Prospects depth chart

[Nublues69]

Blainville-Boisbriand Armada QMJHL g62 46g 43a 89p 61pim
Justin Carbonneau
Right Wing -- shoots R
Born Nov 25 2006 -- Levis, PQ
[18 yrs. ago]
Height 6.01 -- Weight 191 [185 cm/87 kg]


With Jcarbonneau's Size and junior numbers Does He jump ahead of anyone on the top 20 prospects list.

Just a fun exercise for the prospect Guys here on the site. Apparently he stood out as a man among boys at prospect camp.

I didnt see him play but anyone with knowledge can you rank him in the top 20

[DawgDad]

Bolduc.

At the top it all depends on what criteria you want to focus on. I would say, right now, the top three are:

Snuggerud
Mailloux
Dvorsky

All still project top-6 or top-4, all three are at or near the NHL. I would say Carbonneau is behind all three in terms of proving himself as he plays through his development at lower levels of hockey.

[Harry S Deals]

Bolduc.

At the top it all depends on what criteria you want to focus on. I would say, right now, the top three are:

Snuggerud
Mailloux
Dvorsky

All still project top-6 or top-4, all three are at or near the NHL. I would say Carbonneau is behind all three in terms of proving himself as he plays through his development at lower levels of hockey.

Snuggerud and Mailloux are on the Blues are we saying they are still prospects?

Dvorksy
Stenberg
Linstein
Ellis
Carbonneau
Kaskimaki
Robertsson
Jiricek

This sort of thing? Although i still believe Carbonneau has a very good chance to get the 9 game tryout if he wants to forego the NCAA route

[STL fan in MN]

Here’s how I’d see the top-10 prospects:

2 big horses at the top and then 4-5 more guys that project to be needle movers. Then a big group that have good shots to be support/secondary/depth players.

1. Dvorsky
2. Snuggerud
3. Lindstein
4. Carbonneau
5. Mailloux
6. Stenberg
7. Jiricek
8. Fischer
9. Stancl
10. Pekarcik

HM: Dean, Ralph, Ellis, Burns, Kaskimaki

[John Cocktoastin]

Mine...

1. Snuggerud
2. Dvorsky
3. Carbonneau
4. Lindstein
5. Mailloux
6. Stenberg
7. Jiricek
8. Fischer
9. Stancl
10. Pekarcik

[theograce]

Not overly impressed either what I saw from Snuggerud. Hoping he changes my vibe on him

[John Cocktoastin]

Not overly impressed either what I saw from Snuggerud. Hoping he changes my vibe on him

I'm 100% sure this board, and anyone associated with the NHL, is worried that you're not impressed. His coach was however - you know, the guy that matters...

“I thought he was really good," Montgomery said. “I thought he made smart plays. I didn't think he over-complicated the game and he made plays on first-touch. That's a real good sign of a hockey player with really good hockey sense. I thought he acquitted himself well in his first game in the NHL and I was very confident putting him over the boards.”

Laughing

[theograce]

Not overly impressed either what I saw from Snuggerud. Hoping he changes my vibe on him

I'm 100% sure this board, and anyone associated with the NHL, is worried that you're not impressed. His coach was however - you know, the guy that matters...

“I thought he was really good," Montgomery said. “I thought he made smart plays. I didn't think he over-complicated the game and he made plays on first-touch. That's a real good sign of a hockey player with really good hockey sense. I thought he acquitted himself well in his first game in the NHL and I was very confident putting him over the boards.”

Laughing

Well yeah he’s giving him lots of ice. Making smart plays is one thing. I wasn’t impressed with him during intensity. That seems to bother you

[Old_Goat]

Not overly impressed either what I saw from Snuggerud. Hoping he changes my vibe on him

I'm 100% sure this board, and anyone associated with the NHL, is worried that you're not impressed. His coach was however - you know, the guy that matters...

“I thought he was really good," Montgomery said. “I thought he made smart plays. I didn't think he over-complicated the game and he made plays on first-touch. That's a real good sign of a hockey player with really good hockey sense. I thought he acquitted himself well in his first game in the NHL and I was very confident putting him over the boards.”

Laughing

No kidding!

[seattleblue]

I have a warm glow inside at Stancl above Pekarcik from both my boys MN and John C. I endorse MN's list/breakdown too

[b-a-a-a-rclay]

My first impression of Carbonneau is that he will be working on using his teammates more rather than over handling the puck as he moves up in level of competition. I don't think he's very close to being an NHL player although they may give him a few games before sending him back to juniors just so that he experiences the difference. Of course, it's night and day from what he's seen so far. I thought the poise and thought process of Stancl was much better than where JC is right now ... which it should be.

