STLtoday.com

Posted: **29 May 2025 15:01 pm**

McGreevy is the only SP depth the Cards have as of now. Plus the team is winning. The talk of trading a SP to make a spot for McGreevy is not the right baseball decision. Sure, McGreevy deserves to be in the MLs, no argument here. But, very rarely do starting rotations make it the entire year without a starter going down. If my memory is correct, 2015 is the last year the Cards achieved that. So more likely than not, McGreevy will get his chance. Second, trading when you are winning doesn't seem like a good clubhouse move. Lets see how this plays out.

Posted: **29 May 2025 15:27 pm**

Pallante going nowhere but St Louis

Posted: **29 May 2025 16:21 pm**

sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:56 pm
rockondlouie wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:52 pm
sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:41 pm No. He’s a Road Warrior. He wins on the road. Team is 4-3 in his SEVEN starts on the road. Need guys like this. If he don’t walk people he’s good. Mikolas is holding McG spot.
Not hardly BDog,

He's more like Road Kill!

McGreevy's the better option.
Not the way to do business- send a guy down who is doing his job. Through attrition and performance McG will get his. Not this way.

And his starts have been against good teams in rough locations.

Or maybe we wait a little longer then trade McGreevey for Pete Crow Armstrong, or Oneil Cruz.

Posted: **29 May 2025 16:47 pm**

ICCFIM2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 15:01 pm McGreevy is the only SP depth the Cards have as of now. Plus the team is winning. The talk of trading a SP to make a spot for McGreevy is not the right baseball decision. Sure, McGreevy deserves to be in the MLs, no argument here. But, very rarely do starting rotations make it the entire year without a starter going down. If my memory is correct, 2015 is the last year the Cards achieved that. So more likely than not, McGreevy will get his chance. Second, trading when you are winning doesn't seem like a good clubhouse move. Lets see how this plays out.

Pallante and McGreevy will both be in the starting rotation after August 1. Fedde, Mikolas and Matz will all likely be gone, as they are pending free agents the Cards likely won’t re-sign.

Posted: **29 May 2025 16:49 pm**

I think it's great that the team is playing well enough that one the few complaints available would center around keeping Pallante in the rotation. He has been up and down lately but he has proven if given a leash he will likely figure things out. And his bad hasnt been terrible. We have a chance to win most of his starts. McGreevy will get his chance either by injury or attrition in the coming months. I would not send Pallante anywhere but back to the mound every 5th day for the Cardinals.

Posted: **29 May 2025 16:49 pm**

BrockFloodMaris wrote: ↑29 May 2025 16:47 pm
ICCFIM2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 15:01 pm McGreevy is the only SP depth the Cards have as of now. Plus the team is winning. The talk of trading a SP to make a spot for McGreevy is not the right baseball decision. Sure, McGreevy deserves to be in the MLs, no argument here. But, very rarely do starting rotations make it the entire year without a starter going down. If my memory is correct, 2015 is the last year the Cards achieved that. So more likely than not, McGreevy will get his chance. Second, trading when you are winning doesn't seem like a good clubhouse move. Lets see how this plays out.
Pallante and McGreevy will both be in the starting rotation after August 1. Fedde, Mikolas and Matz will all likely be gone, as they are pending free agents the Cards likely won’t re-sign.

+1

Posted: **29 May 2025 16:51 pm**

Carp4Cy wrote: ↑29 May 2025 16:21 pm
sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:56 pm
rockondlouie wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:52 pm
sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:41 pm No. He’s a Road Warrior. He wins on the road. Team is 4-3 in his SEVEN starts on the road. Need guys like this. If he don’t walk people he’s good. Mikolas is holding McG spot.
Not hardly BDog,

He's more like Road Kill!

McGreevy's the better option.
Not the way to do business- send a guy down who is doing his job. Through attrition and performance McG will get his. Not this way.

And his starts have been against good teams in rough locations.
Or maybe we wait a little longer then trade McGreevey for Pete Crow Armstrong, or Oneil Cruz.

Lol

Posted: **29 May 2025 16:54 pm**

McGreevy will be up at some point, but I wouldn't do anything with Pallante right now. My thought is that between someone getting injured, someone getting traded, Liberatore running out of gas (it is his first full season as a starter after all) McGreevy is going to get the call sooner or later.

Plus, Pallante is another of those "runway" guys who I would like to see be given a chance to work through his struggles.

