1. Liberatore has looked like the quality SP the Cardinals hoped he would be
2. Donovan has been even more productive
3. Scott has looked like a capable starter in CF
4. Saggese and Herrera have looked good over really small sample sizes
5. Gorman's K% is down to 26.7% and his BB% is back up to 11.1%, more in line with his better season from 2023
In a season which should be dedicated to sorting out the future core of the team, some positive trends emerging.
Player development positives so far this year
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 1681
- Joined: 23 May 2024 15:33 pm
Re: Player development positives so far this year
I would be thrilled if Scott hits 270, plays plus defense and nabs 50 stolen bags
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 551
- Joined: 23 May 2024 13:45 pm
Re: Player development positives so far this year
Walker has really improved his defense. His hitting looked good at the start but has really tailed off. He has opened his stance some since the start. He is pulling off the ball. Hope Brown can straighten that out soon.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 901
- Joined: 11 Feb 2018 12:39 pm
Re: Player development positives so far this year
Additionally:mattmitchl44 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 07:11 am 1. Liberatore has looked like the quality SP the Cardinals hoped he would be
2. Donovan has been even more productive
3. Scott has looked like a capable starter in CF
4. Saggese and Herrera have looked good over really small sample sizes
5. Gorman's K% is down to 26.7% and his BB% is back up to 11.1%, more in line with his better season from 2023
In a season which should be dedicated to sorting out the future core of the team, some positive trends emerging.
6) Jordan Walker looks like a different guy in right field
7) Pedro Pages has hit enough not to be a liability

Longer term, I'm hoping to see more from Walker with the bat. It could certainly happen, but it is not a given.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 9709
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Player development positives so far this year
Good to see although I wouldn't lump Donovan in w/that group, he's beyond the "development" stage and is an established everyday player.mattmitchl44 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 07:11 am 1. Liberatore has looked like the quality SP the Cardinals hoped he would be
2. Donovan has been even more productive
3. Scott has looked like a capable starter in CF
4. Saggese and Herrera have looked good over really small sample sizes
5. Gorman's K% is down to 26.7% and his BB% is back up to 11.1%, more in line with his better season from 2023
In a season which should be dedicated to sorting out the future core of the team, some positive trends emerging.
On the negative side:
J. Walker (.198 .266 .279 .545) isn't progressing at all or is this who he really is?
M. Winn may come out of it but he's taken a step back at the plate (.231 .317 .288 .605)
A. Burleson has no power anymore, in his last 333 PA's he's got a pitiful .314 slg%/.620 OPS per Bernie
R. Fernandez is lost (11.42 ERA), needs to be demoted
JoJo is nothing more than an obsolete LOOGY, great vs LHH'er and destroyed by RHH'ers who he faces 70% of the time
C. Roycroft has already been demoted
A. Pallante looking more like a #4 than the #3 he looked like in 2024
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 12018
- Joined: 11 Aug 2023 16:20 pm
Re: Player development positives so far this year
rockondlouie wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 10:57 amGood to see although I wouldn't lump Donovan in w/that group, he's beyond the "development" stage and is an established everyday player.mattmitchl44 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 07:11 am 1. Liberatore has looked like the quality SP the Cardinals hoped he would be
2. Donovan has been even more productive
3. Scott has looked like a capable starter in CF
4. Saggese and Herrera have looked good over really small sample sizes
5. Gorman's K% is down to 26.7% and his BB% is back up to 11.1%, more in line with his better season from 2023
In a season which should be dedicated to sorting out the future core of the team, some positive trends emerging.
On the negative side:
J. Walker (.198 .266 .279 .545) isn't progressing at all or is this who he really is?
M. Winn may come out of it but he's taken a step back at the plate (.231 .317 .288 .605)
A. Burleson has no power anymore, in his last 333 PA's he's got a pitiful .314 slg%/.620 OPS per Bernie
R. Fernandez is lost (11.42 ERA), needs to be demoted
JoJo is nothing more than an obsolete LOOGY, great vs LHH'er and destroyed by RHH'ers who he faces 70% of the time
C. Roycroft has already been demoted
A. Pallante looking more like a #4 than the #3 he looked like in 2024
I think Pallante is a very good home pitcher. And not good away.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 9709
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Player development positives so far this year
And that makes him a #4 this seasonsikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 11:02 amrockondlouie wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 10:57 amGood to see although I wouldn't lump Donovan in w/that group, he's beyond the "development" stage and is an established everyday player.mattmitchl44 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 07:11 am 1. Liberatore has looked like the quality SP the Cardinals hoped he would be
2. Donovan has been even more productive
3. Scott has looked like a capable starter in CF
4. Saggese and Herrera have looked good over really small sample sizes
5. Gorman's K% is down to 26.7% and his BB% is back up to 11.1%, more in line with his better season from 2023
In a season which should be dedicated to sorting out the future core of the team, some positive trends emerging.
