STLtoday.com

Trade Winn?

Ya

scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 19:39 pm Trade Winn?

Scouty really hates Winn.

I would, but only if the return for Winn was exceptional. Doesn't matter though, because DeWitt won't pay the price for Bichette.

ecleme22 wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 19:54 pm

scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 19:39 pm Trade Winn?

Scouty really hates Winn.

You play your roll perfectly

He;l''ll no.

No

Sign Bichette and you have no money to sign anybody else for 5 years.

I personally think that Masyn will eventually improve as a hitter, once he matures a little bit more and doesn’t seek home runs so much. He’ll become a consistent.280+ hitter, while still hitting around 15 homers. He was starting to adjust in the second half, but was limited by his knee injury.
I think he learned that, you have to let the home runs come to you, and not seek them on every single pitch.
Masyn is still pretty young but is a more intelligent hitter than some of our guys!
Defensively, I don’t think he has any peers!

MIDMOBIRDTWO wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 20:24 pm He;l''ll no.

+1

BB is not a good defender. Shortstop isn’t position you skimp on defense.

No.
CORRECT BASEBALL ANSWER.
Next question, please.

No that would be a dumb move

Trading an MLB SS that had 3 total errors in a season would merit the POBO's team physician ordering a brain MRI on the POBO.
Results from physician would be Did brain scan ! Found NOTHING !

ecleme22 wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 21:10 pm

MIDMOBIRDTWO wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 20:24 pm He;l''ll no.

+1

BB is not a good defender. Shortstop isn’t position you skimp on defense.

Winn is the guy I have been waiting for the Cardinals to find to play shortstop. There are those who would trade him just to be making a trade, or in the case of certain guys that hate Winn for some reason. Love the guy and his rocket throws to first.

How many Bo Bichettes are there?

MIDMOBIRDTWO wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 21:32 pm

ecleme22 wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 21:10 pm

MIDMOBIRDTWO wrote: ↑31 Oct 2025 20:24 pm He;l''ll no.

+1

BB is not a good defender. Shortstop isn’t position you skimp on defense.

Winn is the guy I have been waiting for the Cardinals to find to play shortstop. There are those who would trade him just to be making a trade, or in the case of certain guys that hate Winn for some reason. Love the guy and his rocket throws to first.

Do a cards forum advanced search using Scouty’s name and ‘Winn’ for the keyword.

You will find pages of criticisms…