Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 11:25 am
put the phone down ME ville - the sandwich orders are stacking up!
STLtoday.com
STLtoday.com Forums
https://interact.stltoday.com/forums/
Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
https://interact.stltoday.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=1516465
Page 3 of 5
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 11:32 am
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 11:47 am
Agree.ecleme22 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:05 amYou during all ST: “Herrera needs to start almost every game! Pages is a JAG!”rockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 10:48 am Aside from his well below major league level throwing issues he had two stays on the IL this season.
Could a move behind the plate could to more?
I'd rather move WillyC back behind the plate, backed up by Pages? or Crooks? and slot Ivan at 1st base.
After Herrera starts only 13 games at catcher in 2025:
“Put Herrera at 1b!!!”
Here’s the thing: if IH wants to catch, at least let him try. And if the org didn’t think he had a future in catching, he would’ve moved off catcher years ago…
He doesn't need to beat out Yadi for a job, just Pages or Crooks. Pages is not all that great.
My opinion says he should be in the squat a little more. IF that helps his footwork and throws and he can catch
half the games, the team is better. Exceptional bat for C.
Pages has contributed to 33 WP charged to the pitcher, 8 PB. He's #51 in blocks,
#26 in Pop time, #19 in CS above average, along with #18 arm.
That OPS+ of 81 is worse than his 2024.
Herrera in 2024 was #18 in blocks, #23 in POP tied with Pedro, #58 in CS above average, IH had a -4 while PP had -3,
but has that #59 arm.
To date it's glove/blocks vs better arm.
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 12:05 pm
I love Herrera, but this idea is D-U-M-B.
He's a hitter. Let's just put him somewhere where he won't be a total liability on days that he's not DH-ing.
He's a hitter. Let's just put him somewhere where he won't be a total liability on days that he's not DH-ing.
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 12:08 pm
Ivan is horrible behind the plate. Put his 2025 numbers up...CS% 0 for 15 in 13 gamesrenostl wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:47 amAgree.ecleme22 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:05 amYou during all ST: “Herrera needs to start almost every game! Pages is a JAG!”rockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 10:48 am Aside from his well below major league level throwing issues he had two stays on the IL this season.
Could a move behind the plate could to more?
I'd rather move WillyC back behind the plate, backed up by Pages? or Crooks? and slot Ivan at 1st base.
After Herrera starts only 13 games at catcher in 2025:
“Put Herrera at 1b!!!”
Here’s the thing: if IH wants to catch, at least let him try. And if the org didn’t think he had a future in catching, he would’ve moved off catcher years ago…
He doesn't need to beat out Yadi for a job, just Pages or Crooks. Pages is not all that great.
My opinion says he should be in the squat a little more. IF that helps his footwork and throws and he can catch
half the games, the team is better. Exceptional bat for C.
Pages has contributed to 33 WP charged to the pitcher, 8 PB. He's #51 in blocks,
#26 in Pop time, #19 in CS above average, along with #18 arm.
That OPS+ of 81 is worse than his 2024.
Herrera in 2024 was #18 in blocks, #23 in POP tied with Pedro, #58 in CS above average, IH had a -4 while PP had -3,
but has that #59 arm.
To date it's glove/blocks vs better arm.
Teams ran without fear.
No arm, legs couldn't handle it.
Extrapolate his PB's to the 100 games Pages caught
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 12:17 pm
That idiot ecleme has been on ignorescoutyjones2 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 12:08 pmIvan is horrible behind the plate. Put his 2025 numbers up...CS% 0 for 15 in 13 gamesrenostl wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:47 amAgree.ecleme22 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:05 amYou during all ST: “Herrera needs to start almost every game! Pages is a JAG!”rockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 10:48 am Aside from his well below major league level throwing issues he had two stays on the IL this season.
Could a move behind the plate could to more?
I'd rather move WillyC back behind the plate, backed up by Pages? or Crooks? and slot Ivan at 1st base.
After Herrera starts only 13 games at catcher in 2025:
“Put Herrera at 1b!!!”
Here’s the thing: if IH wants to catch, at least let him try. And if the org didn’t think he had a future in catching, he would’ve moved off catcher years ago…
He doesn't need to beat out Yadi for a job, just Pages or Crooks. Pages is not all that great.
My opinion says he should be in the squat a little more. IF that helps his footwork and throws and he can catch
half the games, the team is better. Exceptional bat for C.
Pages has contributed to 33 WP charged to the pitcher, 8 PB. He's #51 in blocks,
#26 in Pop time, #19 in CS above average, along with #18 arm.
That OPS+ of 81 is worse than his 2024.
Herrera in 2024 was #18 in blocks, #23 in POP tied with Pedro, #58 in CS above average, IH had a -4 while PP had -3,
but has that #59 arm.
To date it's glove/blocks vs better arm.
Teams ran without fear.
No arm, legs couldn't handle it.
