Through 2 starts
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
Through 2 starts
Andre Pallante is the only starting pitcher with an ERA below 5.
Sonny Gray -0.2 bWAR 5.73 ERA 4.98 FIP 1.00 WHIP
Erick Fedde -0.2 bWAR 7.00 ERA 6.62 FIP 1.22 WHIP
Andre Pallante 0.1 bWAR 3.86 ERA 5.53 FIP 1.39 WHIP
Miles Mikolas -0.5 bWAR 11.25 ERA 3.19 FIP 2.00 WHIP
Matthew Liberatore -0.2 bWAR 5.84 ERA 2.34 FIP 1.14 WHIP
Sonny Gray -0.2 bWAR 5.73 ERA 4.98 FIP 1.00 WHIP
Erick Fedde -0.2 bWAR 7.00 ERA 6.62 FIP 1.22 WHIP
Andre Pallante 0.1 bWAR 3.86 ERA 5.53 FIP 1.39 WHIP
Miles Mikolas -0.5 bWAR 11.25 ERA 3.19 FIP 2.00 WHIP
Matthew Liberatore -0.2 bWAR 5.84 ERA 2.34 FIP 1.14 WHIP
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 9597
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Through 2 starts
Same old same old w/LIbby
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.
(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.

(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 661
- Joined: 23 May 2024 23:25 pm
Re: Through 2 starts
All Libby needs is more time. You’ll see.rockondlouie wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:55 am Same old same old w/LIbby
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.![]()
(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 9597
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Through 2 starts
Sarcasm RoJo?Rojo Johnson wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:58 amAll Libby needs is more time. You’ll see.rockondlouie wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:55 am Same old same old w/LIbby
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.![]()
(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)
Because he's NEVER been able to have success vs RHH'ers (career: .296 .366 .509 .875).
Re: Through 2 starts
Gray actually has an excellent WHIP. Possible that he and Fedde will regress to the upside.Futuregm2 wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:51 am Andre Pallante is the only starting pitcher with an ERA below 5.
Sonny Gray -0.2 bWAR 5.73 ERA 4.98 FIP 1.00 WHIP
Erick Fedde -0.2 bWAR 7.00 ERA 6.62 FIP 1.22 WHIP
Andre Pallante 0.1 bWAR 3.86 ERA 5.53 FIP 1.39 WHIP
Miles Mikolas -0.5 bWAR 11.25 ERA 3.19 FIP 2.00 WHIP
Matthew Liberatore -0.2 bWAR 5.84 ERA 2.34 FIP 1.14 WHIP
Re: Through 2 starts
LOL, right?Rojo Johnson wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:58 amAll Libby needs is more time. You’ll see.rockondlouie wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:55 am Same old same old w/LIbby
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.![]()
(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 9597
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Through 2 starts
Gray's issue has been the HR ball (started in the spring), three in his two starts.
Like you said, great WHiP + a 7.5 to 1 KO-BB rate.
Just keep the ball in the park and he'll be fine.
Re: Through 2 starts
the sad thing, Rock, is this:rockondlouie wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:55 am Same old same old w/LIbby
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.![]()
(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)
no matter how often you or I or others say, "fire MO, fire Oli, sell DeWitt, DFA Miles"...
it won't hasten any of that.
that's the sad thing IMO
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 9597
- Joined: 23 May 2024 12:41 pm
Re: Through 2 starts
You're so right birds'.........but at least Mo (and likely Oli too) is gone after game #162!82birds wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 10:48 amthe sad thing, Rock, is this:rockondlouie wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:55 am Same old same old w/LIbby
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.![]()
(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)
no matter how often you or I or others say, "fire MO, fire Oli, sell DeWitt, DFA Miles"...
it won't hasten any of that.
that's the sad thing IMO
But it still feels good to say it, better to blow off steam than hold it in.

Re: Through 2 starts
Now thru 3 starts Grays ERA is coming down.Carp4Cy wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 10:33 amGray actually has an excellent WHIP. Possible that he and Fedde will regress to the upside.Futuregm2 wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:51 am Andre Pallante is the only starting pitcher with an ERA below 5.
Sonny Gray -0.2 bWAR 5.73 ERA 4.98 FIP 1.00 WHIP
Erick Fedde -0.2 bWAR 7.00 ERA 6.62 FIP 1.22 WHIP
Andre Pallante 0.1 bWAR 3.86 ERA 5.53 FIP 1.39 WHIP
Miles Mikolas -0.5 bWAR 11.25 ERA 3.19 FIP 2.00 WHIP
Matthew Liberatore -0.2 bWAR 5.84 ERA 2.34 FIP 1.14 WHIP
Re: Through 2 starts
You are probably right this is only his 4th year in MLB and he has not looked good starting in minors or majors in those 4 years. Maybe all he needs is another four years.Rojo Johnson wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:58 amAll Libby needs is more time. You’ll see.rockondlouie wrote: ↑08 Apr 2025 08:55 am Same old same old w/LIbby
Can't get RHH'ers out, through 2 starts:
.342 .342 .488 .829
He belongs in the pen' where he thrived in multiple innings relief, enough w/Mo and Oli trying to force him into being a starter.![]()
(And DFA Mikolas by May 1st, the guys been toast for two plus seasons)

-
- Forum User
- Posts: 1710
- Joined: 23 May 2024 22:10 pm
Re: Through 2 starts
Matz pitched well in Spring Training. 2.29 ERA
Matz pitched well in the season. 2.16 ERA
... but he's not one of our best 5 starters.
Cards pitching gave up runs in big innings in games 5 to 10. In only six games they allowed...
7 1-run innings
2 2-run innings
4 3-run innings
3 4-run innings
2 5-run innings
They look awful in runs allowed but look better in hits allowed, WHIP, HR allowed, OPS against, etc.
So hopefully this is all back luck in sequencing and will even out later in the season.
Matz pitched well in the season. 2.16 ERA
... but he's not one of our best 5 starters.
Cards pitching gave up runs in big innings in games 5 to 10. In only six games they allowed...
7 1-run innings
2 2-run innings
4 3-run innings
3 4-run innings
2 5-run innings
They look awful in runs allowed but look better in hits allowed, WHIP, HR allowed, OPS against, etc.
So hopefully this is all back luck in sequencing and will even out later in the season.