Fedde was a 1 year wonder-Everyone on CT bought the [nonsense] hook-line and sinker.

[Bully4you]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

He's a Mikolas. A decent to good game then 2 or 3 duds. You get what you pay for. Cheap teams do this.

Yeah, but isn't as stealth.
I predict total meltdown with him soon.
He's weak.

[Strummer Jones]

There's been a lot of pitching problems on this team--Erick Fedde ain't one of 'em. Even in his clunker of a start he gave us innings. Before that he was a quality start machine. It happens.

Erick Fedde is what the powers-that-be WANT us to believe Mikolas is.

[Bully4you]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

I'll give you that.
He had a few good games.
Reality is setting in though.

[Ozziesfan41]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

I'll give you that.
He had a few good games.
Reality is setting in though.

You said that after he had the last clunker then nothing when he threw 6 shut out then 6 with 1 run then 6 with 2 and you will disappear like a ground hog when reels off three or four more good starts in a row then re-emerge when he has another bad one. Probably chomping at the bit for liebratore to have a bad one so you can pop out on him lol

[Bully4you]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

I'll give you that.
He had a few good games.
Reality is setting in though.

You said that after he had the last clunker then nothing when he threw 6 shut out then 6 with 1 run then 6 with 2 and you will disappear like a ground hog when reels off three or four more good starts in a row then re-emerge when he has another bad one. Probably chomping at the bit for liebratore to have a bad one so you can pop out on him lol

[Futuregm2]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

I'll give you that.
He had a few good games.
Reality is setting in though.

Why is reality setting in now as opposed to the last clunker? After the last clunker he went 3 starts of 6+ innings and 2 runs or less given up.

[thetank2]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

I'll give you that.
He had a few good games.
Reality is setting in though.

Why is reality setting in now as opposed to the last clunker? After the last clunker he went 3 starts of 6+ innings and 2 runs or less given up.

+1

[Bully4you]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

I'll give you that.
He had a few good games.
Reality is setting in though.

Why is reality setting in now as opposed to the last clunker? After the last clunker he went 3 starts of 6+ innings and 2 runs or less given up.

Just because I didn't navigate this site
directly after that fiasco, doesn't mean
I don't believe that.
Some folks can't be on here each and every hour or
day of the year.

[RunSup]

Many on CT said trade Fedde during the off season despite your over generalization.

[Bully4you]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

I'll give you that.
He had a few good games.
Reality is setting in though.

Why is reality setting in now as opposed to the last clunker? After the last clunker he went 3 starts of 6+ innings and 2 runs or less given up.

And I know this just as I know
Guns N Roses are the greatest
hard rock band all time.

[Bully4you]

Many on CT said trade Fedde during the off season despite your over generalization.

Nearly every stinking CTer sang his praise.
Glad to rid themselves of Edman
for this overrated piece of dung.

[scoutyjones2]

Fedde had a low 3s era entering this game. Do i think he will replicate last year. Id say there is a high chance he doesnt. But i think we need to stop insane overreactions to one start on both sides with fedde lately and just let the season play out a little more instead of me seeing fedde is great, fedde is bad. Agter every single start. Lol. Lets stop with the kneejerk reactions and see a little bigger sample size

LoL. It's CT. Roller coaster of love and hate, based on what have you done fore me lately

[rockondlouie]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

Edman is worth every penny, he is a winning player.

Donovan is not the total player that Edman is.

There's a bunch of slugs on this team not remotely equal to Edman, such as Burleson, Gorman, Saggesse, Walker, Siani

Scott and Winn have a chance to be really good, the others, not so much.

Edman was a perfect fit.....for the Dodgers, not here at $9.5M.

Donovan/28 yrs old (.286 .366 .416 .782/120 OPS+) is a better player than Edman/30 yrs old in a few weeks (.262 .316 .413 .729/101 OPS+) at almost $7M less. I'd take Donny 100 out of 100 times over Edman.

But agree w/your "slugs" except for Gorman, I'm not ready to throw the towel in on him just yet.

[Futuregm2]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

Edman is worth every penny, he is a winning player.

Donovan is not the total player that Edman is.

There's a bunch of slugs on this team not remotely equal to Edman, such as Burleson, Gorman, Saggesse, Walker, Siani

Scott and Winn have a chance to be really good, the others, not so much.

Edman was a perfect fit.....for the Dodgers, not here at $9.5M.

Donovan/28 yrs old (.286 .366 .416 .782/120 OPS+) is a better player than Edman/30 yrs old in a few weeks (.262 .316 .413 .729/101 OPS+) at almost $7M less. I'd take Donny 100 out of 100 times over Edman.

But agree w/your "slugs" except for Gorman, I'm not ready to throw the towel in on him just yet.

Edman’s .243 average and .284 OBP would be the lowest average and OBP of his career. They have him hitting in the middle of the order (3-5th) more than anywhere else though, so SLG% is important there.

[rockondlouie]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

Edman is worth every penny, he is a winning player.

Donovan is not the total player that Edman is.

There's a bunch of slugs on this team not remotely equal to Edman, such as Burleson, Gorman, Saggesse, Walker, Siani

Scott and Winn have a chance to be really good, the others, not so much.

Edman was a perfect fit.....for the Dodgers, not here at $9.5M.

Donovan/28 yrs old (.286 .366 .416 .782/120 OPS+) is a better player than Edman/30 yrs old in a few weeks (.262 .316 .413 .729/101 OPS+) at almost $7M less. I'd take Donny 100 out of 100 times over Edman.

But agree w/your "slugs" except for Gorman, I'm not ready to throw the towel in on him just yet.

Edman’s .243 average and .284 OBP would be the lowest average and OBP of his career. They have him hitting in the middle of the order (3-5th) more than anywhere else though, so SLG% is important there.

Not sure how anyone can think he's a better player than Donny who keeps getting better and better at a third of the salary.

When Tommy's sitting at 10 HR's in July that slg% will be back where it belongs in the low .400's.

[RichieRichSTL]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

He doesn't have sustained season over season success. You are assuming that he keeps this ratio. I doubt he becomes disaster bad, but he is likely to regress from last season.