight to Winn


I've been wrong before and will be again.

[rockondlouie]

People have been focused on Noot's slide but Winn has been right there w/him and even worse.

Last 30 days:
Winn
.243 .291 .350 .641

Noot
.231 .342 .462 .804


Since June 1st:
Winn
.232 .274 .316 .591

Noot
.183 .299 .321 .620