Would you go after Bo Bichettes and...

[Banner29]

Ya

Hell no

Yes

[scoutyjones2]

He;l''ll no.

+1

BB is not a good defender. Shortstop isn’t position you skimp on defense.

Winn is the guy I have been waiting for the Cardinals to find to play shortstop. There are those who would trade him just to be making a trade, or in the case of certain guys that hate Winn for some reason. Love the guy and his rocket throws to first.

Do a cards forum advanced search using Scouty’s name and ‘Winn’ for the keyword.

You will find pages of criticisms…

Scouty isn’t hard to figure out. If a majority of cards talk posters like someone he hates them if a majority of cards talk dislikes someone he likes them. If most of cards talk loves mo and oli he would talk about how terrible they are

Yeah, I hate baseball players. You got me. LoL

I've been called a hater and a front office homer. Maybe, just maybe, I'm a little bit more objective and not so subjective.

Bischette is a decent glove, hits for average, OBP, slg and OPS. The horror

Singles hitting fat boy with stone hands.

Now compare to Winns hotting

[ilcubuffs]

BB is playing in WS and could be on a WS winning team. He would come to STL because...................?????????????????

[scoutyjones2]

He;l''ll no.

+1

BB is not a good defender. Shortstop isn’t position you skimp on defense.

Winn is the guy I have been waiting for the Cardinals to find to play shortstop. There are those who would trade him just to be making a trade, or in the case of certain guys that hate Winn for some reason. Love the guy and his rocket throws to first.

Do a cards forum advanced search using Scouty’s name and ‘Winn’ for the keyword.

You will find pages of criticisms…

Scouty isn’t hard to figure out. If a majority of cards talk posters like someone he hates them if a majority of cards talk dislikes someone he likes them. If most of cards talk loves mo and oli he would talk about how terrible they are

Yeah, I hate baseball players. You got me. LoL

I've been called a hater and a front office homer. Maybe, just maybe, I'm a little bit more objective and not so subjective.

Bischette is a decent glove, hits for average, OBP, slg and OPS. The horror

Singles hitting fat boy with stone hands.

Now compare to Winns hitting

[scoutyjones2]

BB is playing in WS and could be on a WS winning team. He would come to STL because...................?????????????????

Money. Money money. As they all do...with a few rate exceptions

And the BJs can trade fora less expensive glove in Winn and his below league average hitting.

[Basil Shabazz]

This is dumb.

If you're trading Winn, then you are doing it to add either a TOR pitcher or MOTO bat.

If you do that then JJW is your plan at SS.

I'm doing neither at this point.

Currently I am moving forward with both Winn and JJW as foundational pieces of my future.

[moose-and-squirrel]

This is dumb.

If you're trading Winn, then you are doing it to add either a TOR pitcher or MOTO bat.

If you do that then JJW is your plan at SS.

I'm doing neither at this point.

Currently I am moving forward with both Winn and JJW as foundational pieces of my future.

exactly this

[Cusecards]

Obviously anyone can be dealt especially if the right deal comes around.
Based on the Cards current situation I can only see them dealing Winn for:
A TOR cost controlled SP.
Or
A legit cost controlled middle of the order bat.
I know people are anxious to see Bloom hit the ground running but I would preach patience.
Contending teams are generally strong up the middle and Winn/JJ gives them a good young combo.
Catching in the system looks promising.
Can Scott hit??

[2ninr]

If you trade Winn and Wetherholt isn't all that you are ruined.

[CardsBest]

Trade Winn?

No Shady.

[juan good eye]

Ya

Hell no

Yes

No every day

[ecleme22]

This is dumb.

If you're trading Winn, then you are doing it to add either a TOR pitcher or MOTO bat.

If you do that then JJW is your plan at SS.

I'm doing neither at this point.

Currently I am moving forward with both Winn and JJW as foundational pieces of my future.

Yep.

In the event JJ forces Winn out at short, let that happen.

[redbirdfan51]

Is Bichette a FA?

[zoiks]

Trading a young gold glove contending shortstop with offensive upside that is making the league minimum so you can give a giant contact to an older free agent shortstop that is one of the worst defensive shortstops is exactly the type of idea I expect to see here.

[Ozziesfan41]

Trading a young gold glove contending shortstop with offensive upside that is making the league minimum so you can give a giant contact to an older free agent shortstop that is one of the worst defensive shortstops is exactly the type of idea I expect to see here.

And the type of stupid idea you would expect from Scouty

[earp]

Bo Bichette is projected to receive a new contract worth around $280 million

?-This is the STL CARDINALS