Rank Flood, Edmonds and Siani as defensive centerfielders

[Lloyd Braun]

Flood 10.6 dWAR career
Bader 7.1 dWAR career
Edmonds 6.4 dWAR career
Bourjos 5.6 dWAR career
Rasmus 5.4 dWAR career
Tony Scott 3.5 dWAR career
Ankiel 0.8 dWAR career
McGee -1.7 dWAR career

These numbers are CF only.

But they’re weighted by the number of games they played at the position.

Surprised Edmonds was so low -didn’t he play CF well for the Angels?

Serious question. Since most of the games from Flood's career weren't televised and there is no visual record... how on earth could they assign dWAR stats?

[sikeston bulldog2]

Flood 10.6 dWAR career
Bader 7.1 dWAR career
Edmonds 6.4 dWAR career
Bourjos 5.6 dWAR career
Rasmus 5.4 dWAR career
Tony Scott 3.5 dWAR career
Ankiel 0.8 dWAR career
McGee -1.7 dWAR career

These numbers are CF only.

But they’re weighted by the number of games they played at the position.

Surprised Edmonds was so low -didn’t he play CF well for the Angels?

Serious question. Since most of the games from Flood's career weren't televised and there is no visual record... how on earth could they assign dWAR stats?

He was that good.