Emphasis on 2025?
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 5843
- Joined: 01 Jul 2021 21:30 pm
Emphasis on 2025?
I would like other's opinion on this. With the organization focusing on a reset, rebuild, whatever this is, what is the goal for 2025?
The team is putting the front office in a tough position. Just close enough to warrant a push, but at what cost? Will Mo, Bloom, and DeWitt go for the post season shot? Or will they play for the future?
Their ultimate decision will be focused on what they do with Helsley. Dealing him ensures a return, but decreases their chances at the playoffs this year. Do they deal him and hope a bullpen by committee is enough to capture a WC? Do they hold him, hope for a playoff spot and let him walk this winter?
To a lesser extent, Nootbaar is in a similar position. They could move him and build for the future. His absence wouldn't affect this season as much as Helsley. But it would necessitate moving others around to fill LF and the occasional CF.
I think they should be judicious sellers with both players. Shrewd deals could impact the future without destroying any chance this year. Please share your opinions.
The team is putting the front office in a tough position. Just close enough to warrant a push, but at what cost? Will Mo, Bloom, and DeWitt go for the post season shot? Or will they play for the future?
Their ultimate decision will be focused on what they do with Helsley. Dealing him ensures a return, but decreases their chances at the playoffs this year. Do they deal him and hope a bullpen by committee is enough to capture a WC? Do they hold him, hope for a playoff spot and let him walk this winter?
To a lesser extent, Nootbaar is in a similar position. They could move him and build for the future. His absence wouldn't affect this season as much as Helsley. But it would necessitate moving others around to fill LF and the occasional CF.
I think they should be judicious sellers with both players. Shrewd deals could impact the future without destroying any chance this year. Please share your opinions.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 13163
- Joined: 20 Nov 2018 23:31 pm
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
I expect them to do nearly nothing and hope for an end of season surprise.JuanAgosto wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:41 pm I would like other's opinion on this. With the organization focusing on a reset, rebuild, whatever this is, what is the goal for 2025?
The team is putting the front office in a tough position. Just close enough to warrant a push, but at what cost? Will Mo, Bloom, and DeWitt go for the post season shot? Or will they play for the future?
Their ultimate decision will be focused on what they do with Helsley. Dealing him ensures a return, but decreases their chances at the playoffs this year. Do they deal him and hope a bullpen by committee is enough to capture a WC? Do they hold him, hope for a playoff spot and let him walk this winter?
To a lesser extent, Nootbaar is in a similar position. They could move him and build for the future. His absence wouldn't affect this season as much as Helsley. But it would necessitate moving others around to fill LF and the occasional CF.
I think they should be judicious sellers with both players. Shrewd deals could impact the future without destroying any chance this year. Please share your opinions.
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
It has all the makings of a JA Happ/Jon Lester trade deadline.
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
If you are going to move either one, you need to trade them for MLB controllable talent that fills a need we have today AND next year, not AA prospects like Roby/Sagesse when we acquired them who are years away and might not amount to any MLB WAR. Trades should win games in 2025 and 2026, not just give Shady more Thread fodder.JuanAgosto wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:41 pm I would like other's opinion on this. With the organization focusing on a reset, rebuild, whatever this is, what is the goal for 2025?
The team is putting the front office in a tough position. Just close enough to warrant a push, but at what cost? Will Mo, Bloom, and DeWitt go for the post season shot? Or will they play for the future?
Their ultimate decision will be focused on what they do with Helsley. Dealing him ensures a return, but decreases their chances at the playoffs this year. Do they deal him and hope a bullpen by committee is enough to capture a WC? Do they hold him, hope for a playoff spot and let him walk this winter?
To a lesser extent, Nootbaar is in a similar position. They could move him and build for the future. His absence wouldn't affect this season as much as Helsley. But it would necessitate moving others around to fill LF and the occasional CF.
I think they should be judicious sellers with both players. Shrewd deals could impact the future without destroying any chance this year. Please share your opinions.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 11847
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
Helsley is the key
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
I’ve heard some talk about Taj Bradley from the Rays. I wonder if they would deal him and Fairbanks for Walker or Crooks+. I know they are in the race though, too.rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:59 pm Helsley is the key
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
Then trade Helsley for best deal you can get.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 5843
- Joined: 01 Jul 2021 21:30 pm
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
Surely tomorrow is Fedde's last opportunity. If not, the organization is telling us that winning is not a priority. And attendance drops even more.rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:59 pm Helsley is the key
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
I agree on Arenado. Its Dodgers or bust.
I also agree on Nootbaar. I think he's a Royal, Astro, or Padre within 3 weeks.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 11847
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
Fairbanks is my Mizzou boy, love to see him here!Futuregm2 wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 13:07 pmI’ve heard some talk about Taj Bradley from the Rays. I wonder if they would deal him and Fairbanks for Walker or Crooks+. I know they are in the race though, too.rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:59 pm Helsley is the key
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
Then trade Helsley for best deal you can get.
Bradley has KO stuff, something this staff needs behind S. Gray.
Maybe you add in S. Matz (to Walker and Crooks), who could start for them?
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 11847
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
And let's hope, like Mikolas, Fedde has a good start so a team may gamble on him!JuanAgosto wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 13:08 pmSurely tomorrow is Fedde's last opportunity. If not, the organization is telling us that winning is not a priority. And attendance drops even more.rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:59 pm Helsley is the key
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
I agree on Arenado. Its Dodgers or bust.
I also agree on Nootbaar. I think he's a Royal, Astro, or Padre within 3 weeks.
Keep an eye on M's too for Noot.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 5843
- Joined: 01 Jul 2021 21:30 pm
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
Would Seattle trade a sp for him?rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 13:21 pmAnd let's hope, like Mikolas, Fedde has a good start so a team may gamble on him!JuanAgosto wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 13:08 pmSurely tomorrow is Fedde's last opportunity. If not, the organization is telling us that winning is not a priority. And attendance drops even more.rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:59 pm Helsley is the key
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
I agree on Arenado. Its Dodgers or bust.
I also agree on Nootbaar. I think he's a Royal, Astro, or Padre within 3 weeks.
Keep an eye on M's too for Noot.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 11847
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Emphasis on 2025?
JuanAgosto wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 13:22 pmWould Seattle trade a sp for him?rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 13:21 pmAnd let's hope, like Mikolas, Fedde has a good start so a team may gamble on him!JuanAgosto wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 13:08 pmSurely tomorrow is Fedde's last opportunity. If not, the organization is telling us that winning is not a priority. And attendance drops even more.rockondlouie wrote: ↑11 Jul 2025 12:59 pm Helsley is the key
Without him the team is Closer-less, not a good place to be and you can kiss a playoff spot bye-bye.
That's why they'll wait (unless overwhelmed w/an offer) till the last week (day?) to decide if they deal him or not.
-I think Noot's on his way out, he could be the first to go and he'll bring back a solid prospect.
-Fedde needs to go no matter what their position in the standings is ASAP, same w/Matz.
-We'd all love to add Mikolas to those two but he's got that NTC and might not waive.
-I don't see NADO going anywhere unless the Dodgers come calling.
I agree on Arenado. Its Dodgers or bust.
I also agree on Nootbaar. I think he's a Royal, Astro, or Padre within 3 weeks.
Keep an eye on M's too for Noot.
Woo-Woo!

Plus we throw in Walker?
Dream on, right?