herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Moderators: STLtoday Forum Moderators, Cards Talk Moderators
herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
dont care where he plays but his bat has to be in the lineup...this guy can hit...he hit in the minors and he is really raking in the majors
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Él está en llamas, damas y caballeros.
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
The guy hit 300 as a rookie, he looks special not hot
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 4449
- Joined: 23 May 2024 13:01 pm
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Agree burly is hitting if need be put him in right bring in Walker as defensive replacement but Herrera needs to play every day I’m fine with him as DH and sometimes catcher and in offseason have him try to learn the corners but he needs to be in the lineup every day he won’t hit .400 but with his all fields approach and taking solid at bats he needs to play
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 473
- Joined: 17 Mar 2020 16:20 pm
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Can they quickly teach him to stand in RF, and catch fly balls?
That would be amazing
That would be amazing
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 107
- Joined: 23 May 2024 21:11 pm
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
I saw some comments about Herrera's BAPIP in GDT.
I have never loved the BAPIP means "luck" idea. How hard you hit the ball matters, and players do indeed direct the ball based on defensive positioning and where the ball is pitched.
Yes, his BAPIP is .385, but that doesn't mean he is purely lucky.
He is hitting it hard where the defense isn't, I'd suggest BAPIP is about 20% about luck.
I have never loved the BAPIP means "luck" idea. How hard you hit the ball matters, and players do indeed direct the ball based on defensive positioning and where the ball is pitched.
Yes, his BAPIP is .385, but that doesn't mean he is purely lucky.
He is hitting it hard where the defense isn't, I'd suggest BAPIP is about 20% about luck.
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
I mean you have to be lucky to an extent to be hitting over .400. No one does over an extended period of time. But say his babip regresses to .300 and he still hits. 300 wirh decent power, hes still a great hitter, hes just on a torrid streak nowSTL Cardinal Fan 24 wrote: ↑17 May 2025 02:44 am I saw some comments about Herrera's BAPIP in GDT.
I have never loved the BAPIP means "luck" idea. How hard you hit the ball matters, and players do indeed direct the ball based on defensive positioning and where the ball is pitched.
Yes, his BAPIP is .385, but that doesn't mean he is purely lucky.
He is hitting it hard where the defense isn't, I'd suggest BAPIP is about 20% about luck.
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/team/138STL Cardinal Fan 24 wrote: ↑17 May 2025 02:44 am I saw some comments about Herrera's BAPIP in GDT.
I have never loved the BAPIP means "luck" idea. How hard you hit the ball matters, and players do indeed direct the ball based on defensive positioning and where the ball is pitched.
Yes, his BAPIP is .385, but that doesn't mean he is purely lucky.
He is hitting it hard where the defense isn't, I'd suggest BAPIP is about 20% about luck.
According to statcast baseball savant page, herrera has an expected batting average of .356 vs his current .409 and an expected slg% of .756 vs his current .907
Its ultimately a small sample size but even with some extra luck, the xba and xslg% still say hes killing it right now and have expected ops well over 1.000 still.
Hes clearly locked in. However, small sample size. He will probably havw a slump at some point but im excited to see what he can do over full season.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 1683
- Joined: 23 May 2024 15:33 pm
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Regarding BABIP:
Since 1970, 1535 players have taken 2000+ PA in the majors.
Of those 1535 players, only 4 (Rod Carew, Austin Jackson, Chris Johnson, and Aaron Judge) have a BABIP greater than .350. Only 19 (about 1%) have a BABIP greater than .340. And only 75 (about 5%) even have a BABIP greater than .330.
So anybody sitting on a BABIP greater than about .330 over a small sample size is likely seeing a lot of positive "luck" in their results.
Since 1970, 1535 players have taken 2000+ PA in the majors.
Of those 1535 players, only 4 (Rod Carew, Austin Jackson, Chris Johnson, and Aaron Judge) have a BABIP greater than .350. Only 19 (about 1%) have a BABIP greater than .340. And only 75 (about 5%) even have a BABIP greater than .330.
So anybody sitting on a BABIP greater than about .330 over a small sample size is likely seeing a lot of positive "luck" in their results.
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Projecting Herrera to be a +.800 OPS type guy currently looks pretty good.
That's a potential bat worth trying to protect from the rigors of C, especially when he's not particularly good at it and the system has some good C prospects not far from their own opportunity at the show.
A plus .800 OPS guy plays anywhere his defense doesn't limit himself too much. LF would be the first place to try to expand his positional resume past being the current 3rd C and DH.
That's a potential bat worth trying to protect from the rigors of C, especially when he's not particularly good at it and the system has some good C prospects not far from their own opportunity at the show.
A plus .800 OPS guy plays anywhere his defense doesn't limit himself too much. LF would be the first place to try to expand his positional resume past being the current 3rd C and DH.
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Just not at catcher
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Of course he does. I love the way he attacks the baseball, yet hits it where it is pitched - not trying to pull everything. Hitting nearly 29% to the opposite field on contact. He is making hard contact 43% of AB this season, vs only 8.6% soft contact.
-
- Forum User
- Posts: 244
- Joined: 23 May 2024 17:01 pm
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Teaching him to stand in LF and catching fly balls with Nootbaar moving to RF would be a better plan if things continue as they are.Joseph-Magrane wrote: ↑17 May 2025 01:17 am Can they quickly teach him to stand in RF, and catch fly balls?
That would be amazing
Re: herrera clearly has to be in the lineup every day
Laughed at the headline
A Mr. Obvious moment
Wonder if a KC poster did a :
Bobby Witt Jr. clearly needs to be in the lineup every day
Don’t care if he plays 2nd or SS , he can hit !
Don’ t worry though, I have a sneaky feeling he won’t be held out from batting. DH or wherever
You wii NOT see this headline on CT
Oli benches Herrera.
tells fans he can’t find adequate position Lmao
A Mr. Obvious moment

Wonder if a KC poster did a :
Bobby Witt Jr. clearly needs to be in the lineup every day
Don’t care if he plays 2nd or SS , he can hit !
Don’ t worry though, I have a sneaky feeling he won’t be held out from batting. DH or wherever
You wii NOT see this headline on CT
Oli benches Herrera.
tells fans he can’t find adequate position Lmao