On the negative side:
J. Walker (.198 .266 .279 .545) isn't progressing at all or is this who he really is?
M. Winn may come out of it but he's taken a step back at the plate (.231 .317 .288 .605)
A. Burleson has no power anymore, in his last 333 PA's he's got a pitiful .314 slg%/.620 OPS per Bernie
R. Fernandez is lost (11.42 ERA), needs to be demoted
JoJo is nothing more than an obsolete LOOGY, great vs LHH'er and destroyed by RHH'ers who he faces 70% of the time
C. Roycroft has already been demoted
A. Pallante looking more like a #4 than the #3 he looked like in 2024
I think Pallante is a very good home pitcher. And not good away.
Last year, when he pitched like a high end #3 he posted a 3.88 Home ERA & a 3.67 Road ERA.
Like Winn he has plenty of time to right things, I'm not concerned about either.
The rest I listed, including Walker, I don't see having much upside.
Re: Player development positives so far this year
Winn HAS come out of it. Over his last 10 games he is hitting .351 with an .851 OPS. He came back from the IL picking up right where he had left off.rockondlouie wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 10:57 amGood to see although I wouldn't lump Donovan in w/that group, he's beyond the "development" stage and is an established everyday player.mattmitchl44 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 07:11 am 1. Liberatore has looked like the quality SP the Cardinals hoped he would be
2. Donovan has been even more productive
3. Scott has looked like a capable starter in CF
4. Saggese and Herrera have looked good over really small sample sizes
5. Gorman's K% is down to 26.7% and his BB% is back up to 11.1%, more in line with his better season from 2023
In a season which should be dedicated to sorting out the future core of the team, some positive trends emerging.
On the negative side:
J. Walker (.198 .266 .279 .545) isn't progressing at all or is this who he really is?
M. Winn may come out of it but he's taken a step back at the plate (.231 .317 .288 .605)
A. Burleson has no power anymore, in his last 333 PA's he's got a pitiful .314 slg%/.620 OPS per Bernie
R. Fernandez is lost (11.42 ERA), needs to be demoted
JoJo is nothing more than an obsolete LOOGY, great vs LHH'er and destroyed by RHH'ers who he faces 70% of the time
C. Roycroft has already been demoted
A. Pallante looking more like a #4 than the #3 he looked like in 2024
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 9709
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Player development positives so far this year
Yea noticed that too, SSS (10 G) but like I said in another post I'm not worried at all about him (or Pallante).Futuregm2 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 11:17 amWinn HAS come out of it. Over his last 10 games he is hitting .351 with an .851 OPS. He came back from the IL picking up right where he had left off.rockondlouie wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 10:57 amGood to see although I wouldn't lump Donovan in w/that group, he's beyond the "development" stage and is an established everyday player.mattmitchl44 wrote: ↑25 Apr 2025 07:11 am 1. Liberatore has looked like the quality SP the Cardinals hoped he would be
2. Donovan has been even more productive
3. Scott has looked like a capable starter in CF
4. Saggese and Herrera have looked good over really small sample sizes
5. Gorman's K% is down to 26.7% and his BB% is back up to 11.1%, more in line with his better season from 2023
In a season which should be dedicated to sorting out the future core of the team, some positive trends emerging.
On the negative side:
J. Walker (.198 .266 .279 .545) isn't progressing at all or is this who he really is?
M. Winn may come out of it but he's taken a step back at the plate (.231 .317 .288 .605)
A. Burleson has no power anymore, in his last 333 PA's he's got a pitiful .314 slg%/.620 OPS per Bernie
R. Fernandez is lost (11.42 ERA), needs to be demoted
JoJo is nothing more than an obsolete LOOGY, great vs LHH'er and destroyed by RHH'ers who he faces 70% of the time
C. Roycroft has already been demoted
A. Pallante looking more like a #4 than the #3 he looked like in 2024