Posted: **29 May 2025 17:48 pm**

Carp4Cy wrote: ↑29 May 2025 16:21 pm
sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:56 pm
rockondlouie wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:52 pm
sikeston bulldog2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 13:41 pm No. He’s a Road Warrior. He wins on the road. Team is 4-3 in his SEVEN starts on the road. Need guys like this. If he don’t walk people he’s good. Mikolas is holding McG spot.
Not hardly BDog,

He's more like Road Kill!

McGreevy's the better option.
Not the way to do business- send a guy down who is doing his job. Through attrition and performance McG will get his. Not this way.

And his starts have been against good teams in rough locations.
Or maybe we wait a little longer then trade McGreevey for Pete Crow Armstrong, or Oneil Cruz.

Posted: **29 May 2025 18:36 pm**

BrockFloodMaris wrote: ↑29 May 2025 16:47 pm
ICCFIM2 wrote: ↑29 May 2025 15:01 pm McGreevy is the only SP depth the Cards have as of now. Plus the team is winning. The talk of trading a SP to make a spot for McGreevy is not the right baseball decision. Sure, McGreevy deserves to be in the MLs, no argument here. But, very rarely do starting rotations make it the entire year without a starter going down. If my memory is correct, 2015 is the last year the Cards achieved that. So more likely than not, McGreevy will get his chance. Second, trading when you are winning doesn't seem like a good clubhouse move. Lets see how this plays out.
Pallante and McGreevy will both be in the starting rotation after August 1. Fedde, Mikolas and Matz will all likely be gone, as they are pending free agents the Cards likely won’t re-sign.

That would be the correct move for the team to make IMO. Along with Helsley.

Posted: **29 May 2025 18:38 pm**

I think it's too early. Put McGreevy into the race this soon may burn him out innings wise. I don't have a problem bringing him up a time or two, or in July...but now, I think, too soon.

Posted: **29 May 2025 18:42 pm**

hugeCardfan wrote: ↑29 May 2025 18:38 pm I think it's too early. Put McGreevy into the race this soon may burn him out innings wise. I don't have a problem bringing him up a time or two, or in July...but now, I think, too soon.

Huge, he is throwing six innings a game in Memphis anyway. Not that big a difference in the majors.

Posted: **29 May 2025 18:43 pm**

Pallante has earned the patience required for him to correct my current issues he's having.

Posted: **29 May 2025 18:53 pm**

MIDMOBIRDTWO wrote: ↑29 May 2025 18:42 pm
hugeCardfan wrote: ↑29 May 2025 18:38 pm I think it's too early. Put McGreevy into the race this soon may burn him out innings wise. I don't have a problem bringing him up a time or two, or in July...but now, I think, too soon.
Huge, he is throwing six innings a game in Memphis anyway. Not that big a difference in the majors.

I know. I follow duce's thread too. But, there is no urgency to pitch him every 5th day. My guess is that the wear and tear won't be as great as well. If the FO thought it would be beneficial to sit McGreevy for ten days, 2 weeks, the season consequences would be negligible in AAA.

I just don't think McGreevy has built his arm up enough over the last couple years to go straight to the majors and play out a full postseason.

Posted: **29 May 2025 18:58 pm**

imyourhuckleberry wrote: ↑29 May 2025 18:43 pm Pallante has earned the patience required for him to correct my current issues he's having.

Okay but what about HIS current issues?…

Posted: **29 May 2025 19:00 pm**

hugeCardfan wrote: ↑29 May 2025 18:53 pm
MIDMOBIRDTWO wrote: ↑29 May 2025 18:42 pm
hugeCardfan wrote: ↑29 May 2025 18:38 pm I think it's too early. Put McGreevy into the race this soon may burn him out innings wise. I don't have a problem bringing him up a time or two, or in July...but now, I think, too soon.
Huge, he is throwing six innings a game in Memphis anyway. Not that big a difference in the majors.
I know. I follow duce's thread too. But, there is no urgency to pitch him every 5th day. My guess is that the wear and tear won't be as great as well. If the FO thought it would be beneficial to sit McGreevy for ten days, 2 weeks, the season consequences would be negligible in AAA.

I just don't think McGreevy has built his arm up enough over the last couple years to go straight to the majors and play out a full postseason.

If there is anyone in the minors ready for it, it's McGreevy.

STLtoday.com

Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy

Re: Time to send Pallante down & recall McGreevy