Baez could get a look after a couple hundred minor league PA's next year.
Depends on how he looks.
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
Baez could get a look after a couple hundred minor league PA's next year.
I doubt it. Wetherholt was better in aaa than Baez in aa. And they didn't bring up Wetherholt. We have fundamental differences in the direction we think the club is going, so we aren't going to agree on this. I understand the reasons for not bringing up Wetherholt are different, but I think the colossal failure of Walker is going to stay with them for awhile. And frankly, if Baez does blow up aaa, they probably want to maximize the years he is under club controlMelville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:02 pmBaez could get a look after a couple hundred minor league PA's next year.
Depends on how he looks.
I have to admit......I both laughed AND cried while reading the combined absurdity and sentimentality of your post!Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 17:27 pmNever about me.scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 16:16 pmYou OK,? So wrong about the UniKKKorn.Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:34 pmMock him if that is what your character dictates, but Shady has been proven correct about Burleson.imadangman wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:09 pm craviduce, are there any "hotshots" you'd be so kind to inform us of, right here on this here groundbreaking shady thread that has been started during the 12 o'clock hour of this here September the 20th, Two thousand and twenty-five.
Nothing wrong with him wondering who else might be on the way with less fanfare than Wetherholt.
![]()
It is regrettable when others attempt to make it so.
I am only and always about the game.
It is boorish on your part to attempt to highjack a thread based on a perfectly reasonable question.
So won't go there - other than to say I have been perfectly correct about Gorman and remain so today.
Now, back to Shady's appropriate question.
Prospect lists change from year to year, but the position player in the STL system who interest me the most in looking at 2026, other than Wetherholt, is Joshua Baez
Shady asked "who behind Wetherholt"?2ninr wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:17 pmI doubt it. Wetherholt was better in aaa than Baez in aa. And they didn't bring up Wetherholt. We have fundamental differences in the direction we think the club is going, so we aren't going to agree on this. I understand the reasons for not bringing up Wetherholt are different, but I think the colossal failure of Walker is going to stay with them for awhile. And frankly, if Baez does blow up aaa, they probably want to maximize the years he is under club controlMelville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:02 pmBaez could get a look after a couple hundred minor league PA's next year.
Depends on how he looks.
I hear what you are saying, but the need is different. They have multiple middle infielders and many left handed bats. They are kind of desperate for a right handed hitting outfielder.2ninr wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:17 pmI doubt it. Wetherholt was better in aaa than Baez in aa. And they didn't bring up Wetherholt. We have fundamental differences in the direction we think the club is going, so we aren't going to agree on this. I understand the reasons for not bringing up Wetherholt are different, but I think the colossal failure of Walker is going to stay with them for awhile. And frankly, if Baez does blow up aaa, they probably want to maximize the years he is under club controlMelville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:02 pmBaez could get a look after a couple hundred minor league PA's next year.
Depends on how he looks.
Precisely.Talkin' Baseball wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 21:51 pmI hear what you are saying, but the need is different. They have multiple middle infielders and many left handed bats. They are kind of desperate for a right handed hitting outfielder.2ninr wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:17 pmI doubt it. Wetherholt was better in aaa than Baez in aa. And they didn't bring up Wetherholt. We have fundamental differences in the direction we think the club is going, so we aren't going to agree on this. I understand the reasons for not bringing up Wetherholt are different, but I think the colossal failure of Walker is going to stay with them for awhile. And frankly, if Baez does blow up aaa, they probably want to maximize the years he is under club controlMelville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:02 pmBaez could get a look after a couple hundred minor league PA's next year.
Depends on how he looks.
He was outside the Cardinals top 30 and struck out 45% of the time in A ball in 2024. So 2025 has indeed been a meteoric rise for him. He started the season in A ball. I give it a zero % chance he starts the season in St Louis. Chaim Blooms calling card is not rushing players to fix what's wrong with the major league team. However badly we need power, especially rh power, I don't see a pathway for him in 2026. Click your heelsMelville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 21:11 pmShady asked "who behind Wetherholt"?2ninr wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:17 pmI doubt it. Wetherholt was better in aaa than Baez in aa. And they didn't bring up Wetherholt. We have fundamental differences in the direction we think the club is going, so we aren't going to agree on this. I understand the reasons for not bringing up Wetherholt are different, but I think the colossal failure of Walker is going to stay with them for awhile. And frankly, if Baez does blow up aaa, they probably want to maximize the years he is under club controlMelville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:02 pmBaez could get a look after a couple hundred minor league PA's next year.
Depends on how he looks.
He was asking for a comparison as to which was better at aa or aaa.
Baez, if he shows well in 2026 in a couple hundred of PA's at AAA, could very well get a look by August.
And no, there will be zero worry about repeating Walker's story.
If Baez debuts sometime next year, he will be 3 years older than when Walker did so - and will be in his 6th professional season.
