Re: What do you think Bloom is asking for Donovan ?
Posted: 29 Nov 2025 23:32 pm
I doubt Bloom is focused on what to ask for. He's listening to what is being offered at this point. There'll be time to refine his ask.
STLtoday.com Forums
https://interact.stltoday.com/forums/
https://interact.stltoday.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=1518259
When I first started reading this thread I had the same basic thought, get a throw in pitcher on the deal. Is that really a good way to go? You can pick up a Kirk GIbson/Lance Lynn type for nothing just about anytime to fill that spot. So maybe better to upgrade the prospect or international money. Either way works.craviduce wrote: ↑29 Nov 2025 20:52 pm Top tier prospect, lottery ticket and/or starting pitcher with some control (can't be picky there, so maybe 1 or 2 years left in Arb), and a Competitive Balance pick in the 2026 draft...if the team we trade with doesn't have a CBP, then $200K in IFA bonus allotment.
Maybe I'm being too greedy? But that seems on par for Donovan's BTV. PLease, correct me if I'm wrong....too much/too little.
edit ~ the starting pitcher won't be a great one...4.00-4.50 ERA, but can hurl 150 plus innings.
Evidently, craviduce claims Donovan won't bring that kind of a starting pitcher. I say, it depends on the number of teams bidding for him. The more I read about all of the teams lining up for a chance to trade for Donovan. It's seems this is a rare opportunity to stack the shelf by filling needs with quality players. Ex. a high level starting pitcher with some years of team control and a RH hitting power hitter. Actually, of LH power hitter would do if he is/could be a legit MOTO hitter.rockondlouie wrote: ↑30 Nov 2025 08:57 am Young major league starter w/multiple years of control and (minimum) upside to being a #2
or
AA/AAA starting pitcher with (minimum) #2 upside and ready to make the leap to MLB no later than 2027.
And it's very possible Bloom will have to add (perhaps a catcher?) to achieve that goal.Shady wrote: ↑30 Nov 2025 10:12 amEvidently, craviduce claims Donovan won't bring that kind of a starting pitcher. I say, it depends on the number of teams bidding for him. The more I read about all of the teams lining up for a chance to trade for Donovan. It's seems this is a rare opportunity to stack the shelf by filling needs with quality players. Ex. a high level starting pitcher with some years of team control and a RH hitting power hitter. Actually, of LH power hitter would do if he is/could be a legit MOTO hitter.rockondlouie wrote: ↑30 Nov 2025 08:57 am Young major league starter w/multiple years of control and (minimum) upside to being a #2
or
AA/AAA starting pitcher with (minimum) #2 upside and ready to make the leap to MLB no later than 2027.
That's a good idea regarding possibly adding a catcher (Catdinals have an abundance) to enhance a deal for something really special in a Donovan deal.rockondlouie wrote: ↑30 Nov 2025 10:28 amAnd it's very possible Bloom will have to add (perhaps a catcher?) to achieve that goal.Shady wrote: ↑30 Nov 2025 10:12 amEvidently, craviduce claims Donovan won't bring that kind of a starting pitcher. I say, it depends on the number of teams bidding for him. The more I read about all of the teams lining up for a chance to trade for Donovan. It's seems this is a rare opportunity to stack the shelf by filling needs with quality players. Ex. a high level starting pitcher with some years of team control and a RH hitting power hitter. Actually, of LH power hitter would do if he is/could be a legit MOTO hitter.rockondlouie wrote: ↑30 Nov 2025 08:57 am Young major league starter w/multiple years of control and (minimum) upside to being a #2
or
AA/AAA starting pitcher with (minimum) #2 upside and ready to make the leap to MLB no later than 2027.
A bidding war will likely ensue given Donny is in demand by almost all contenders.
If he asks too much….potential deals fall through and the club gets nothing
It was a mistake to leak to a reporter that he wanted to trade Donovan. Teams are going to lowball him thinking he is desperate. Now he's walking it back saying he might keep Donovan if he doesn't get enough.ramfandan wrote: ↑29 Nov 2025 19:58 pm For sure (as all GM's do ) , Bloom is playing the game when asked about Donovan . The standard line would be 'well , it would take a substantial return to give up Donovan but I am willing to listen . If I get his value, I would consider it . Sure !
So then in general terms , the teams would be asking Bloom so what areas are you seeking ? (not specific names initially but pitchers vs position players.. major leaguers / prospects )
If you were a fly on Bloom's wall , what are you thinking Bloom is telling them ?
Haven’t had the pleasure…sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑30 Nov 2025 11:06 amHave you ever heard the song- The Zoo -Scorpions.