STLtoday.com

He has to be considered. Oli has turned his career around.

kscardsfan wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 19:50 pm He has to be considered. Oli has turned his career around.

I agree. But we should probably ask craviduce. LOL

Umm.... no

About a .0000000000001 chance.

Sure. And Liberatore for Cy Young, Wetherholt for ROY, Gorman for Comeback Player, Marmol for MOY. Am I missing anything?

russellhammond wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 21:04 pm Sure. And Liberatore for Cy Young, Wetherholt for ROY, Gorman for Comeback Player, Marmol for MOY. Am I missing anything?

Cardinals for WS obviously

kscardsfan wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 19:50 pm He has to be considered. Oli has turned his career around.

He is not even in the discussion

russellhammond wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 21:04 pm Sure. And Liberatore for Cy Young, Wetherholt for ROY, Gorman for Comeback Player, Marmol for MOY. Am I missing anything?

Yes the WS championship and the gold glove for Walker.

russellhammond wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 21:04 pm Sure. And Liberatore for Cy Young, Wetherholt for ROY, Gorman for Comeback Player, Marmol for MOY. Am I missing anything?

Yeah, you did miss something. If all the above happens, then Bloom receives the Executive of the Year award by unanimous vote !

Unfortunately, I would say WAY less than slim. I went to Baseball Reference and checked 40 different League Leader categories for the NL. He is 8th in BAvg, no other positive categories that I am seeing. The only other TOP 10 positives in the lineup are Scott 2nd in SB% & tied for 5th in Sac Hits, Contreras 1st & Herrera 8th in HBP, Donavan 8th in ABperSO.

On the bad side, Herrera 2nd, Contreras tied for 6th, and Burly tied for 9th in GIDP.

I am old and the readers aren't helping much, so maybe I missed a STL in there. If so, whoops, my bad.

He is also currently 5th in WAR among position players on the team. Donnie leads at 2.5, which is less than half of #10 in the league.

Sorry, this is NOT a good team and there is NOBODY close to an MVP caliber player.

kscardsfan wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 19:50 pm He has to be considered. Oli has turned his career around.

Of course! Burly is the best player of this generation and can do anything he sets his mind to!

…except drive in 70 runs or hit in clutch situations or play defense or run the bases or reach 22 homers or finish with an .790+OPS from the favorable 3-spot while playing a power position, but all that is overrated. And of course the best argument, when comparing him to others on this 4th place team, his batting average and strikeout rate are a little better, so he’s pretty much elite.

MVP! MVP!

BTW…I do realize you are joking, unlike some other responders.

Of course! Burly is the best player of this generation and can do anything he sets his mind to!

…except drive in 70 runs or hit in clutch situations or play defense or run the bases or reach 22 homers or finish with an .790+OPS from the favorable 3-spot while playing a power position, but all that is overrated. And of course the best argument, when comparing him to others on this 4th place team, his batting average and strikeout rate are a little better, so he’s pretty much elite.

MVP! MVP!

BTW…I do realize you are joking, unlike some other responders.
[/quote]

It makes a certain poster puff up.

kscardsfan wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 19:50 pm He has to be considered. Oli has turned his career around.

Since when do players who rank 5th in WAR on their own team get considered for MVP votes?

blackinkbiz wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 12:57 pm

kscardsfan wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 19:50 pm He has to be considered. Oli has turned his career around.

Since when do players who rank 5th in WAR on their own team get considered for MVP votes?

Lol.

kscardsfan wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 12:59 pm

blackinkbiz wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 12:57 pm

kscardsfan wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 19:50 pm He has to be considered. Oli has turned his career around.

Since when do players who rank 5th in WAR on their own team get considered for MVP votes?

Lol.

Oh, sorry, I get it now. I think I just assumed this thread was started by a certain someone. lol

He's in my head.