STLtoday.com

Just curious what / who you all think will win.

Who do you think will win?

The kid from Seattle. Ohtani.

Judge. Ohtani

Schwarber and Raleigh.

Absolut wrote: ↑08 Sep 2025 06:39 am Judge. Ohtani

This

fWAR leaders:

AL
Judge 7.9
Raleigh 7.5
Witt 6.9

NL
Ohtani 7.6 (combined, 6.3 batting)
Turner 6.6
Carroll 5.9

bWAR leaders:

AL
Judge 7.5
Skubal 6.7
Witt 6.0

NL
Skenes 7.0
Sanchez 6.7
PCA/Ohtani 6.3

Baseball-Reference really gotta stop relying on just ERA for their pitcher WAR.

Baseball needs a star. Ohtani is a dimming light. He wins in NL. So to energize the sport, create a rivalry. Let the kid win, and Jusge second.

Instant karma.

sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑08 Sep 2025 06:35 am The kid from Seattle. Ohtani.

Except for homeruns, judge is crushing him is most other categories.

scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑08 Sep 2025 07:20 am

Absolut wrote: ↑08 Sep 2025 06:39 am Judge. Ohtani

This

+1

Judge
Ohtani

It won't be close with either.

Swuhgen wrote: ↑08 Sep 2025 10:12 am Judge
Ohtani

It won't be close with either.

I think judge and Raleigh may be a little closer because if Raleigh ends up leading the league in RBI and home runs and hits close to 60 as a catcher it could get him close in the running

AL

C. Raleigh

(Super close vote but CR set the MLB HR record for catchers and just edges out Judge. Judge's time on the IL could cost him the MVP)


NL

S. Ohtani

(TGKS runner-up)

Judge and Ohtani and it’s not that close