Cardinal Hall of Fame

[musicman]

When will they announce the latest voting results?

[rockondlouie]

When will they announce the latest voting results?

Should be soon:

The full 2025 Cardinals Hall of Fame Induction Class, which will also include a veteran player chosen by the Red Ribbon Committee and a Cardinals organization selection, will be announced in May.

[Jatalk]

I get a little frustrated at Hall of Fame. Seems like everyone gets in. I’m not sure all meet what I would consider the below criteria or definition of Hall of Famer. This is just my opinion and I’m sure many disagree


Exceptional Performance:
Hall of Famers consistently demonstrate a high level of skill and performance, often exceeding expectations for their position or role.
Tangible Milestones:
Achieving significant milestones, such as records, championships, awards, or other quantifiable achievements, is often a key factor.
Long-Term Consistency:
Many Hall of Fames value longevity and consistency in their performance, with sustained excellence over a career being a strong indicator.
Impact and Influence:
Hall of Famers often have a profound impact on their field, whether through their on-field contributions, leadership, or influence on the game or art form.
Respect and Recognition:
Induction into a Hall of Fame typically involves a formal selection process, with members of the Hall of Fame or experts in the field voting on who is worthy of recognition

[Basil Shabazz]

Should there be a minimum tenure requirement as a Cardinal to be eligible for the Cardinals HOF?

[sikeston bulldog2]

Should there be a minimum tenure requirement as a Cardinal to be eligible for the Cardinals HOF?

I thought it three years.

[Jatalk]

Should there be a minimum tenure requirement as a Cardinal to be eligible for the Cardinals HOF?

I thought it three years.

It is three years which is a little short to me.

[sikeston bulldog2]

Should there be a minimum tenure requirement as a Cardinal to be eligible for the Cardinals HOF?

I thought it three years.

It is three years which is a little short to me.

Yea. Five seems good for a team HOF.

[hullie]

Is already saturated. Kudos to David Freese for saying no.

[scoutyjones2]

Is already saturated. Kudos to David Freese for saying no.

So true!

It's the Oprah HOF...

You get a jacket!

you get a jacket!

you get a jacket!

[bakker]

I get a little frustrated at Hall of Fame. Seems like everyone gets in. I’m not sure all meet what I would consider the below criteria or definition of Hall of Famer. This is just my opinion and I’m sure many disagree


Exceptional Performance:
Hall of Famers consistently demonstrate a high level of skill and performance, often exceeding expectations for their position or role.
Tangible Milestones:
Achieving significant milestones, such as records, championships, awards, or other quantifiable achievements, is often a key factor.
Long-Term Consistency:
Many Hall of Fames value longevity and consistency in their performance, with sustained excellence over a career being a strong indicator.
Impact and Influence:
Hall of Famers often have a profound impact on their field, whether through their on-field contributions, leadership, or influence on the game or art form.
Respect and Recognition:
Induction into a Hall of Fame typically involves a formal selection process, with members of the Hall of Fame or experts in the field voting on who is worthy of recognition

Agree completely. Joe Torre imo shouldn't be in. Very good to great few years with the team but just that, a few years. Same with Tudor. Danny mc was promoting Steve Carlton. It's as if the Cards have to draft players who were great elsewhere but the Cards were just a minor part of the career.