Fedde was a 1 year wonder-Everyone on CT bought the [nonsense] hook-line and sinker.

[Bully4you]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

[Wattage]

Fedde had a low 3s era entering this game. Do i think he will replicate last year. Id say there is a high chance he doesnt. But i think we need to stop insane overreactions to one start on both sides with fedde lately and just let the season play out a little more instead of me seeing fedde is great, fedde is bad. Agter every single start. Lol. Lets stop with the kneejerk reactions and see a little bigger sample size

[BrockFloodMaris]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

Everyone on CT?

[BrockFloodMaris]

Fedde had a low 3s era entering this game. Do i think he will replicate last year. Id say there is a high chance he doesnt. But i think we need to stop insane overreactions to one start on both sides with fedde lately and just let the season play out a little more instead of me seeing fedde is great, fedde is bad. Agter every single start. Lol. Lets stop with the kneejerk reactions and see a little bigger sample size

How do people navigate being a Cards fan, or any aspect of life, as one big roller coaster of emotional highs and lows? Sounds exhausting.

[Mort Gage]

Fedde had a low 3s era entering this game. Do i think he will replicate last year. Id say there is a high chance he doesnt. But i think we need to stop insane overreactions to one start on both sides with fedde lately and just let the season play out a little more instead of me seeing fedde is great, fedde is bad. Agter every single start. Lol. Lets stop with the kneejerk reactions and see a little bigger sample size

How do people navigate being a Cards fan, or any aspect of life, as one big roller coaster of emotional highs and lows? Sounds exhausting.

It takes a special kind of drama queen to get this worked up over an April loss by a non-contending team. I wonder how he is during a real crisis.

[TraveledLessRoad]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

[Ozziesfan41]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

[AnExParrot]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

Everyone on CT?

Yeah, the OP has to do a total re-write of history for his title/thread to make sense. To his credit, the little he deserves, he at least pulled back on "everyone" to "many here" in his post.

[Cusecards]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

It’s funny you didnt post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 2 runs his last start and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 innings and gave up just 1 run the start before that and didn’t post this when he pitched 6 shut out innings the start before that you wait until now lol you’re a clown. He’s had 2 bad starts and 4 starts where he gave up two or fewer runs. I guess when lieberatore finally has a clunker you will be posting I told you he wasn’t a starter hes a reliever what are the cards doing lol

LOL
Have to check my calendar.
Must be Bully’s day to post?
Web7 tomorrow??
Kentucky Kid???

[rockondlouie]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

[Chubbs0910]

It was a bad trade. That did nothing for the franchise unless they flip Fedde.

[hmoss859]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

Edman is worth every penny, he is a winning player.

Donovan is not the total player that Edman is.

There's a bunch of slugs on this team not remotely equal to Edman, such as Burleson, Gorman, Saggesse, Walker, Siani

Scott and Winn have a chance to be really good, the others, not so much.

[sikeston bulldog2]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

Edman is worth every penny, he is a winning player.

Donovan is not the total player that Edman is.

There's a bunch of slugs on this team not remotely equal to Edman, such as Burleson, Gorman, Saggesse, Walker, Siani

Scott and Winn have a chance to be really good, the others, not so much.

I think Saggese is a player. On many teams he’d start at second. He’s a throw back to the Javier’s and Glenn Beckett of the day.

[CCard]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

He's a Mikolas. A decent to good game then 2 or 3 duds. You get what you pay for. Cheap teams do this.

[Ozziesfan41]

That trade was perfectly fine. We gave up an injured, lesser version of Brendan Donovan for a starter who (when all is said and done) will have pitched to a 3.5 ERA over his year and a half here.

Trade was a good one TRL no way BDWJr was paying T. Edman $9.5M or extending him.

Fedde's had four outstanding starts, two clunkers.

He'll bring back a solid prospect in a few months.

Edman is worth every penny, he is a winning player.

Donovan is not the total player that Edman is.

There's a bunch of slugs on this team not remotely equal to Edman, such as Burleson, Gorman, Saggesse, Walker, Siani

Scott and Winn have a chance to be really good, the others, not so much.

lol that’s funny

[Bully4you]

It was obvious Fedde wasn't going to sustain
any of his 2024 luck.
This past off season many here acted like he was
a legit #2.
Absurd.
He's more like a #4 or #5.
Needed to be traded already.
What the hell are they doing.
HELLO Chaim Bloom.
Get in the game.

Everyone on CT?

Large portion.
Like when you go to Golden Corral.