Donovan 5th at 2B in AS Voting; Javier Baez 3rd in the AL OF

[Futuregm2]

https://www.mlb.com/news/all-star-ballo ... ne-23-2025


Cardinals

1B
8. Willson Contreras

2B
5. Brendan Donovan

3B
9. Nolan Arenado

SS
10. Masyn Winn

OF
Nobody

DH
7. Ivan Herrera

[Talkin' Baseball]

Winn and Donovan should be higher for certain.

[hugeCardfan]

Winn and Donovan should be higher for certain.

Maybe if it was just grading defense. Winn is about right this year. But Donovan is better than just #5.

[rockondlouie]

Donny getting ROYALLY screwed.

I understand the Marte love but.........

Donny among qualified NL 2nd basemen:

#1 in BA
#1 in OB%
#1 in OPS
#1 in hits
#1 in doubles
#2 in slg%

Winn is right at #7-9

[Futuregm2]

Winn and Donovan should be higher for certain.

Maybe if it was just grading defense. Winn is about right this year. But Donovan is better than just #5.

I would say Donovan should be 2nd behind Marte and Winn should be about 7th or 8th.

[hugeCardfan]

Winn and Donovan should be higher for certain.

Maybe if it was just grading defense. Winn is about right this year. But Donovan is better than just #5.

I would say Donovan should be 2nd behind Marte and Winn should be about 7th or 8th.

No argument there. Both players could legitimately sue Cardinal Nation for non support. Donovan would get my support.

[Ozziesfan41]

Donny getting ROYALLY screwed.

I understand the Marte love but.........

Donny among qualified NL 2nd basemen:

#1 in BA
#1 in OB%
#1 in OPS
#1 in hits
#1 in doubles
#2 in slg%

Winn is right at #7-9

He will make the team. Cardinals have to have a representative

[rockondlouie]

Donny getting ROYALLY screwed.

I understand the Marte love but.........

Donny among qualified NL 2nd basemen:

#1 in BA
#1 in OB%
#1 in OPS
#1 in hits
#1 in doubles
#2 in slg%

Winn is right at #7-9

He will make the team. Cardinals have to have a representative

[12xu]

Hot Dog Javy #3 in voting for OF in AL? Yes, he is having his best year since '21, but the Tiger fans are stuffing those ballot boxes!!

[Futuregm2]

Hot Dog Javy #3 in voting for OF in AL? Yes, he is having his best year since '21, but the Tiger fans are stuffing those ballot boxes!!

It’s crazy. Meanwhile Byron Buxton is 10th in the AL OFers despite ranking among AL OFers with at least 200+ PAS:

AVG: .280 (7th)
OPS: .912 (2nd)
HR: 17 (T-3rd)
RBI: 47 (4th)
R: 46 (3rd)
SB: 13 (T-5th)
FWAR: 3.1 (2nd)

[HorseTrader]

Donovan's time in LF is hurting him