GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
First time seeing Herrera wearing the goalie mask.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 976
- Joined: 23 May 2024 18:37 pm
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
Say what you want but the dude has shown he can rake and drive in runsAlex Reyes Cy Young wrote: ↑19 Mar 2025 13:12 pmI don't like Burley at 3, at all!vegascardsfan5890 wrote: ↑19 Mar 2025 13:03 pm I honestly wouldnt mind if the lineup went a little like this:
1. Noot CF
2. Contreras 1B
3. Burleson DH
4. Arenado 3B
5. Donovan LF
6. Herrera C
7. Gorman 2B
8. Walker RF
9. Winn SS
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
good Spring Training, Matz
I pray this translate to the Regular Season.
Fingers crossed
I pray this translate to the Regular Season.

Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
I read the Post article saying if Oli didn’t envision him as starter, he would want him playing full time at AAA rather than a lot of bench time.Ron Gant's Bicep wrote: ↑19 Mar 2025 13:27 pm I am not holding my breath but goodness it would be an injustice if the team still goes with Siani in center after the spring VSII has put together.
I worry that as well as Scott has progressed that a AAA placement now could affect him emotionally. Chance it could really bum him out and affect him long term.
Even if he can play in platoon in CF, I would like to see Scott on final roster.
Your thoughts ?
-
- Banned User
- Posts: 6965
- Joined: 13 May 2020 21:57 pm
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
We are seeing today how productive and explosive the Cardinal's lineup can be when the right people are playing.
Sadly we know Oli loves 140 different lineups over the course of a season.
These 9 should be in the lineup and on the field defensively.
SCOTT CF
NOOTBAAR LF
CONTRERAS 1B
ARENADO 3B
DONOVAN 2B
HERRERA C
BURLESON DH
WINN SS
WALKER RF
Always utilizing OBP and speed whether you have Scott leading off of batting 9th. Winn should be where historically he is best -- batting 8th.
That lineup will score runs and succeed as far as the pitching takes us.
Sadly we know Oli loves 140 different lineups over the course of a season.
These 9 should be in the lineup and on the field defensively.
SCOTT CF
NOOTBAAR LF
CONTRERAS 1B
ARENADO 3B
DONOVAN 2B
HERRERA C
BURLESON DH
WINN SS
WALKER RF
Always utilizing OBP and speed whether you have Scott leading off of batting 9th. Winn should be where historically he is best -- batting 8th.
That lineup will score runs and succeed as far as the pitching takes us.
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
Seaver King....Wake Forest first round pick...#10 . WF placed 3 in the Top 10 last year....Kurtz, Burns, King
getting some mop up time with the Nats at SS today
getting some mop up time with the Nats at SS today
Last edited by craviduce on 19 Mar 2025 13:41 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
Effortless 98mph.
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
Matz has pitched really well this spring. Hopefully he gets off to a great first half and then traded for a nice prospect or two.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 225
- Joined: 21 May 2023 07:26 am
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT

My thoughts: Scott MUST start for St. Louis when the season opens. Not Memphis. Just saw him in Jupiter and he looked as good as any player on the team. Saini is a great defensive centerfielder who cannot hit above .200 with little to no power. Scott gives the Cards a better chance to win, plus he’s no slouch in the outfield or on the bases.ramfandan wrote: ↑19 Mar 2025 13:37 pmI read the Post article saying if Oli didn’t envision him as starter, he would want him playing full time at AAA rather than a lot of bench time.Ron Gant's Bicep wrote: ↑19 Mar 2025 13:27 pm I am not holding my breath but goodness it would be an injustice if the team still goes with Siani in center after the spring VSII has put together.
I worry that as well as Scott has progressed that a AAA placement now could affect him emotionally. Chance it could really bum him out and affect him long term.
Even if he can play in platoon in CF, I would like to see Scott on final roster.
Your thoughts ?
Last edited by EastCoastDave on 19 Mar 2025 13:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
That's the catch 22 this year, if Matz and Fedde pitch well enough to be in demand for a trade,
the team could be in the hunt for the Central.
That doesn't get talked about enough on here.
If Arenado, Helsley, Fedde, Matz, etc... play well enough for a team to want to trade for them, the Cards should have a decent record.
Re: GDT: Spring Training : Cars vs. Nats (3/19) ~ 12:05pm CDT
Herrera with his 5th ST double