I can acknowledge you have been right on several occasions and saw things the majority did not. Your assessment of Gorman is not one of these occasions.Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 17:27 pmNever about me.scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 16:16 pmYou OK,? So wrong about the UniKKKorn.Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:34 pmMock him if that is what your character dictates, but Shady has been proven correct about Burleson.imadangman wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:09 pm craviduce, are there any "hotshots" you'd be so kind to inform us of, right here on this here groundbreaking shady thread that has been started during the 12 o'clock hour of this here September the 20th, Two thousand and twenty-five.
Nothing wrong with him wondering who else might be on the way with less fanfare than Wetherholt.
![]()
It is regrettable when others attempt to make it so.
I am only and always about the game.
It is boorish on your part to attempt to highjack a thread based on a perfectly reasonable question.
So won't go there - other than to say I have been perfectly correct about Gorman and remain so today.
Now, back to Shady's appropriate question.
Prospect lists change from year to year, but the position player in the STL system who interest me the most in looking at 2026, other than Wetherholt, is Joshua Baez
Appreciate your initial kind words.CorneliusWolfe wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 07:56 amI can acknowledge you have been right on several occasions and saw things the majority did not. Your assessment of Gorman is not one of these occasions.Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 17:27 pmNever about me.scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 16:16 pmYou OK,? So wrong about the UniKKKorn.Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:34 pmMock him if that is what your character dictates, but Shady has been proven correct about Burleson.imadangman wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:09 pm craviduce, are there any "hotshots" you'd be so kind to inform us of, right here on this here groundbreaking shady thread that has been started during the 12 o'clock hour of this here September the 20th, Two thousand and twenty-five.
Nothing wrong with him wondering who else might be on the way with less fanfare than Wetherholt.
![]()
It is regrettable when others attempt to make it so.
I am only and always about the game.
It is boorish on your part to attempt to highjack a thread based on a perfectly reasonable question.
So won't go there - other than to say I have been perfectly correct about Gorman and remain so today.
Now, back to Shady's appropriate question.
Prospect lists change from year to year, but the position player in the STL system who interest me the most in looking at 2026, other than Wetherholt, is Joshua Baez
Unless you’re taking the Shady approach on Burleson, which you curiously defend….tout his abilities and potential through 3 awful seasons and claim victory if he turns in one slightly above average season.
yupAZ_Cardsfan wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 18:00 pm What about Liam Doyle? #5 overall pick labeled closest to big league ready.
Blaze Jordan is also a possible jolt. 22 years old power bat hitting well in AAA this year.
Heck a lot of the pitching falls into the catagory of "if he finds ML command he is ready".
is this why you got my order wrong ? - I said mayo not mustard!Melville wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 09:09 amAppreciate your initial kind words.CorneliusWolfe wrote: ↑21 Sep 2025 07:56 amI can acknowledge you have been right on several occasions and saw things the majority did not. Your assessment of Gorman is not one of these occasions.Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 17:27 pmNever about me.scoutyjones2 wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 16:16 pmYou OK,? So wrong about the UniKKKorn.Melville wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:34 pmMock him if that is what your character dictates, but Shady has been proven correct about Burleson.imadangman wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 14:09 pm craviduce, are there any "hotshots" you'd be so kind to inform us of, right here on this here groundbreaking shady thread that has been started during the 12 o'clock hour of this here September the 20th, Two thousand and twenty-five.
Nothing wrong with him wondering who else might be on the way with less fanfare than Wetherholt.
![]()
It is regrettable when others attempt to make it so.
I am only and always about the game.
It is boorish on your part to attempt to highjack a thread based on a perfectly reasonable question.
So won't go there - other than to say I have been perfectly correct about Gorman and remain so today.
Now, back to Shady's appropriate question.
Prospect lists change from year to year, but the position player in the STL system who interest me the most in looking at 2026, other than Wetherholt, is Joshua Baez
Unless you’re taking the Shady approach on Burleson, which you curiously defend….tout his abilities and potential through 3 awful seasons and claim victory if he turns in one slightly above average season.
I am only and always about the game.
Zero bias, zero agenda.
Concerning Gorman, my analysis was and remains correct.
I have said from day one that if given 600 PA's a season, we would be a 25+ HR, 80+ RBI hitter.
Which is EXACTLY who he has been.
His 162 game / 600 PA average is 28 HR and 79 RBI - and he is barely 25 years old.
That is excellent production from a 25 year old 3b/2b.
It would be impossible for anyone to be more correct than I have been, so far.
Does he need to raise his BA and OBP by 20 points, and cut down on K's?
Yes.
And that will happen with consistent playing time.
That consistent playing time may come somewhere other than STL, giving the organization's incomprehensible handling of him.
Let's see what happens.
I am confident he will continue to reach - and exceed - what I have correctly stated all along.
Now, back to the topic of this thread.
Shady asked who, behind Wetherholt, might be on a path to being a productive contributor.
He was immediately and needlessly mocked for asking a perfectly legitimate question.
I don't do that - with anyone.
Instead, I pointed out he was right about Burleson (.269/.314/.420 in '24 and .289/.342/.464 this season) when most were not.
And, I stated that Joshua Baez is the prospect position player I am most interested in seeing continues progress from in 2026.
Every portion of my post is perfectly accurate, of course.