Page 1 of 1
Would someone on CT please do a 2024 MLB draft redraft
Posted: 09 Sep 2025 11:37 am
by Bully4you
Someone with knowledge of minor league players.
Just curious where JJW would fall if it were held today.
Maybe craviduce would be able to do this.
Or AOF might have some information too.
Re: Would someone on CT please do a 2024 MLB draft redraft
Posted: 09 Sep 2025 12:41 pm
by kyace
Cleveland would be nuts if they didn’t pick Kurtz as #1. Konnor Griffin most likely #3 . I think Reds still take Burns #2. In this scenario A’s take Wetherholt at 4. White Sox still take Smith and Royals the same with Jac. Cards end up with Bazzana instead of Wetherholt.
Re: Would someone on CT please do a 2024 MLB draft redraft
Posted: 09 Sep 2025 13:09 pm
by Bully4you
kyace wrote: ↑09 Sep 2025 12:41 pm
Cleveland would be nuts if they didn’t pick Kurtz as #1. Konnor Griffin most likely #3 . I think Reds still take Burns #2. In this scenario A’s take Wetherholt at 4. White Sox still take Smith and Royals the same with Jac. Cards end up with Bazzana instead of Wetherholt.
I agree.
Kurtz is killing it.
Under your scenario, the Cards did excellent though.
They nailed that pick.
JJ would have been gone at 4.
Bazzana seems like a nice player though.
Looks like some have already made it to the show.
Although really JJ should be on the MLB team too.
Re: Would someone on CT please do a 2024 MLB draft redraft
Posted: 09 Sep 2025 13:14 pm
by Bully4you
kyace wrote: ↑09 Sep 2025 12:41 pm
Cleveland would be nuts if they didn’t pick Kurtz as #1. Konnor Griffin most likely #3 . I think Reds still take Burns #2. In this scenario A’s take Wetherholt at 4. White Sox still take Smith and Royals the same with Jac. Cards end up with Bazzana instead of Wetherholt.
Thanks for doing that.
Re: Would someone on CT please do a 2024 MLB draft redraft
Posted: 09 Sep 2025 14:29 pm
by craviduce
Redraft this early?
flip a coin...Tails it is.
1. Guardians ~ Konnor Griffin
2. Reds ~ Chase Burns
3. Rockies ~ Nick Kurtz (hits 50 HR in 2025 ....40 in Denver)
4. A's ~ Charlie Condon ....they seek power, but JJ would be the proper pick.
5. Sox ~ Cam Caminitti, LHP, HS
6. Royals ~ J.J. Wetherholt
7. Cards ~ Carson Benge ~ CF/OF Okla State.
8. Angels ~ Bazzana
9. Pirates ~ Jac Caglianone
10. Nats ~ Braden Montgomery
Benge (Mets 1st round pick)....putting up #s almost as good as JJ...almost. He addresses OF, and can play anywhere. Mets hit the lottery with that pick...so far.
Reds are hard pressed to get off a strategy...that strategy seems to be Starting pitching...no matter what. They still draft Burns.
Re: Would someone on CT please do a 2024 MLB draft redraft
Posted: 09 Sep 2025 14:53 pm
by craviduce
craviduce wrote: ↑09 Sep 2025 14:29 pm
Redraft this early?
flip a coin...Tails it is.
1. Guardians ~ Konnor Griffin
2. Reds ~ Chase Burns
3. Rockies ~ Nick Kurtz (hits 50 HR in 2025 ....40 in Denver)
4. A's ~ Charlie Condon ....they seek power, but JJ would be the proper pick.
5. Sox ~ Cam Caminitti, LHP, HS
6. Royals ~ J.J. Wetherholt
7. Cards ~ Carson Benge ~ CF/OF Okla State.
8. Angels ~ Bazzana
9. Pirates ~ Jac Caglianone
10. Nats ~ Braden Montgomery
Benge (Mets 1st round pick)....putting up #s almost as good as JJ...almost. He addresses OF, and can play anywhere. Mets hit the lottery with that pick...so far.
Reds are hard pressed to get off a strategy...that strategy seems to be Starting pitching...no matter what. They still draft Burns.
the Coin Toss....Kurtz was heads, Griffin was tails....1 and 3.