STLtoday.com

sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 05:34 am Good morning.

This is a JJ to third thread. I’m having a Shady moment.

19. There are nineteen third baseman inducted into to HOF. That’s the fewest number by position. They are rare.

There are more managers and owner/sponsors in than third baseman.

I look at some of our history- Shannon Reitz, Pendleton, Freese Nado Boyer and see steady players. No hall guys. Boyer should be in.

So it seems fielding a third baseman of high caliber is very tough. Almost non existent. Why then would you not try it if you have a chance. We have that chance.


JJ. Once Donovan is traded, we need a good second baseman. Saggese? Gomber? Neither does much to assist a GG caliber infield. So it’s JJ at second. But.

An internal move of this nature is as bold and effective as a savvy trade. Just think of the possibilities- an AS third baseman who hits like George Brett. There hasn’t been a Brett since George. It’s time.

Then we field a second baseman. Bold. This is a greät opportunity to take a huge step forward.

Finally. Yeah! Would you rather have a stud second baseman or third baseman. And. Which one is more valuable to the infield, the pitchers, the team.

It’s early. Coffee is hot, buzz is waning. Still dark. Any ideas here.

Wattage wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 05:38 am

sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 05:34 am Good morning.

This is a JJ to third thread. I’m having a Shady moment.

19. There are nineteen third baseman inducted into to HOF. That’s the fewest number by position. They are rare.

There are more managers and owner/sponsors in than third baseman.

I look at some of our history- Shannon Reitz, Pendleton, Freese Nado Boyer and see steady players. No hall guys. Boyer should be in.

So it seems fielding a third baseman of high caliber is very tough. Almost non existent. Why then would you not try it if you have a chance. We have that chance.


JJ. Once Donovan is traded, we need a good second baseman. Saggese? Gomber? Neither does much to assist a GG caliber infield. So it’s JJ at second. But.

An internal move of this nature is as bold and effective as a savvy trade. Just think of the possibilities- an AS third baseman who hits like George Brett. There hasn’t been a Brett since George. It’s time.

Then we field a second baseman. Bold. This is a greät opportunity to take a huge step forward.

Finally. Yeah! Would you rather have a stud second baseman or third baseman. And. Which one is more valuable to the infield, the pitchers, the team.

It’s early. Coffee is hot, buzz is waning. Still dark. Any ideas here.

i think the reason less 3b are in hall is more because people exoect nore offense out of the 3b position than 2b, although recently 3b doesnt actually produce rhat more offense than 2b but people still have that assumption. the 2b also has a greater impact on defense usually being involved ib nore plays.

i dont think jj necessarily fills anything better at 3b. also i think its a little early to be saying jj hits like george brett.

weve hyped up many prospects just to see them fail.

Wattage wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 05:38 am

sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 05:34 am Good morning.

This is a JJ to third thread. I’m having a Shady moment.

19. There are nineteen third baseman inducted into to HOF. That’s the fewest number by position. They are rare.

There are more managers and owner/sponsors in than third baseman.

I look at some of our history- Shannon Reitz, Pendleton, Freese Nado Boyer and see steady players. No hall guys. Boyer should be in.

So it seems fielding a third baseman of high caliber is very tough. Almost non existent. Why then would you not try it if you have a chance. We have that chance.


JJ. Once Donovan is traded, we need a good second baseman. Saggese? Gomber? Neither does much to assist a GG caliber infield. So it’s JJ at second. But.

An internal move of this nature is as bold and effective as a savvy trade. Just think of the possibilities- an AS third baseman who hits like George Brett. There hasn’t been a Brett since George. It’s time.

Then we field a second baseman. Bold. This is a greät opportunity to take a huge step forward.

Finally. Yeah! Would you rather have a stud second baseman or third baseman. And. Which one is more valuable to the infield, the pitchers, the team.

It’s early. Coffee is hot, buzz is waning. Still dark. Any ideas here.

i think the reason less 3b are in hall is more because people exoect nore offense out of the 3b position than 2b, although recently 3b doesnt actually produce rhat more offense than 2b but people still have that assumption. the 2b also has a greater impact on defense usually being involved ib nore plays.

i dont think jj necessarily fills anything better at 3b. also i think its a little early to be saying jj hits like george brett.

weve hyped up many prospects just to see them fail.

CNYFan wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 06:10 am I agree with JJ to third. It has been my stance since early spring. I now think the organization will settle for having JJ at 2B but I was hoping JJ would be the 3B guy.

ramfandan wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 06:36 am When JJ's tools were rated , his ARM received a 50 grade . In scouting terms , 50 is the average of MLB players . 60 would be a Plus arm if a guy has a strong arm. (Of course there are 70 Plus Plus and 80 Elite )

I haven't seen JJ play enough at 3rd to have an opinion yet. Want to see him go to his right on hot shots down the line where a 3rd baseman has to plant and throw while straddling the foul line. He is rated as having good range so that can be an asset for a 3rd baseman .