[rezero]

Bolduc.

At the top it all depends on what criteria you want to focus on. I would say, right now, the top three are:

Snuggerud
Mailloux
Dvorsky

All still project top-6 or top-4, all three are at or near the NHL. I would say Carbonneau is behind all three in terms of proving himself as he plays through his development at lower levels of hockey.

Snuggerud and Mailloux are on the Blues are we saying they are still prospects?

Dvorksy
Stenberg
Linstein
Ellis
Carbonneau
Kaskimaki
Robertsson
Jiricek

This sort of thing? Although i still believe Carbonneau has a very good chance to get the 9 game tryout if he wants to forego the NCAA route

Why do you think Mailloux is going to make the Blues as he was called up for only 1 game in 2024 and 7 games in 2025? Dvorsky has 2 games in the NHL which is not too different than Mailloux. I am sure Army will push Monte to give him every opportunity, but he still has a lot to prove.

[John Cocktoastin]

I have a warm glow inside at Stancl above Pekarcik from both my boys MN and John C. I endorse MN's list/breakdown too

Seattle - I'm putting him ahead due to his size. You can't teach it and love the way he uses it. Can't wait to see his progression.

[b-a-a-a-rclay]

Bolduc.

At the top it all depends on what criteria you want to focus on. I would say, right now, the top three are:

Snuggerud
Mailloux
Dvorsky

All still project top-6 or top-4, all three are at or near the NHL. I would say Carbonneau is behind all three in terms of proving himself as he plays through his development at lower levels of hockey.

Snuggerud and Mailloux are on the Blues are we saying they are still prospects?

Dvorksy
Stenberg
Linstein
Ellis
Carbonneau
Kaskimaki
Robertsson
Jiricek

This sort of thing? Although i still believe Carbonneau has a very good chance to get the 9 game tryout if he wants to forego the NCAA route

Why do you think Mailloux is going to make the Blues as he was called up for only 1 game in 2024 and 7 games in 2025? Dvorsky has 2 games in the NHL which is not too different than Mailloux. I am sure Army will push Monte to give him every opportunity, but he still has a lot to prove.

It sounds like DA told Mailloux that the (3rd pairing) NHL spot is basically his to lose.

[The Average Gatsby]

Not overly impressed either what I saw from Snuggerud. Hoping he changes my vibe on him

I'm 100% sure this board, and anyone associated with the NHL, is worried that you're not impressed. His coach was however - you know, the guy that matters...

“I thought he was really good," Montgomery said. “I thought he made smart plays. I didn't think he over-complicated the game and he made plays on first-touch. That's a real good sign of a hockey player with really good hockey sense. I thought he acquitted himself well in his first game in the NHL and I was very confident putting him over the boards.”

Laughing

Well yeah he’s giving him lots of ice. Making smart plays is one thing. I wasn’t impressed with him during intensity. That seems to bother you

4 points in his first 7 playoff games seems like a pretty good start to me.

[DawgDad]

Bolduc.

At the top it all depends on what criteria you want to focus on. I would say, right now, the top three are:

Snuggerud
Mailloux
Dvorsky

All still project top-6 or top-4, all three are at or near the NHL. I would say Carbonneau is behind all three in terms of proving himself as he plays through his development at lower levels of hockey.

Snuggerud and Mailloux are on the Blues are we saying they are still prospects?

Dvorksy
Stenberg
Linstein
Ellis
Carbonneau
Kaskimaki
Robertsson
Jiricek

This sort of thing? Although i still believe Carbonneau has a very good chance to get the 9 game tryout if he wants to forego the NCAA route

Why do you think Mailloux is going to make the Blues as he was called up for only 1 game in 2024 and 7 games in 2025? Dvorsky has 2 games in the NHL which is not too different than Mailloux. I am sure Army will push Monte to give him every opportunity, but he still has a lot to prove.

It sounds like DA told Mailloux that the (3rd pairing) NHL spot is basically his to lose.

A defenseman plays under intense pressure, last man back, don't fumble puck at blue line, make all the right reads and perfect passes. Lay a heaping dose of pressure on the young man, see what he's made of and what he's learned. If he's ready he'll play with poise, confidence, and energy.

You do not do this to a prospect with minimal pro experience.