Baseball America 2021 redraft - Josh Baez
Posted: 29 Dec 2025 13:56 pm
They would have taken Marcelo Mayer at #18 instead of the Cards' selection of McGreevy, which is debatable. The surprise was Baez, whom they had the Yankees redraft at #20.
20. Yankees — OF Joshua Baez
Actual Pick: SS Trey Sweeney
Original Drafting Team: Cardinals (2.54)
Draft Rank: No. 31
Best BA Rank: 2026 Cardinals No. 4 prospect
Baez was a boom-or-bust prospect in the 2021 class who was both exceptionally young for the class and exceptionally toolsy. No one doubted his ability to impact the baseball, and he also had one of the most impressive throwing arms, but there were significant questions about his pure hitting ability. Those questions pushed him to the second round where the Cardinals took a shot on his upside potential for $2.25 million.
Prior to the 2025 season, it was looking like a lost cause for Baez, but he made adjustments that allowed him to tap into his power more frequently and turn in a career year. He hit .287/.384/.500 with 20 home runs between High-A and Double-A and cut his strikeout rate significantly, from 35.5% in 2024 to 20.6% in 2025. He now looks like a potential 30-homer hitter with above-average everyday upside.
20. Yankees — OF Joshua Baez
Actual Pick: SS Trey Sweeney
Original Drafting Team: Cardinals (2.54)
Draft Rank: No. 31
Best BA Rank: 2026 Cardinals No. 4 prospect
Baez was a boom-or-bust prospect in the 2021 class who was both exceptionally young for the class and exceptionally toolsy. No one doubted his ability to impact the baseball, and he also had one of the most impressive throwing arms, but there were significant questions about his pure hitting ability. Those questions pushed him to the second round where the Cardinals took a shot on his upside potential for $2.25 million.
Prior to the 2025 season, it was looking like a lost cause for Baez, but he made adjustments that allowed him to tap into his power more frequently and turn in a career year. He hit .287/.384/.500 with 20 home runs between High-A and Double-A and cut his strikeout rate significantly, from 35.5% in 2024 to 20.6% in 2025. He now looks like a potential 30-homer hitter with above-average everyday upside.