Extrapolate his PB's to the 100 games Pages caught
And I NEVER, EVER said what he posted.......guys a liar.
I'm the one who first suggested Hererra work all last winter w/J. Jay and PLAY IN LEFT FIELD.
Re: Where are all of the Burleson doubter's now ?
Post by rockondlouie » 22 Jun 2025 09:05 am
I want them to convert I. Hererra to a LF, something I started calling for them to do last season.
ecleme = LIAR
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 12:35 pm
rockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 12:17 pmThat idiot ecleme has been on ignorescoutyjones2 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 12:08 pmIvan is horrible behind the plate. Put his 2025 numbers up...CS% 0 for 15 in 13 gamesrenostl wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:47 amAgree.ecleme22 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:05 amYou during all ST: “Herrera needs to start almost every game! Pages is a JAG!”rockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 10:48 am Aside from his well below major league level throwing issues he had two stays on the IL this season.
Could a move behind the plate could to more?
I'd rather move WillyC back behind the plate, backed up by Pages? or Crooks? and slot Ivan at 1st base.
After Herrera starts only 13 games at catcher in 2025:
“Put Herrera at 1b!!!”
Here’s the thing: if IH wants to catch, at least let him try. And if the org didn’t think he had a future in catching, he would’ve moved off catcher years ago…
He doesn't need to beat out Yadi for a job, just Pages or Crooks. Pages is not all that great.
My opinion says he should be in the squat a little more. IF that helps his footwork and throws and he can catch
half the games, the team is better. Exceptional bat for C.
Pages has contributed to 33 WP charged to the pitcher, 8 PB. He's #51 in blocks,
#26 in Pop time, #19 in CS above average, along with #18 arm.
That OPS+ of 81 is worse than his 2024.
Herrera in 2024 was #18 in blocks, #23 in POP tied with Pedro, #58 in CS above average, IH had a -4 while PP had -3,
but has that #59 arm.
To date it's glove/blocks vs better arm.
Teams ran without fear.
No arm, legs couldn't handle it.
Extrapolate his PB's to the 100 games Pages caught
And I NEVER, EVER said what he posted.......guys a liar.
I'm the one who first suggested Hererra work all last winter w/J. Jay and PLAY IN LEFT FIELD.
Re: Where are all of the Burleson doubter's now ?
Post by rockondlouie » 22 Jun 2025 09:05 am
I want them to convert I. Hererra to a LF, something I started calling for them to do last season.
ecleme = LIAR
You accusing someone of being a liar? That's richRe: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 13:10 pm
and yet the cards have supposedly, 2 good catching prospects that need to play. And no LF prospect? Yet they switch back IH to catcher instead of LF....
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 13:13 pm
Herrera should have been behind the plate 100 games or better this year. That answer would be known. As was done with Walker this year. He def has improved a lot. I put him back there through at least May and see what happens. Let him get comfortable. This is the position that could really add a bat. No more Pages, Pozo.
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 13:51 pm
He's so odd. He called Pages a JAG all of ST. I think it had to do with PP getting a lot of spring training starts. He was adamant Herrera should be the starter.riff raff wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 12:35 pmrockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 12:17 pmThat idiot ecleme has been on ignorescoutyjones2 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 12:08 pmIvan is horrible behind the plate. Put his 2025 numbers up...CS% 0 for 15 in 13 gamesrenostl wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:47 amAgree.ecleme22 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:05 amYou during all ST: “Herrera needs to start almost every game! Pages is a JAG!”rockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 10:48 am Aside from his well below major league level throwing issues he had two stays on the IL this season.
Could a move behind the plate could to more?
I'd rather move WillyC back behind the plate, backed up by Pages? or Crooks? and slot Ivan at 1st base.
After Herrera starts only 13 games at catcher in 2025:
“Put Herrera at 1b!!!”
Here’s the thing: if IH wants to catch, at least let him try. And if the org didn’t think he had a future in catching, he would’ve moved off catcher years ago…
He doesn't need to beat out Yadi for a job, just Pages or Crooks. Pages is not all that great.
My opinion says he should be in the squat a little more. IF that helps his footwork and throws and he can catch
half the games, the team is better. Exceptional bat for C.
Pages has contributed to 33 WP charged to the pitcher, 8 PB. He's #51 in blocks,
#26 in Pop time, #19 in CS above average, along with #18 arm.
That OPS+ of 81 is worse than his 2024.
Herrera in 2024 was #18 in blocks, #23 in POP tied with Pedro, #58 in CS above average, IH had a -4 while PP had -3,
but has that #59 arm.
To date it's glove/blocks vs better arm.
Teams ran without fear.
No arm, legs couldn't handle it.
Extrapolate his PB's to the 100 games Pages caught
And I NEVER, EVER said what he posted.......guys a liar.
I'm the one who first suggested Hererra work all last winter w/J. Jay and PLAY IN LEFT FIELD.