In my mind due to his size, I envisioned him more as a 2nd baseman. Maybe it's because a lot of the 3rd baseman are much bigger
Schmidt 6-2, 200 , Robinson 6-1, Rolen 6-4 245 , Arenado 6-2 215 JJ is 5-10, 190

Maybe he will do fine at 3rd , I just mentally pictured him at 2nd using his athletic ability not only in range but turning double plays at 2nd combining with Masyn Winn as a good combo. Possibly he could be fine at both . Will be watching closely in spring training . Sure appears the Cardinals may want to start him out at 3rd . His hitting will be his calling card in MLB . So if not a premier defensive player, that will not be a big deal .

ramfandan wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 06:36 am When JJ's tools were rated , his ARM received a 50 grade . In scouting terms , 50 is the average of MLB players . 60 would be a Plus arm if a guy has a strong arm. (Of course there are 70 Plus Plus and 80 Elite )

I haven't seen JJ play enough at 3rd to have an opinion yet. Want to see him go to his right on hot shots down the line where a 3rd baseman has to plant and throw while straddling the foul line. He is rated as having good range so that can be an asset for a 3rd baseman .

In my mind due to his size, I envisioned him more as a 2nd baseman. Maybe it's because a lot of the 3rd baseman are much bigger
Schmidt 6-2, 200 , Robinson 6-1, Rolen 6-4 245 , Arenado 6-2 215 , Manny Machado 6-2 218 JJ is 5-10, 190

Maybe he will do fine at 3rd , I just mentally pictured him at 2nd using his athletic ability not only in range but turning double plays at 2nd combining with Masyn Winn as a good combo. Possibly he could be fine at both . Will be watching closely in spring training . Sure appears the Cardinals may want to start him out at 3rd . His hitting will be his calling card in MLB . So if not a premier defensive player, that will not be a big deal .

Absolut wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 07:19 am

ramfandan wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 06:36 am When JJ's tools were rated , his ARM received a 50 grade . In scouting terms , 50 is the average of MLB players . 60 would be a Plus arm if a guy has a strong arm. (Of course there are 70 Plus Plus and 80 Elite )

I haven't seen JJ play enough at 3rd to have an opinion yet. Want to see him go to his right on hot shots down the line where a 3rd baseman has to plant and throw while straddling the foul line. He is rated as having good range so that can be an asset for a 3rd baseman .

In my mind due to his size, I envisioned him more as a 2nd baseman. Maybe it's because a lot of the 3rd baseman are much bigger
Schmidt 6-2, 200 , Robinson 6-1, Rolen 6-4 245 , Arenado 6-2 215 , Manny Machado 6-2 218 JJ is 5-10, 190

Maybe he will do fine at 3rd , I just mentally pictured him at 2nd using his athletic ability not only in range but turning double plays at 2nd combining with Masyn Winn as a good combo. Possibly he could be fine at both . Will be watching closely in spring training . Sure appears the Cardinals may want to start him out at 3rd . His hitting will be his calling card in MLB . So if not a premier defensive player, that will not be a big deal .

That was my thinking. Better fit at second.

Ronnie Dobbs wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 07:33 am I've read and heard some people who have said that they think 3rd is ultimately where JJ ends up. I've also heard that he has more power potential than some give him credit for. But I've also read that he doesn't have great arm strength and accuracy, which hurts his chances of sticking at SS, and could follow him to third.

Guess we'll find out soon.

sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑24 Nov 2025 05:34 am Good morning.

This is a JJ to third thread. I’m having a Shady moment.

19. There are nineteen third baseman inducted into to HOF. That’s the fewest number by position. They are rare.

There are more managers and owner/sponsors in than third baseman.

I look at some of our history- Shannon Reitz, Pendleton, Freese Nado Boyer and see steady players. No hall guys. Boyer should be in.

So it seems fielding a third baseman of high caliber is very tough. Almost non existent. Why then would you not try it if you have a chance. We have that chance.


JJ. Once Donovan is traded, we need a good second baseman. Saggese? Gomber? Neither does much to assist a GG caliber infield. So it’s JJ at second. But.

An internal move of this nature is as bold and effective as a savvy trade. Just think of the possibilities- an AS third baseman who hits like George Brett. There hasn’t been a Brett since George. It’s time.

Then we field a second baseman. Bold. This is a greät opportunity to take a huge step forward.

Finally. Yeah! Would you rather have a stud second baseman or third baseman. And. Which one is more valuable to the infield, the pitchers, the team.

It’s early. Coffee is hot, buzz is waning. Still dark. Any ideas here.