GDT : Cards vs. Pirates (5/5) ~ 6:45pm CDT

[Jatalk]

not fast enough, VS2

poor AB, Noot

He might be safe. Regardless I wonder about our 3rd base coach

[Futuregm2]

MLB is such [nonsense] with the reviews

[82birds]

safe

horrible replay decision

[gpeeps22]

What’s the point of replay if you don’t overturn that?

[blackinkbiz]

So the catcher can just kneel on the plate to block it now? That's what it looked like to me.

[Absolut]

not fast enough, VS2

poor AB, Noot

He might be safe. Regardless I wonder about our 3rd base coach

He was safe. Ump clearly stated the failed challenge was on blocking. Oli made the wrong challenge.

[craviduce]

the guy in New York bet on this game

[Ozziesfan41]

safe

horrible replay decision

Just awful I don’t see the purpose of replay when they aren’t going to overturn clearly bad calls

[icon]

Home plate ump can't call balls and strikes or plays at the plate. Why exactly is he out there?

[MIDMOBIRDTWO]

That is the most obvious and easy safe call I have ever seen and the NY clowns missed it.

[Absolut]

safe

horrible replay decision

Oli challenged blocking per ump. Not that he was safe or not.

[craviduce]

Interesting....they're going to keep Graceffo around for the extended future....no piggy back.

The writing was on the wall there. BP it is

[BMoreCardsFan]

Horrible call he was safe!

[12xu]

Oli challenged whether the catcher blocked the plate without the ball, he should have challenged the tag, which was high as Scott's hand slid in safely.

[craviduce]

nice, Donovan. Very good read off the bat

[dccardinal]

WTF? Did we have a camera view that the umpires in NY didn’t? The appeal covers both reviewable aspects of the play.