Re: Where are all of the Burleson doubter's now ?
Post by rockondlouie » 22 Jun 2025 09:05 am
I want them to convert I. Hererra to a LF, something I started calling for them to do last season.
ecleme = LIAR
Oh and we did he put me on ignore? Because he said Tim Raines never put fear in pitchers, so I pushed back at that. He got threatened and put me on ignore. LOL
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 14:07 pm
They do. One of them will be a rookie next year and bats LH, so he can easily platoon. The other is in AA, so they aren’t rushing him up any time soon.Clubmaker2 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 13:10 pm and yet the cards have supposedly, 2 good catching prospects that need to play. And no LF prospect? Yet they switch back IH to catcher instead of LF....
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 14:27 pm
Good prospects need to play a fair amount. You are going to platoon IH at catcher, he is about your best hitter? If you say he will switch to dh those days, then why have a team where the dh sucks and easily gets replaced by the catcher . That is a platoon to rh pitching , which is most of the time... Cards will Again, just make (bleep) roster construction.Ronnie Dobbs wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 14:07 pmThey do. One of them will be a rookie next year and bats LH, so he can easily platoon. The other is in AA, so they aren’t rushing him up any time soon.Clubmaker2 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 13:10 pm and yet the cards have supposedly, 2 good catching prospects that need to play. And no LF prospect? Yet they switch back IH to catcher instead of LF....
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 14:34 pm
Want to build a competitive team from the start?
Get the best fielders/athletics you can from up the middle defense. This will also help your pitchers - giving them more confidence that the fielders can bail them out
That’s not Herrera.
Then add bats at the corners - but not someone who can’t field their position adequately.
Add a veteran starter, hopefully ax near-ace.
Get the best fielders/athletics you can from up the middle defense. This will also help your pitchers - giving them more confidence that the fielders can bail them out
That’s not Herrera.
Then add bats at the corners - but not someone who can’t field their position adequately.
Add a veteran starter, hopefully ax near-ace.
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 15:15 pm
Start working on improving his throwing. Right after he heals from elbow surgery. Herrera is hurt a lot. Catcher might not be a good position for him.ramfandan wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 17:42 pm according to Oli as reported by Jim Hayes in pregame show .
Guess Oli is feeling he has manager's spot sowed up .
If Herrera can improve defensively to be primary catcher , that means it frees up a 'bat' to be the DH spot adding improved offense .
Guess Bloom will address this in a month
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 15:25 pm
He went to the driveline throwing lab last off season, seems it didnt help. Why is there anything to be optimistic about? Agree, injury issues, no more catching. He should likely be George Foster playing left field ...rightthinker4 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 15:15 pmStart working on improving his throwing. Right after he heals from elbow surgery. Herrera is hurt a lot. Catcher might not be a good position for him.ramfandan wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 17:42 pm according to Oli as reported by Jim Hayes in pregame show .
Guess Oli is feeling he has manager's spot sowed up .
If Herrera can improve defensively to be primary catcher , that means it frees up a 'bat' to be the DH spot adding improved offense .
Guess Bloom will address this in a month
Re: Herrera going to spring training 2026 as a catcher ?
Posted: 21 Sep 2025 16:01 pm
You’re right.scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 12:08 pmIvan is horrible behind the plate. Put his 2025 numbers up...CS% 0 for 15 in 13 gamesrenostl wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:47 amAgree.ecleme22 wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 11:05 amYou during all ST: “Herrera needs to start almost every game! Pages is a JAG!”rockondlouie wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 10:48 am Aside from his well below major league level throwing issues he had two stays on the IL this season.
Could a move behind the plate could to more?
I'd rather move WillyC back behind the plate, backed up by Pages? or Crooks? and slot Ivan at 1st base.
After Herrera starts only 13 games at catcher in 2025:
“Put Herrera at 1b!!!”
Here’s the thing: if IH wants to catch, at least let him try. And if the org didn’t think he had a future in catching, he would’ve moved off catcher years ago…
He doesn't need to beat out Yadi for a job, just Pages or Crooks. Pages is not all that great.
My opinion says he should be in the squat a little more. IF that helps his footwork and throws and he can catch
half the games, the team is better. Exceptional bat for C.
Pages has contributed to 33 WP charged to the pitcher, 8 PB. He's #51 in blocks,
#26 in Pop time, #19 in CS above average, along with #18 arm.
That OPS+ of 81 is worse than his 2024.
Herrera in 2024 was #18 in blocks, #23 in POP tied with Pedro, #58 in CS above average, IH had a -4 while PP had -3,
but has that #59 arm.
To date it's glove/blocks vs better arm.
Teams ran without fear.
No arm, legs couldn't handle it.
Extrapolate his PB's to the 100 games Pages caught
And if I thought that Bloom would trade Crooks, etc. because IH wants to try catching again in 2026, I’d be upset.
As of now, it’s a nothing burger.